Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Tuesday 13 April 2004
On April 13, 2004, the House dealt mainly with the ongoing public sector strike, the Labrador marine service decision, and the 2004 Budget, which members debated at length. The Speaker also ruled on a point of order about recognizing visitors in the galleries, finding no procedural irregularity in the matter raised. Notable speakers included Premier Williams, Opposition members Grimes, Jones and Harris, and Ministers Rideout and Ottenheimer, and the House adjourned until a Private Members' Day debate on 5 Wing Goose Bay.
Members' Statements
Member's statement congratulating the Randell family
Ms Thistle
Ms Thistle congratulated a Grand Falls-Windsor family on receiving black belts in Tae Kwon Do.
Routine Proceedings
Petition on Labrador School Board director salaries
Mr. Hickey
Mr. Hickey presented a petition from Lake Melville residents asking the minister to reduce Labrador School Board directors' salaries to the approved scales. The petition cited the 1997 Auditor General report and provisions of the Schools Act.
Petition presented by Ms Jones on Labrador marine services
Ms Jones
Ms Jones presented a petition on Labrador marine services and argued in support of it, describing the Memorial University study and its consultations. Her petition was to be tabled rather than read in full.
Question Period
Public sector strike and negotiations
Mr. Grimes, Premier Williams, Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Harris
The Opposition asked why government would not meet the unions face to face to end the strike, now in its thirteenth day. The Premier said government had made an offer that the unions had not answered, while the Finance Minister denied government had any plan to change pension entitlements.
Labrador marine service and freight routing decision
Mr. Andersen, Mr. Rideout, Ms Jones
The Opposition criticized the government's decision to raise North Coast Labrador shipping rates and to change the freight service out of Cartwright and Lewisporte. The Transportation Minister defended the decision as improving frequency and service for Labrador communities.
Orders of the Day
Budget debate: Labrador marine services and Labrador transportation funding
Ms Jones, Mr. Rideout, Mr. Parsons
Ms Jones argued that the government broke a commitment to honour the Memorial University consultants' recommendation, which favoured Cartwright, and criticized the Budget's forest access road spending in Labrador. Mr. Rideout replied that the government had the right to take a different decision, and the Opposition House Leader urged the minister to consider rural needs in the Western Newfoundland service realignment.
Budget debate: school consolidation and Western Newfoundland school projects
Mr. Joyce, Mr. Ottenheimer
Mr. Joyce said a North Shore school expansion in the Budget was already under way and urged action on Herdman Collegiate. Mr. Ottenheimer, the Minister of Education, described the consolidation of school boards into new districts and gave enrolment figures showing declines over recent decades.
Budget debate: health care, drug coverage and rural economy
Ms Jones, Mr. Rideout
Ms Jones criticized the Budget for omitting Alzheimer's drug funding and for not addressing expected health care changes, and she said rural economic growth was weaker under the current government. Mr. Rideout replied that ministers would defend their decisions.
Budget debate: public sector wage offer and economic outlook
Mr. Harris
Mr. Harris criticized the government's wage offer of zero, zero, two and two per cent over four years, saying it would mean a real wage decrease under the PricewaterhouseCoopers inflation projections. He also questioned the report's negative assumptions on debt, federal transfers and oil revenue.
Maiden speech of Mr. Denine
Mr. Denine, Mr. Grimes, Mr. Barrett
Mr. Denine, the Member for Mount Pearl, gave his maiden speech defending the Budget, including low-income tax relief and a supported employment program. Mr. Barrett responded critically, accusing the government of misrepresenting layoffs and road spending.
Budget debate: roads, tourism and small business in Trinity-Bay de Verde
Ms Johnson
Ms Johnson welcomed Budget measures for her district, including the low-income tax reduction, road funding, tourism marketing, a Department of Business, and broadband expansion.
Budget debate: Labrador West infrastructure and services
Mr. Collins
Mr. Collins said the Budget did little for Labrador West, citing poor highway conditions, the need for a new hospital in Labrador West, air ambulance policy and the loss of early French Immersion. He also welcomed the announced return of ferry service to Goose Bay.
Other business
Speaker's ruling on recognition of visitors in the galleries
Mr. Speaker
The Speaker ruled on a point of order from the Opposition House Leader about ministers greeting visitors in the galleries. He said recognition of gallery visitors is the Speaker's prerogative, though ministers have sometimes done so in the past.
Ministerial statement on Environmental Awards nominations
Mr. T. Osborne, Mr. Harris
Mr. Osborne announced that nominations were open for the Fifteenth Annual Newfoundland and Labrador Environmental Awards. Mr. Harris welcomed the program and said his district would nominate candidates.
Adjournment and next sitting
Mr. E. Byrne, Mr. Speaker
Mr. Byrne moved adjournment and announced that the next day, a Private Members' Day, would include a debate on a motion from the Member for Lake Melville about the future of 5 Wing Goose Bay. The House then adjourned until 2:00 p.m. the next day.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.