Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Tuesday 17 December 1996
This sitting of the House of Assembly, dated December 17, 1996, opened with question period on the province's share of federal equalization and revenues from Hibernia, Terra Nova and Voisey's Bay, and on the transshipment facility, with Premier Tobin and Leader of the Opposition Sullivan the main voices. Most of the sitting then ran late into the night, through second and third readings and clause-by-clause committee work on bills covering the HST, pensions, food donation, volunteer medals, heritage animals, criminal-history disclosure, expropriation, education and schools. Several opposition amendments were defeated, and the Government House Leader, Mr. Tulk, gave notice of a motion to force passage of the schools bill.
Question Period
Equalization and resource revenues from Hibernia, Terra Nova and Voisey's Bay
Asked by Premier Tobin · Answered by Leader of the Opposition
The Premier said he has raised with the Prime Minister the risk that rising royalty revenues will reduce equalization payments, and that Ottawa is open to discussing a catch-up period for Newfoundland. The Leader of the Opposition pressed on specific programs, and the Premier replied that the formula is national and that he had discussed a $100 million economic development program and a joint environmental assessment.
Transshipment facility deal and access to its details
Mr. Sullivan, Premier Tobin, Mr. Furey
The Leader of the Opposition asked the government to release the specifics of the transshipment facility arrangement. The Premier and Industry, Trade and Technology Minister Furey replied that all elements were made public at the announcement and that the opposition had been briefed at the department.
Labour relations working group report
Mr. E. Byrne
Mr. Byrne argued that the working group's recommendations were a compromise between business and labour, and that implementing only some of them would be harmful.
Spanish and Portuguese fishing activity
Mr. Fitzgerald
Mr. Fitzgerald asked the Fisheries Minister whether he knew of a reported 500 per cent rise in Spanish and Portuguese fishing since 1995 and what was being done about it. The exchange turned partly into personal jabs and did not produce a substantive answer in the transcript.
Other business
Harmonized sales tax (HST) and the GST/HST debate
Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Ottenheimer, Mr. Shelley, Mr. J. Byrne, Mr. E. Byrne, Mr. Fitzgerald, Mr. French, Mr. Osborne
Opposition members argued that the HST would raise costs for low- and middle-income households and cost Newfoundland about $242 million a year in sales tax revenue compared with current arrangements. They also criticized the federal government's broken GST promise and called the deal a secret arrangement. The debate was on the main motion and was interrupted by procedural calls and heckling.
Bill on pension benefits
Mr. J. Byrne
Mr. Byrne raised concerns about the future sufficiency of pensions, given demographic change, and objected that the superintendent's powers under the pension benefits bill are subject to ministerial approval, as in other recent bills.
Bill 30: Good Faith Donation and Distribution of Food Act
Mr. Fitzgerald, Mr. Tulk, Mr. Sullivan
Mr. Fitzgerald argued the bill would encourage food bank donations. Mr. Tulk moved under Standing Order 54.2(1) that the bill be referred to the Standing Committee on Social Services, with the report due before March 31, 1997.
Bill 29: Newfoundland and Labrador Volunteer Service Medal Act
Mr. H. Hodder, Mr. Sullivan, Mr. J. Byrne, Mr. Tulk
Members supported creating a medal to recognize volunteers, with a selection committee and a ten-year service threshold. Speakers praised volunteers in town councils, sports groups and community organizations. The bill was given second reading.
Bill 32: Protection of Heritage Animals Act
Mr. Sullivan, Mr. H. Hodder, Mr. Tulk
Mr. Sullivan supported protecting heritage animals such as the Newfoundland pony. Mr. Hodder asked about the penalty provisions, and Mr. Tulk explained that the Newfoundland Pony Society had not requested funding. The bill was read a second time and referred to a Committee of the Whole.
Bill 39: Release of criminal history information and amendments
Mr. Ottenheimer, Mr. J. Byrne, Mr. H. Hodder, Mr. E. Byrne, Mr. Tulk, Mr. Decker
Opposition amendments would have required disclosure to be consistent with the federal High Risk Offender Information Protocol and would have placed a three-member committee in place of the minister's decision. The first amendment was defeated and clause 1 passed. Mr. Tulk raised a procedural objection about the order of amendments.
Bill 38: Amendment to the City of St. John's Act (No. 2)
Mr. J. Byrne, Mr. Matthews, Mr. E. Byrne
Mr. Byrne disputed the minister's account of arrears owed to St. John's by surrounding towns and of the fire and rescue cost arrangements. An amendment to clause 2 was defeated, and the bill was passed without amendment.
Bill 33: Amendments to the Expropriation Act
Mr. French, Mr. J. Byrne, Mr. H. Hodder, Mr. Ottenheimer, Mr. Osborne, Mr. Shelley
Mr. French proposed amendments giving landowners a role in applications to the board and requiring the minister to act promptly in certain cases. Opposition members argued the bill gives the minister more power and shifts disputes to the Public Utilities Board, with costs and representation concerns for landowners. Debate was prolonged through the early morning hours.
Bill 36: Assessment Act and St. John's Assessment Act
Mr. Tulk
The bill was read a third time and ordered passed.
Bill 27: Education Act amendments
Mr. Ottenheimer, Mr. Sullivan
Mr. Ottenheimer moved amendments clarifying religious education courses, making the Act's commencement a date proclaimed by the Lieutenant-Governor in Council, and directing savings from consolidation to classrooms. Mr. Sullivan defended the education reform process and the referendum. Mr. Ottenheimer also questioned student-record and excusal provisions, and an amendment to clause 3 was put to a vote.
Bill 48: Act to Revise the Law Respecting the Operation of Schools
Mr. Tulk
Mr. Tulk gave notice that he would move the next day under Standing Order 50 that debate on the schools bill not be further adjourned, and that committee consideration be the first business when the House next sits. He then moved that the committee rise and report progress.
Automobile dealers, direct sellers and insurance licensing consolidation
Mr. Ottenheimer
Mr. Ottenheimer described a bill that replaces annual licensing under several acts with a one-time licence, subject to annual reports and fees, creating a registry for dealers, salespeople, direct sellers, adjusters, agents, brokers and real estate agents.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.