Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Thursday 14 May 2009
The House debated several bills at second reading and in Committee of the Whole, including amendments to the Student Financial Assistance Act, the Legal Aid Act, the Tobacco Control Act, the Pharmacy Act, and the Research and Development Council Act, plus a new chiropractic bill. Members also took up oral questions on child protection staffing and on silviculture work for laid-off forestry workers, and a ministerial statement on the craft sector. Several bills moved to committee or were reported without amendment, and the sitting ran late into the night, with a recess and a 7:00 p.m. resumption along the way.
Members' Statements
Ministerial statement on the craft sector and investment
Mr. Kelvin Parsons, Ms Michael
Mr. Parsons welcomed the minister's statement on the craft sector and the use of technology to connect craftspeople. Ms Michael noted investment agreements with Ireland, Iceland and Rhode Island and questioned the modest number of businesses attracted by the department in six years.
Routine Proceedings
Bill 26 and Bill 28 notices
Ms Burke
The Government House Leader announced that Bill 26 would be read a second time the following day. She also moved for leave to introduce Bill 28, An Act To Amend The Provincial Court Act 1991, and moved that it be read a first time.
Question Period
Question on child protection social worker caseloads and workforce instability
Ms Burke
Responding to questions about why social workers did not see children as required, the Leader of the Opposition pointed to workforce instability, with high turnover in child protection work and inexperienced staff. She said workers often move to other positions within the system because of the accountability involved.
Question on silviculture work and AbitibiBowater seedlings
Asked by Ms Jones · Answered by Mr. Speaker
Ms Jones asked whether the government would commit to jobs for 87 employees and to planting about 3 million seedlings this spring under a five-year silviculture agreement with AbitibiBowater. The Minister of Natural Resources was called to respond; the record does not show the answer.
Orders of the Day
Bill 9, An Act To Amend The Student Financial Assistance Act
Mr. King, Mr. Kelvin Parsons, Ms Jones, Mr. Kent, Mr. Verge
The Minister of Education presented the bill, which builds on earlier measures to reduce student debt, and cited a College of the North Atlantic graduate survey. Opposition members questioned the interest and debt provisions, and the government said the zero-interest decision is set in the bill; in committee the bill was carried without amendment.
Bill 15, An Act To Amend The Legal Aid Act
Mr. T. Marshall, Mr. Kelvin Parsons, Ms Michael, Ms Jones, Mr. Skinner
Debate focused on the eligibility rules for legal aid in summary conviction matters, including the test of likelihood of imprisonment or loss of livelihood and the extraordinary-circumstances provision. Opposition members asked for clarification, and the Minister of Finance spoke on federal funding for legal aid; the bill was read a second time and referred to Committee of the Whole.
Bill 17, An Act To Amend The Tobacco Control Act
Mr. Wiseman, Ms Jones, Ms Michael
The minister framed the bill as part of the Provincial Wellness Strategy to de-normalize smoking, with Ms Jones citing provincial smoking rates among youth and pregnant women. Ms Michael asked whether flavoured tobacco would be banned and raised retail display rules; the bill was carried through committee without amendment.
Bill 12, An Act To Amend The Pharmacy Act
Mr. Wiseman, Ms Jones, Ms Michael, Mr. Kelvin Parsons
The bill lets pharmacists fill prescriptions written by licensed prescribers in other provinces and territories, a change the Pharmacy Board supported. The Opposition raised concerns about audit clawbacks that discourage short-term supplies, and about the drafting of the reasonable-steps wording; in committee, debate continued on whether certain issues belonged in the act.
Bill 20, An Act To Amend The Research and Development Council Act
Mr. Skinner, Mr. Kelvin Parsons
The minister described four minor amendments, including allowing board appointments of up to three years for staggered terms, a duty-of-care clause, and expanding the definition to include social sciences and humanities. The Opposition questioned why the amendments were needed before the parent act, passed in December, was proclaimed, and whether the council was truly arm's-length; the minister said the amendments take effect when the parent act does, and the motion passed.
Chiropractic bill, committee stage (professional corporations, board and register)
Ms Jones, Mr. Kelvin Parsons, Chair
In Committee of the Whole, members went through clauses on the register of chiropractors, professional chiropractic corporations, and regulation-making powers. Debate covered the board's composition (six chiropractors and three public members), expense reimbursement, financial reporting with a $1,000 penalty for non-compliance, a code of ethics, and public access to licence information. A procedural dispute arose over the use of French in the House, which the Chair addressed.
Second reading debate on the chiropractic bill and complementary therapies
Ms Jones, Ms Michael
Ms Jones spoke in support of the bill, describing the need for clear complaint and hearing processes for the public. Ms Michael argued that chiropractic, massage therapy, naturopathy, physical therapy and non-surgical podiatry are covered by insurance plans and should be recognized as part of health care.
Other business
Procedural points: recess, point of order and rulings on relevancy
Mr. Speaker, Chair, Mr. Kelvin Parsons
The House recessed at one point, then resumed at 7:00 p.m. A point of order arose over a member speaking French without translation, which the Chair resolved by allowing debate in an official language. Mr. Parsons also raised a relevancy question about the Research and Development Council debate, and the Chair asked a member to conclude his remarks.
Adjournment
Mr. Speaker
The House adjourned until 1:30 p.m. the following Tuesday, after the Committee of the Whole reported Bill 14 carried with some amendments, and those amendments were read a second time.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.