Hansard·Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly·Session 3, GA 45·

Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Tuesday 21 November 2006

The House opened with members' statements honouring a child and youth care worker, Duke of Edinburgh Bronze Award recipients, and a fallen Burgeo soldier, followed by a tourism statement and responses. Question period centred on the $15 million fibre optic deal with Persona, which the Opposition Leader and Grand Bank critic challenged against the EWA consultant's report, and on home heating fuel rebates for low-income households. Orders of the Day included first reading of Bill 46, passage of Bill 35, committee work on Bill 23, and second reading debates on Bill 43 (Vital Statistics Act fees) and Bill 40 (Public Inquiries Act), where opposition members pressed for fee reductions and for a public inquiry into the fibre optic deal.

Read the official Hansard ↗

Members' Statements

Members' statement on Jenny McGrath's national child and youth care award

Mr. Forsey

Mr. Forsey congratulated Jenny McGrath of Bishop's Falls on receiving the 2006 National Child and Youth Care Worker award, noting her work, her education and her move to teach in Alberta.

Members' statement on Duke of Edinburgh's Bronze Award recipients

Mr. Sweeney

Mr. Sweeney congratulated five young people from Carbonear-Harbour Grace on earning the Duke of Edinburgh's Bronze Award, describing the program's aims.

Members' statement remembering Sergeant Vaughan Ingram

Mr. Parsons

Mr. Parsons paid tribute to Sergeant Vaughan Ingram of Burgeo, killed in Afghanistan, and described the funeral and memorial ceremonies and his earlier wounding, asking members to join in honouring him.

Ministerial statement on tourism marketing initiatives

Mr. Hedderson, Mr. Andersen, Mr. R. Collins

The Minister of Tourism, Culture and Recreation outlined increased tourism marketing funding, a new tourism website due in January 2007, a smaller travel guide and a resident campaign. Mr. Andersen welcomed the announcement, while Mr. R. Collins called for action on Labrador tourism, snowmobile funding and outfitters' losses from caribou zones.

Routine Proceedings

Petition on washroom and waiting facilities at the Burgeo-Ramea ferry terminal

Mr. Parsons

Mr. Parsons presented a petition from Ramea residents seeking washroom and waiting room facilities at the Burgeo ferry terminal, noting earlier requests to the transportation department had gone unanswered.

Question Period

Fibre optic deal with Persona and the EWA consultant's report

Mr. Reid, Mr. Taylor, Premier Williams, Ms Foote

The Opposition Leader questioned whether the Electronic Warfare Associates report supported the $15 million taxpayer contribution, noting the report's limits on assessing Persona's solvency and quantifying benefits. The Minister of Innovation, Trade and Rural Development defended the business case, described the government's meetings with consortium representatives, and said the report would be tabled after ATIP screening. The Premier cited claimed health, education and economic benefits, and Ms Foote asked how the consortium's rate of return was judged modest.

Home heating fuel rebates and support for low-income households

Asked by Ms Michael · Answered by Mr. Sullivan

Ms Michael said the government was behind last year's timing on heating fuel rebates, cited high energy poverty in the Province, and asked what help low-income households would receive and why HST was not removed from heating fuel. The Government House Leader responded that the government had expanded low-income supports, including social assistance and heating supplements, and said removing HST would benefit higher-income people as well.

Orders of the Day

Bill 35, An Act To Amend The Notaries Public Act

Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Fitzgerald

The Committee of the Whole considered Bill 35 and reported it without amendment. The House then gave it third reading and passed it.

Bill 46, An Act To Amend The Provincial Court Act, 1991

Mr. Sullivan

With leave, the government introduced Bill 46 at first reading so it could be circulated. The House carried the motion, and second reading was set for the following day.

Bill 23, An Act To Establish A Health Research Ethics Authority, committee stage

Ms Jones, Mr. Sullivan

In committee, Ms Jones asked about amendments the minister had reportedly discussed with the NDP leader but which she had not yet seen. The Chair had the amendments passed to the Table for review, and the committee then rose, reported progress and asked leave to sit again.

Bill 43, An Act To Amend The Vital Statistics Act, second reading

Ms Whalen, Mr. Sweeney, Ms Michael, Mr. Reid, Mr. Parsons, Ms Jones, Ms Thistle, Mr. Butler

The Minister of Government Services said the bill would let the minister, rather than Cabinet, set the fee paid to clergy and others who register births and deaths, raising it from $20 to $50 per hundred events. Opposition members argued that birth and death fees should be eliminated or reduced, pointed to other fee increases, and questioned how fee revenue was spent. Mr. Parsons asked whether the rate was being increased, and the Chair urged members to keep debate to the principles of the bill.

Bill 40, An Act To Revise The Law Respecting The Conduct Of Public Inquiries, second reading

T. Marshall, Mr. Parsons

The Minister of Justice introduced the bill to replace the 1990 Public Inquiries Act, adding a lighter-weight inquiry option under Part II and provisions on witness and participant rights. Mr. Parsons, responding for the Opposition, argued that a public inquiry was needed to examine the fibre optic deal, questioned the consultant's expertise, and said the Auditor General lacked access to Cabinet information.

This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.