Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Thursday 4 December 2008
On December 4, 2008, the House of Assembly heard members' statements on community groups, a memorial for the victims of the 1989 Montreal massacre, and Christmas Lights Across Canada, then spent most of Question Period on mill and mine closures, the economic downturn, and waste management. Opposition members, led by Ms Jones and Mr. Kelvin Parsons, pressed Ministers Dunderdale, Whalen and Jackman and Premier Williams on Grand Falls-Windsor, Wabush, IOC and Voisey's Bay. The House also moved four bills through first reading, gave second reading to Bills 55, 57, 58 and 61, and adjourned after debate on Bill 49 (Securities Act) was left open.
Members' Statements
Christmas Lights Across Canada ceremony
Mr. Taylor, Mr. Butler, Ms Michael
Mr. Taylor invited members and the public to the evening lighting ceremony at Confederation Building, which uses LED lights and thirteen symbolic trees. Mr. Butler and Ms Michael welcomed the event and
Routine Proceedings
Petition for a long-term care facility in the Carbonear area
Mr. Butler
Mr. Butler presented petitions from Shearstown, Makinsons, Clarke's Beach and Carbonear asking for a new long-term care facility, saying the existing facilities have outlived their useful life.
Introduction and first reading of Bills 50, 63, 64 and 68
Mr. Speaker, Clerk (MacKenzie), Ms Burke
Leave was granted for four bills to be introduced: Bill 50 (Provincial Court Act amendment), Bill 63 (Management of Information Act), Bill 64 (Rooms Act), and Bill 68 (House of Assembly Accountability, Integrity and Administration Act No. 2). Each was read a first time and ordered read a second time the next day.
Notice of Bill 70: Newfoundland and Labrador Research and Development Council
Mr. Taylor
On behalf of the Minister of Innovation, Trade and Rural Development, Mr. Taylor gave notice that leave would be sought to introduce a bill establishing the Research and Development Council.
Tabling of the 2007-2008 Mineral Licences, Mining Leases and Surface Leases report
Ms Dunderdale
Ms Dunderdale tabled the Department of Natural Resources' annual report on mineral licences, mining leases and surface leases for 2007-2008.
Question Period
Grand Falls-Windsor pulp and paper mill closure and supports for workers
Asked by Ms Jones · Answered by Ms Dunderdale
Ms Jones asked what the government had offered to keep the Abitibi-Bowater mill open and what retraining and support was planned. Ms Dunderdale outlined the province's energy arrangements and $11 million in support over three years, said a task force had been in place for three months, and blamed the company's position for the closure.
Economic downturn, job losses and call for an all-party economic summit
Mr. Kelvin Parsons, Premier Williams, Ms Michael
Mr. Kelvin Parsons listed recent shutdowns at Wabush, IOC, Voisey's Bay and other firms and asked the Premier to chair an all-party economic summit. Premier Williams defended the government's response, citing the Cabinet's work and the Grand Falls task force, and said spending would continue. Ms Michael asked what concrete steps would mitigate the crisis.
Hebron project and Voisey's Bay and IOC shutdown impacts
Asked by Mr. Kelvin Parsons · Answered by Ms Dunderdale
Ms Dunderdale said the Hebron project was proceeding on schedule with no planned changes. On Voisey's Bay, she said a July shutdown was expected to have no financial impact because of a rotation and holiday arrangement. On IOC, she said the government did not yet know the financial effect on temporary and part-time workers.
Waste management strategy, Robin Hood Bay and municipal tipping fees
Ms Jones, Ms Whalen, Mr. Jackman
Ms Jones raised the cost burden on towns such as Holyrood that now truck garbage to Robin Hood Bay, and asked about the status of the Greater Avalon program and use of MMSB's $11 million reserve for recycling. Ms Whalen cited a $200 million investment, and Mr. Jackman said the strategy would build engineered landfills and that the money was not sitting idle.
Orders of the Day
Bill 55: Repeal of the Homes for Special Care Act
Mr. Wiseman, Ms Jones, Ms Michael
The Minister of Health and Community Services said the 1973 act no longer applied because children are now served through regional health authorities and other programs. Ms Jones and Ms Michael raised wider concerns about foster care, home care costs, residential therapeutic care and housing for people with disabilities, and Ms Michael said the act's repeal was linked to responsibilities taken on when institutions closed. The motion carried at second reading.
Bill 61: An Act Respecting the Practice of Dentistry
Mr. Wiseman, Ms Jones, Ms Michael
Mr. Wiseman moved second reading, saying the bill strengthens governance and discipline by creating a Dental Board with investigative powers. Ms Jones said the Opposition would support it and raised dental recruitment and children's access to care. Ms Michael urged coverage for repairing teeth, not only extracting them, for people on social assistance. The bill was read a second time and referred to a Committee of the Whole.
Bill 57: Repeal of the Private Homes for Special Care Allowances Act
Mr. Wiseman
Mr. Wiseman said the repeal removes a statute with no further application, as income and support programs now cover individuals in care arrangements. The bill was read a second time and carried.
Bill 58: Repeal of the Venereal Disease Prevention Act and HPV vaccination
Mr. Kelvin Parsons, Ms Michael, Mr. Wiseman
The repeal was supported because the old act covers only four diseases and the Communicable Diseases Act is more current. Mr. Kelvin Parsons described the school HPV vaccination program. Ms Michael questioned the rapid federal funding, asked for full information for parents, and urged more Pap smear awareness. Mr. Wiseman said the decision followed public health advice, and the bill carried.
Bill 49: An Act to Amend the Securities Act
Mr. O'Brien, Mr. Kelvin Parsons
Mr. O'Brien described the amendments as harmonizing securities rules and adding clarity for investors. Mr. Kelvin Parsons spoke on securities regulation, the U.S. sub-prime crisis and the local economic effects, and debate was left open when the House adjourned.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.