Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Monday 9 December 1996
On December 9, 1996, the Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly covered a wide range of matters, from regional economic development boards and fish and wildlife advisory councils to Hydro, Voisey's Bay copper, workers' compensation, E-911 and search and rescue. The bulk of the evening was second reading debate on Bill 48, the Schools Act revision, with Bill 27 (An Act Respecting Education) also introduced and debated, and opposition members criticising vague wording, ministerial powers and the lack of detail on school viability and busing. Notable figures included Premier Tobin, Education Minister Grimes, Opposition Leader Dr. Gibbons, Mr. Harris, Mr. Shelley and Mr. J. Byrne. The excerpt is sampled, so many exchanges are summarised only in part.
Members' Statements
Regional economic development boards
Ms Foote, Mr. Harris
The Minister of Development and Rural Renewal reported that regional economic development boards were established across the twenty zones, including a division of the Southern Avalon zone. Mr. Harris expressed concern that government could blame the boards for shortfalls in rural development funding.
Fish and wildlife advisory council and conservation stamp
Mr. Tulk, Mr. Fitzgerald
The minister announced an Inland Fish and Wildlife Advisory Council and a Conservation and Stewardship Stamp Program. Mr. Fitzgerald voiced fears that outfitters and special interest groups could price ordinary anglers off inland waterways.
Ground search and rescue organizations motion
Mr. Smith
Mr. Smith gave notice of a motion to be introduced the next day recognising ground search and rescue organizations and asking government to explore ways of assisting them, which are mainly funded by local fund-raising.
Question Period
Hydro debt collection and pension issues
Mr. Sullivan, Dr. Gibbons, Premier Tobin
The opposition asked whether government had interfered with Hydro's normal debt recovery. The Leader of the Opposition said Hydro would conduct its business as needed, and the Premier said government was not interfering with Hydro's management, including on pension issues.
Voisey's Bay copper capacity and refinery
Mr. Shelley, Dr. Gibbons, Premier Tobin
Mr. Shelley asked for a tabled tonnage-per-day copper capacity figure and whether the Premier had talked of a copper refinery in Labrador with companies other than Inco. The Minister estimated copper production and explained how the concentrate might be sold to several smelters. The Premier spoke on the Lower Churchill contract, saying it needed renegotiation but not a confrontation with Quebec.
Hospital cleaning and needle disposal at St. Clare's Hospital
Asked by Mr. French · Answered by Mr. Matthews
Mr. French asked the Health Minister about changes in practices at St. Clare's Hospital regarding disposal of used needles, following the minister's dismissal of earlier concerns about cleaning cuts.
Workers' Compensation review process
Asked by Mr. E. Byrne · Answered by Mr. K. Aylward
Mr. Byrne asked whether the minister was aware of a 1995 regulatory change allowing the commission to review decisions of the review panel, and about an injured worker whose earnings had not been reinstated. The Minister promised recommendations shortly and said the matter would come back to the House after a meeting.
E-911 emergency system
Mr. J. Byrne
Mr. J. Byrne asked whether the government still regarded an E-911 system as a priority, citing a 1995 statement by the then Municipal Affairs Minister that it would reduce response delays. He raised fire-fighter safety and rural health care.
Orders of the Day
Bill 48, An Act To Revise The Law Respecting The Operation Of Schools
Mr. Grimes, Mr. Ottenheimer, Mr. H. Hodder, Mr. Osborne, Mr. Shelley, Mr. Fitzgerald, Mr. J. Byrne, Mr. E. Byrne
Second reading debate on the schools bill. The Education Minister outlined provisions on home schooling, corporal punishment, school councils, denominational subcommittees and school property. Opposition members questioned section 10 on religious education exemptions, fee provisions, expulsion procedures, section 95 on denominational property, busing fees under section 76, and the absence of Williams Royal Commission recommendations on instructional time.
Bill 27, An Act Respecting Education, second reading
Mr. Tulk, Mr. Grimes, Mr. Harris
The bill was called for second reading. Mr. Harris criticised the failure to follow through on the Premier's commitment on federal support and asked for the 'magic number' for school viability to be set out in legislation rather than left to regulation. The Minister said the government had chosen a program-based approach and closed debate.
Other business
Human Rights Code amendment on sexual orientation
Mr. Harris
Mr. Harris presented a petition from over 250 residents asking that sexual orientation be added to the Human Rights Code, including employment benefits, and that the government act this sitting. He noted earlier NDP attempts and the federal amendment.
Points of order and House scheduling
Mr. Tulk, Mr. Harris
The Government House Leader and Mr. Harris exchanged remarks about the evening sitting and members' attendance after notice had been given that the House would sit after 5:00 p.m.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.