Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Thursday 5 May 2005
The House marked the federal Year of the Veteran with ministerial and member tributes and a tree-planting ceremony, then heard members' statements on athletic and student achievements. Oral Question Period was dominated by the crab raw-material sharing dispute, the St. Anthony licence and the FFAW impasse, with the Opposition also pressing on OxyContin abuse and health waiting times. The afternoon ended with Committee of Supply debate on the Budget, which included exchanges over a caucus expulsion of the Member for Placentia & St. Mary's, and the House adjourned to Monday, May 9.
Members' Statements
Member statements: St. Francis Crusaders provincial basketball championship
Mr. Sweeney
Mr. Sweeney congratulated the St. Francis Crusaders on winning the provincial midget basketball championship, noting Victoria Ralph was named tournament MVP.
Member statements: Premier's Athletic Awards for Terra Nova athletes
Mr. Oram
Mr. Oram congratulated three athletes from his district, Samantha Ralph, Renee White and Sasha Wilkins, on receiving Premier's Athletic Awards for training support.
Member statements: Gurpreet Sohi and public speaking
Mr. Langdon
Mr. Langdon recognised Gurpreet Sohi of John Watkins Academy for winning the provincial Lions speak-out and advancing to a competition in Halifax on May 14.
Routine Proceedings
Health services petition and Hay Group report
Ms Jones, Ms Johnson
Ms Jones presented a petition on health service cuts, saying the Hay Group report recommendations were presumed to apply and asking for a government response. Ms Johnson said discussions on roadwork were under way and announcements would follow.
Question Period
Crab raw-material sharing and the St. Anthony processing licence
Asked by Mr. Grimes · Answered by Mr. Taylor
Mr. Grimes asked whether the minister had to guarantee John Risley crab in order to open the St. Anthony plant, and questioned the quota figures given the plant's zero three-year average. Mr. Taylor replied that a court order required reconsideration of a patently unreasonable 2003 decision, and that government controls processing through conditional licences.
Impact of the St. Anthony licence on other plants and workers
Asked by Mr. Grimes · Answered by Mr. Taylor
Mr. Grimes argued that crab taken from other plants would hurt their workers. Mr. Taylor said he had never claimed no impact, and put the provincial effect at about 3 per cent while Northern Peninsula processing would rise from about 1.25 million to 4.2 million pounds.
FFAW impasse and the Sunday meeting request
Mr. Harris, Mr. Taylor, Mr. Grimes
Mr. Harris asked why the minister had not met FFAW and processor representatives on Sunday to resolve the impasse. Mr. Taylor said he had been told of a discussion in progress and that a Labour Relations Agency contact had been made, and he drew a rebuke from the Speaker over ministerial titles and commentary.
Plant worker concerns and government commitments
Asked by Ms Burke · Answered by Mr. Taylor
Minister Burke said she had met a group of plant workers earlier in the week and had made commitments to follow through on action plans. Mr. Taylor said funding to help affected plant workers had been promised by the Premier.
Rural fishing communities and the raw-material sharing plan
Ms Dunderdale
Minister Dunderdale said concern for rural and fishing communities drove the raw-material sharing plan.
OxyContin abuse and related law enforcement problems
Asked by Ms Jones · Answered by Mr. Sullivan
Ms Jones asked when government would act on the OxyContin task force recommendations and cited pharmacists refusing prescriptions, break-ins and criminal activity in St. John's and Grand Falls. Mr. Sullivan, as Acting Minister of Health, responded to the questions, though the transcript records that portion only in fragments.
Emergency and outpatient waiting times in Gander
Ms Jones
Ms Jones asked whether the Health minister was aware of waiting-time problems in emergency and outpatient services at Gander hospitals and what action was being taken.
Orders of the Day
Budget 2005-06 Estimates and Committee of Supply
Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Grimes, Mr. Rideout, Mr. Speaker
The Lieutenant Governor's message transmitted the Estimates for the year ending March 31, 2006, and the House resolved into Committee of Supply. A procedural dispute over whose turn it was to speak followed, with Mr. Rideout arguing the rotation began afresh, and the committee later reported progress and was ordered to sit again.
Budget announcements and federal Atlantic Accord prepayment
Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Harris
Mr. Sullivan cited a credit rating upgrade to BBB high, credited the $2 billion Atlantic Accord prepayment, and listed tourism marketing rising to $8 million, $500,000 for the Labrador Winter Games and $113 million for health care. Mr. Harris disputed his account of how the federal Budget treatment of the Accord would be handled.
Tourism, parks and environment budget items
Mr. Oram, Mr. T. Osborne
Mr. Oram praised Budget tourism spending, including the extra $1 million for marketing, $100,000 a year for Destination Labrador and extended visitor centre seasons. Mr. T. Osborne described recycling and waste diversion programs in Lewisporte, Mount Pearl and Corner Brook, contaminated site cleanups and $250,000 for provincial parks.
Caucus expulsion of the Member for Placentia & St. Mary's
Mr. Joyce, Mr. Grimes
Mr. Joyce criticised the removal of the Member for Placentia & St. Mary's from caucus and questioned the Minister of Innovation, Trade and Rural Development on FPI profits, which drew disputes over sexist language and withdrawals. Mr. Grimes said the member had been pressured to choose between himself and the Premier and that caucus was divided.
Crab licence hardship for Burin Peninsula workers
Mr. Grimes, Mr. Wiseman, Mr. Reid
Mr. Grimes described a Burin Peninsula couple denied social assistance because they were deemed to be on strike, and said plant workers were not on strike but refusing to fish under the new system. Mr. Wiseman and Mr. Reid disputed the characterisation of his remarks, and Mr. Wiseman withdrew a comment calling a member a liar.
VLT and electronic gambling expansion
Mr. Collins
Mr. Collins criticised Atlantic Lotto for bringing electronic machines into bars, calling it hypocritical given efforts to control gambling. He cited a Nova Scotia committee record in which an expert warned against electronic Keno.
Other business
Year of the Veteran 2005
Mr. T. Marshall, Mr. Grimes, Mr. Harris, Mr. Speaker
Minister Marshall announced the federal designation of 2005 as the Year of the Veteran and described a tree-planting ceremony at Confederation Building attended by veterans. Mr. Grimes and Mr. Harris spoke for their parties in thanks, and the Speaker welcomed the guests in the galleries.
Adjournment motions and sitting schedule
Mr. Rideout, Mr. Grimes
Mr. Rideout moved under Standing Order 11 that the House not adjourn at 5:30 p.m. or 10:00 p.m. on Monday, May 9, then moved that the House adjourn until that day at 1:30 p.m. Mr. Grimes noted that several more hours of Budget debate remained.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.