Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Wednesday 21 March 2001
The House spent much of the sitting on Voisey's Bay nickel processing, mainly through Question Period and a private member's resolution from the St. John's East MHA, Mr. Ottenheimer, which was defeated on a recorded vote. Premier Grimes, the Leader of the Opposition, Mr. E. Byrne, and several government and opposition members debated whether the government's position on shipping ore out of the Province matched its 1999 platform. Other matters included the Marystown shipyard and Friede Goldman financing, Atlantic Co-operative Alliance (ACA) and Country Ribbon chicken production, shrimp exports to the European Union, a home care workers' petition, and ministerial statements on World Water Day and the Women's Policy Office. The sitting ended with the House adjourned to Thursday at 2:00 p.m., and the transcript notes that the Budget was due the following day.
Members' Statements
Ministerial statement on fish price negotiations
Mr. Reid, Mr. Harris, Mr. Taylor
The Minister of Fisheries and Aquaculture reported that shrimp and cod prices had been set for April to June and that negotiations for other species would begin in early April. The opposition raised concerns about the processing and marketing of lump roe, industrial shrimp and crab, and the Final Offer Selection Process was defended as a process developed with the fishing unions.
Ministerial statement on World Water Day and drinking water
Mr. Ralph Wiseman, Mr. T. Osborne
The Minister of Environment and Conservation marked World Water Day and announced a drinking water workshop in Gander for March 26 and 27. The critic responded that more than talk was needed, citing boil-water orders in more than 200 communities and sewage discharges into rivers.
Ministerial statement on the Women's Policy Office document
Ms Kelly, Mr. Harris
The minister responsible for the status of women thanked the Women's Policy Office and community groups for a document on equality. The St. John's West MHA praised the document but asked why the government had not moved to add source of income as a prohibited ground under the provincial Human Rights Code.
Member's statement on a sixtieth wedding anniversary
Mr. Taylor
The Member for Bonavista South congratulated Andrew and Tamer Canning of Roddickton on their sixtieth wedding anniversary.
Routine Proceedings
Home care workers' wages and petition
Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Collins
The Opposition House Leader presented petitions from home care workers seeking higher wages, saying they were earning below the poverty line and that the Budget should bring a significant increase. The Member for Labrador West said the workers should also be covered by workers' compensation or a similar insurance program.
Setting up committees (Motion 5)
Mr. Lush
The Government House Leader asked members to pass Motion 5, which would set up the committees read into the record the previous day, so that next week's debate could proceed. The Speaker then returned to petitions, and the motion was put with members assenting.
Question Period
Voisey's Bay ore shipment and the government's 1999 mandate in Question Period
Mr. E. Byrne, Premier Grimes, Mr. Fitzgerald
The Leader of the Opposition challenged the Premier on whether shipping unprocessed ore out of the Province matched the 1999 mandate and on comments by the former Minister of Mines and Energy. The Premier replied that the Liberal objective had always been to have the nickel processed in the Province and that the government would find a way to achieve it.
Marystown shipyard and Friede Goldman financing
Asked by Mr. Fitzgerald · Answered by Mr. Tulk
The Member for Bonavista North asked whether the government would finance vessel construction at Marystown, through loan guarantees, grants or deferral or cancellation of the $10 million to $15 million Friede Goldman owes the Province. The Minister of Industry, Trade and Rural Development said the question deserved a serious answer and that the comment was unbecoming.
ACA, IPL and Country Ribbon chicken production
Mr. Hunter, Mr. Woodford, Mr. Collins
Opposition members asked whether there was an enforceable guarantee that Country Ribbon chicken production would not move out of the Province, and where the poultry growth commitment from the write-off of an ACA debt now stood. The Minister of Forest Resources and Agrifoods said the dispute was between a private company and its unionized workers, that compliance levels were being met, and that he would table the agreements if nothing in them prohibited it.
Shrimp exports and the European Union tariff
Asked by Mr. Taylor · Answered by Mr. Reid
The Member for The Straits & White Bay North asked what steps the minister had taken to have the federal government negotiate with the European Union over the import tariff on Canadian shrimp. The minister, who had earlier given a statement on fish price negotiations, was asked to respond.
Opening Question Period exchange on Voisey's Bay and the Member for Port de Grave
Asked by Mr. E. Byrne · Answered by Premier Grimes
The Leader of the Opposition asked whether the Premier had met with the Member for Port de Grave, who had said he did not clearly understand the Premier's position. The Premier responded that the Leader of the Opposition was trying to manipulate the truth and restated the government's objective of having nickel made in the Province.
Private Members' Business
Private member's resolution on Voisey's Bay and the government's mandate
Mr. Ottenheimer, Premier Grimes, Mr. E. Byrne, Mr. Ross Wiseman, Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Harris, Mr. Matthews, Mr. Manning
The St. John's East MHA moved a resolution arguing the government lacked a mandate to govern because its Voisey's Bay position had shifted from the 1999 Red Book commitments. Government members argued the platform had been kept and that negotiations were starting afresh, while opposition members pressed for the terms of any deal to be tabled. The House defeated the motion on a recorded vote.
Other business
Adjournment
Mr. Speaker
The Speaker declared the private member's motion defeated and adjourned the House until Thursday at 2:00 p.m.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.