Hansard·Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly·Session 3, GA 43·

Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Thursday 28 May 1998

The sitting in May 1998 covered fisheries, with ministerial statements on the cod and crab season and a sharp exchange over the seal hunt, and a debate on the 1998 Budget that included Government Services and Social Services Committee concurrence motions. Question period raised political interference in the Vista School District, chemotherapy waiting times, the Labrador Metis land claim, Coast Guard and federal transfer cuts, and youth internship funding. Several members, including Efford, Harris, Hodder, Jones, Shelley and Osborne, were prominent, and the Speaker reserved a ruling on unparliamentary language.

Read the official Hansard ↗

Question Period

Coast Guard funding cuts and federal transfer reductions

Mr. E. Byrne, Mr. Dicks, Mr. Speaker

Byrne asked the Finance Minister to contact the federal department about funding clawed back from the Coast Guard. Dicks said he had raised the cuts repeatedly, cited CHST falling from over $400 million to about $280 million, and reported that provinces had agreed in principle to a population floor for equalization.

Political interference in the Vista School District decision

Asked by Mr. H. Hodder · Answered by Ms Kelly

Hodder charged that the Premier's parliamentary assistant politically interfered in the Vista board's school-configuration decision and asked why the government had not supported the board's original two-school recommendation. The acting Education Minister replied that the elected board made the decision and the government supported it; the exchange drew points of order and calls for order.

Chemotherapy patients' waiting-time policy in St. John's

Asked by Mr. Sullivan · Answered by Ms J.M. Aylward

Sullivan asked the Health Minister to have a hospital policy changed so chemotherapy patients would not wait hours for service. The minister said she had met the board and raised the issue, but that boards are autonomous and make their own practice decisions.

Labrador Metis land claim and the federal Justice opinion

Ms Jones

Jones asked the government about the political fallout and protection of rights of about 5,000 Labrador Metis after a federal Justice opinion found the claim had not been established. She asked whether the province would intervene on their behalf, and she also argued for Aboriginal seal-netting rights.

Federal HRDC cuts to youth internship and co-operative high school programs

Ms Bettney

The St. John's West minister said she and the Education Minister had made representations to federal HRDC in support of the Youth Internship Program and co-operative high school programs. Officials were meeting regional HRDC staff, with results expected the following week.

French language program spending

Ms S. Osborne

Osborne asked how many positions and students were covered by $190,000 spent on French language salaries in 1997-98 and $247,000 proposed for 1998-99. She said her questions had been answered with patronizing remarks and demanded written answers.

Orders of the Day

Concurrence motion on the Government Services Committee report and 1998 Budget debate

Mr. Tulk, Mr. Wiseman, Mr. J. Byrne, Mr. Speaker

Wiseman moved the Government Services report, defended the 1998 Budget as balanced and as directing money to education, health and the Trans-Labrador Highway, and claimed the previous administration had spent without restraint. J. Byrne replied at length, disputing the record, and then adjourned debate until 7:00 p.m.

Concurrence motion on the Social Services Committee report

Mr. Mercer, Mr. J. Byrne, Mr. Shelley, Mr. Speaker

The Government House Leader moved the Social Services Committee concurrence and praised its work. Opposition members used the debate to criticize education cuts and the Eagan arbitration appeal, and the House later concurred in the report.

Education funding cuts and teaching profession

Mr. J. Byrne, Mr. Shelley

Byrne said education facilities spending falls from about $41 million to about $24 million, disputing the government's claim of increased education funding. Shelley urged that sports, arts and extracurricular programs be protected and praised teachers through reform.

Labrador energy: diesel-plant rates and the Lower Churchill transmission route

Ms Jones, Mr. Speaker

Jones said residents of diesel-served communities pay the highest power rates and that Lower Churchill transmission could benefit Coastal Labrador. She proposed routing the line along the Trans-Labrador Highway and noted possible tourism and transportation benefits.

Sunday shopping and family life

Ms S. Osborne

Osborne read a constituent letter complaining that Sunday shopping had removed family time for a shift worker and that store hours had grown beyond the original 12-to-5 Sunday limit. She cited it as evidence against the policy.

Public Tender Act changes, water export and oil-spill response

Mr. T. Osborne

Osborne welcomed some government changes to the Public Tender Act, said others recommended by the Opposition were still outstanding, and raised concerns about water export and oil-spill response capacity, which he said would take 72 hours to assemble. He adjourned debate for the evening.

Other business

Ministerial statement on the 1998 cod and groundfish season, and the 3Ps cod quota

Mr. Efford, Mr. Fitzgerald, Mr. Harris, Mr. Sullivan

The Fisheries Minister outlined the season's crab and shrimp start, plant employment and quality-assurance concerns, and the opposition questioned what had changed since last year's dumping of 3Ps fish. The federal 20,000-tonne 3Ps cod quota was welcomed, but Sullivan argued it was too small to justify harvesters gearing up for a short fishery.

Newfoundland and Labrador Agriculture Awareness Campaign

Mr. K. Aylward, Mr. Harris, Mr. Fitzgerald

The Minister of Forestry and Agrifoods announced a joint provincial-federal campaign to raise public awareness of the agriculture sector, citing farm sales of a record $74 million. Harris argued the government should pursue the sector more aggressively given its value relative to the fishery.

Getting the Message Out CD-ROM and access to technology

Mr. Tulk, Mr. Shelley, Mr. Harris, Mr. Dicks

The Minister of Development presented a CD-ROM on economic achievements, to be updated regularly and distributed to members and the press. Shelley raised red tape faced by young entrepreneurs, and Harris questioned how many residents could afford the computer needed to run it.

Seal hunt and comparisons with other countries

Mr. Efford, Mr. Harris, Mr. Tulk

Efford defended the provincial seal cull and compared it with culls elsewhere, while Harris said his comments were damaging the province's seal industry. Efford's remarks about a former MHA drew objections and withdrawal, and the Speaker said he would review Hansard on the unparliamentary words used.

This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.