Hansard·Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly·Session 2, GA 43·

Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Wednesday 3 December 1997

The House of Assembly on December 3, 1997 opened with a unanimous resolution endorsing Canada's leadership on an international anti-personnel land-mine treaty, then moved through a heated Question Period on Aboriginal land claims and Conne River status, Come By Chance emissions, offshore oil safety, and IFAW donations. Members presented petitions on a vehicle tax and on Housing Corporation rent increases. Private Members' Day was devoted to a Baie Verte motion condemning the International Fund for Animal Welfare and calling for a promotional campaign to defend the seal hunt, which drew several government and opposition speakers. Premier Tobin, Opposition Leader Sullivan, and Ministers Langdon and Matthews figured prominently in the exchanges.

Read the official Hansard ↗

Routine Proceedings

Petition on taxation of used vehicle values

Mr. E. Byrne, Mr. H. Hodder, Mr. Matthews

Mr. Byrne presented a petition, signed by some thirty-five to forty residents, asking government to stop taxing vehicle values that do not reflect real worth and to remove the regulation. Mr. Hodder supported it and proposed an affidavit system. Minister Matthews said the Minister of Finance would consider the representations and that the government was reviewing the concerns.

Petition on Newfoundland and Labrador Housing Corporation rent increase

Mr. T. Osborne

Mr. Osborne presented another petition on behalf of Voices for Justice on Housing asking that a rent increase of 25 to 30 per cent on a sliding scale be reconsidered. He said the increase was hurting seniors, the working poor and single parents, and noted that the minister had asked for the decision to be put on hold.

Question Period

Conne River and Micmac land claims and Indian status

Asked by Mr. Sullivan · Answered by Premier Tobin

Opposition Leader Sullivan asked whether the Premier saw a difference between granting status to the Conne River community and withholding it from other Micmac communities that met registration requirements. The Premier replied that the opposition could not have it both ways and asked which communities the opposition meant, naming several towns and questioning whether they should be settled through land claims.

Emissions from Come By Chance and comparison with British Columbia

Mr. J. Byrne, Premier Tobin, Mr. T. Osborne

The Premier said the minister had taken steps to cut emissions from Come By Chance by 14,000 tonnes a year. He argued that Newfoundland and Labrador differs from British Columbia because it has an offshore oil and gas industry. Mr. Osborne responded that the Province needs emergency preparedness measures for a disaster.

Occupational health and safety standards for offshore oil and gas

Asked by Mr. E. Byrne · Answered by Mr. Langdon

Mr. Byrne asked whether Occupational Health and Safety regulations for the offshore were still only in draft form and when they would become law, citing recent evacuations from the Bill Shoemaker rig and from Terra Nova. Minister Langdon said draft regulations were in place and under work with the C-NOPB, cited a drill he had observed on a rig, and said the Premier and he had been invited to visit the rig.

Speaker's ruling on tabling documents by private members

Mr. Speaker

The Speaker reminded a member that private members have no right to table documents in the House, citing long-standing precedent after the member had attempted to do so during Question Period.

Point of order on relevance of the Premier's answer

Asked by Mr. H. Hodder · Answered by Premier Tobin

Mr. Hodder raised a point of order, arguing that the Premier's answer on forestry, IT, biotechnology and Terra Nova was irrelevant to the question asked by the Member for Bonavista South. The Premier replied that his answer was as relevant as the question.

Alleged IFAW donations to the Premier

Asked by Mr. Fitzgerald · Answered by Premier Tobin

Mr. Fitzgerald asked whether the Premier had ever personally accepted a political donation from the IFAW or had one made to an account he controlled. The Premier denied ever accepting such a donation and challenged the member to make the allegation formally, calling it rumour-mongering otherwise.

Pelletization plant at Labrador City and Iron Ore Company of Canada

Mr. Furey

Mr. Furey, the Member for Baie Verte, reported meeting the President of the Iron Ore Company of Canada with the Member for Labrador West. They discussed a Bechtel study on a new pelletization plant, possible reactivation of the Sept-Îles plant, and pelletizing future requirements at Labrador City with inexpensive power to keep the jobs in the Province.

Private Members' Business

Private Members' motion condemning IFAW and supporting the seal hunt

Mr. Shelley, Mr. Andersen, Mr. Fitzgerald, Mr. G. Reid, Ms Jones, Mr. Speaker

Mr. Shelley moved the Baie Verte motion condemning the IFAW, rejecting its portrayal of the seal hunt as cruel, and calling on both levels of government to run a joint promotional campaign. Members spoke in support, citing economic and cultural importance to rural and Aboriginal communities. Mr. G. Reid, while supporting the motion, cautioned against a high-profile campaign and against announcing quota increases, and defended a Twillingate harvester he said had been wrongly portrayed in a doctored broadcast clip. Ms Jones described a feasibility study underway in her district for a commercial seal fishery. The motion was put and approved.

Other business

Resolution endorsing Canada's leadership on an anti-personnel land-mine treaty

Premier Tobin

The Premier moved a resolution, noting that Canada was hosting an international conference of over 100 countries expected to sign a treaty banning anti-personnel mines. The House was asked to unanimously endorse Canada's leadership and urge other nations to follow, and members responded with approval.

This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.