Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Thursday 3 December 2009
On December 3, 2009, the House of Assembly opened with members' statements on a Mi'kmaq author, a Tidy Towns win and disability awareness, then turned to question period, which centred on the Upper Churchill and Lower Churchill dealings with Quebec and New Brunswick, a Justice Wells review into an inmate's death, the New Harbour dump, and accessibility for people with disabilities. Bills 42, 43, 44, 45, 46 and 47 were debated at second reading, and all were carried. The Labrador Inuit land claims bills drew the most attention, with the Nunatsiavut Speaker in the gallery and a late-sitting dispute over whether the House would return at 7 p.m. to finish Bill 47.
Members' Statements
Members' statement on Chief Mi'sel Joe's book
Ms Perry
Ms Perry congratulated Mi'kmaq Chief Mi'sel Joe of Conne River on his second book and noted an upcoming work on Sylvester Joe. She asked members to join in congratulating him.
Members' statement on Conche Tidy Towns award
Mr. Dean
Mr. Dean congratulated the Town of Conche on winning the 2009 Tidy Towns competition in its population category, crediting school children, town council and volunteers for the cleanup.
Members' statements on violence against women and International Day of Persons With Disabilities
Ms Jones, Ms Sullivan
Ms Jones called for adequate funding and transition supports for women's shelters and noted the Violence Prevention Initiative. Ms Sullivan recognised a disability advocate nominated
Question Period
Upper and Lower Churchill dealings with Quebec and New Brunswick
Asked by Ms Jones · Answered by Ms Dunderdale
The Opposition Leader asked whether the province would start court action after Quebec refused to reopen the Upper Churchill contract. The minister said CF(L)Co had asked Hydro-Quebec to reopen it, had set a January 15 deadline, and would decide its next steps once it had a written reply. The exchange then turned to Lower Churchill transmission through New Brunswick, with the Opposition criticising negotiations conducted through the media and the minister saying any user of transmission would pay a tariff.
Death of an inmate and the Justice Robert Wells review
Asked by Mr. Kelvin Parsons · Answered by Mr. F. Collins
The Opposition House Leader asked the status of the review by Justice Robert Wells into the death of an inmate. Mr. Collins said the review was complete, the report had gone to the department and stakeholders for response by February 26, and it would not be released in full because it contains personal information, though members could receive the recommendations.
New Harbour dump and PCB concerns
Asked by Mr. Butler · Answered by Ms Johnson
Mr. Butler asked the department's plan after a federal investigation into the closed New Harbour dump in Trinity Bay, which is alleged to still violate federal PCB regulations. The minister said the Trinity Bay South Waste Management Committee had closed the site, that the government would follow the federal investigation, and that $750,000 had been spent with further monitoring and a liner planned.
Accessible washrooms in St. John's hospitals
Asked by Ms Michael · Answered by Mr. Kennedy
Ms Michael asked whether Eastern Health would be required to make hospital washrooms accessible for people with disabilities. The Minister of Health and Community Services said the issue was serious and would be examined with the new disabilities office. Ms Michael then asked for short-term solutions across all health authorities, and the minister said he would meet the health authorities and the coalition.
Employment barriers for persons with disabilities
Asked by Ms Michael · Answered by Ms Sullivan
Ms Michael cited unemployment among people with disabilities and asked whether the province had a concrete plan beyond existing programs. The minister pointed to the Disability Policy Office and a newly announced council, and said they were investigating barriers and developing new programs.
Orders of the Day
Bill 47, An Act To Amend The Labrador Inuit Land Claims Agreement Act No. 2 (Nunavik overlap agreement)
Ms Pottle, Ms Jones, Ms Michael, Ms Burke, Mr. Kelvin Parsons
Ms Pottle described the 2005 overlap agreement between Labrador Inuit and Nunavik Inuit and said the bill is needed to bring it into force by amending the Labrador Inuit agreement. The Opposition Leader used the debate to raise education, housing and other challenges in Nunatsiavut communities. Bill 47 was read a second time and referred to a Committee of the Whole House, with a point of order and a debate about stopping the clock to finish it that evening.
Bill 46, An Act To Amend The Labrador Inuit Land Claims Agreement Act
Mr. Speaker, Ms Burke
The Minister of Aboriginal Affairs closed debate on second reading, and the House agreed to read the bill a second time. It was ordered referred to a Committee of the Whole House the following day.
Bill 44, Memorial University pension amendments
Mr. King, Mr. Kelvin Parsons, Ms Michael, Mr. Dalley, Mr. Speaker
The Minister of Education outlined amendments required for compliance with the federal Income Tax Act and Canada Revenue Agency changes, including definition changes and grandfathering of about twenty non-MUN employees. The Opposition asked how affected pensioners had been consulted, and Ms Michael raised pensioner poverty and indexation. The Speaker reminded members to keep to the bill, and the bill was read a second time after the minister closed debate.
Bill 42, An Act To Amend The Vital Statistics Act, 2009
Mr. O'Brien, Mr. Butler
Mr. O'Brien moved second reading and explained three changes: allowing nurse practitioners and registered nurses to certify deaths and stillbirths, extending the marriage registration period from five to seven days, and letting authorized persons obtain certain certificates for deceased persons. Mr. Butler supported the bill. It was read a second time and referred to a Committee of the Whole House.
Bill 45, An Act To Amend The Victims Of Crime Services Act
Mr. F. Collins, Mr. Kelvin Parsons, Ms Michael, Ms Dunderdale
Mr. Collins said the bill would require peace officers to give victim information to Victim Services, with the details set by regulation, and would clarify the relationship with privacy law. The Opposition questioned the timing and the scope of the regulations. Ms Michael said the RNC already shares this information while the RCMP has been constrained by federal privacy rules, and Ms Dunderdale gave the government's support. The bill was read a second time.
Bill 43, An Act To Repeal The Newspapers And Books Act
Mr. French, Mr. Kelvin Parsons
Mr. French said the repeal was warranted because the Corporations Act now covers the registration information and the Criminal Code addresses defamation, so the old affidavit requirements were obsolete and duplicative. The Opposition House Leader said his party would support the bill. It was read a second time.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.