Hansard·Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly·Session 2, GA 47·

Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Thursday 25 April 2013

The House opened with a members' statement by Mr. Brazil honouring the Kin Club of Paradise and its member Gerry Healey, followed by a ministerial statement from Mr. O'Brien on municipal funding in Budget 2013. Oral questions focused on the cut to the College of the North Atlantic's Adult Basic Education program, with Mr. A. Parsons pressing Premier Dunderdale and Ms Shea, and on health spending and smoking cessation, with Ms Michael pressing Mr. Kennedy. The afternoon's petitions and the long debate on Motion 1, the Budget Speech, and a non-confidence sub-amendment covered home care, fracking, whistle-blower protection, ABE, fisheries, tourism, oil price forecasts and Muskrat Falls, with government and opposition members trading accusations about the Budget.

Read the official Hansard ↗

Members' Statements

Members' statement honouring the Kin Club of Paradise and Gerry Healey

Mr. Speaker, Mr. Brazil

Mr. Brazil recognized the Kin Club of Paradise, its charitable work, and member Gerry Healey, who was named outstanding Deputy Governor for District 7 and received a zone leadership award. The Speaker welcomed Healey and his family to the gallery, and the House applauded.

Routine Proceedings

Ministerial statement on Budget 2013 municipal funding

Mr. O'Brien, Mr. Joyce, Mr. Murphy

Mr. O'Brien outlined Budget 2013 measures for municipalities, including maintained Municipal Operating Grants for communities under 11,000, a new MOG formula funded at $22 million for 2014, a $25 million capital works program for the seven larger municipalities, and a review of the provincial-municipal fiscal framework. Mr. Joyce and Mr. Murphy responded, with Mr. Murphy arguing St. John's had lost grant funding elsewhere in the Budget and that government should pay municipal taxes on its buildings.

Question Period

Cut to the College of the North Atlantic's ABE program

Mr. A. Parsons, Premier Dunderdale, Ms Shea

Mr. A. Parsons asked why the college's ABE program costs more and graduates fewer students, citing the faculty's letter opposing the cut and the Noseworthy report's conflicting figures on seats reserved for Income Support clients. The Premier defended investment in the public college system, and Ms Shea said the department would look for cost-saving measures while still offering the program. Mr. Parsons repeated his question on seat numbers, and the minister's answer on seat allocation was not clearly given.

Health care spending and smoking cessation funding

Asked by Mr. Kennedy · Answered by Ms Michael

Mr. Kennedy said the government chose cancer drugs over smoking cessation because of limited funds, and he cited health infrastructure and an aging population. Ms Michael criticized that choice and asked whether the Premier had ordered an analysis of future savings from smoking prevention. She also raised the cut to the Mother Baby Nutrition Supplement and a grant to Vale for hydrometric stations.

Vessel company investment in rural Newfoundland and Labrador

Mr. Hutchings

Mr. Hutchings defended a government investment in a company that had bought a vessel whose cost rose because of Canadianization requirements. He said the company had sought help, that it had gone through business analysis, and that the investment was sound for the industry and rural communities.

Orders of the Day

Motion 1: Budget Speech and the non-confidence sub-amendment

Mr. King, Mr. Edmunds, Mr. Cross, Ms Shea, Mr. Murphy, Mr. Davis, Mr. Pollard, Mr. Osborne

Mr. King called Motion 1, approving the government's budgetary policy in general. Mr. Edmunds described the Budget as a lack of budget and focused on ABE, while Mr. Cross defended the Budget as principled and sustainable, citing deficits, no borrowing in 2013, and seniors' and health spending. The debate continued with government and opposition members on the sub-amendment and the Budget's effects.

Budget effects on fisheries, rural areas, youth and tourism

Mr. Mitchelmore

Mr. Mitchelmore argued that the Budget cut rural areas, youth retention, tourism marketing and fisheries support while raising licence and fee costs. He said revenue depended heavily on the commuter economy and questioned the claims made for the Budget.

Budget defence, public service and Muskrat Falls

Ms Shea

Ms Shea defended the Budget as necessary fiscal management, criticized the NDP's spending positions and its stance on Muskrat Falls, and described integration of Advanced Education and Skills, including income support and labour market programs. She also criticized harassment directed at the Premier.

Oil price forecasts and the revenue shortfall

Mr. Murphy

Mr. Murphy asked the Finance Minister to explain a $400 million gap in corporate revenue and a shortfall in the Budget. He criticized last year's $124 per barrel oil price assumption as unsupported by available forecasts and disputed the revenue projections.

Municipal formula, Newfoundland and Labrador's fiscal position and the Premier

Mr. Pollard

Mr. Pollard praised the new municipal formula starting January 1, 2014, and said the Province had not borrowed for operations since 2004. He defended the Premier's leadership and rejected the view that the Province should not be called a have Province.

Housing, Poverty Reduction Strategy and Muskrat Falls loan guarantee

Mr. Osborne

Mr. Osborne commended the Poverty Reduction Strategy and the reduction of rent to 25 per cent of household income, but criticized gaps in housing repairs. He questioned shifting deficit projections and the Muskrat Falls AAA rating and federal loan guarantee.

Public service, policing and the Premier's leadership

Mr. Davis

Mr. Davis, a former investigator, reflected on respect and community policing and then defended public servants and ministers against criticism. He spoke about job cuts affecting water bombers, and said the Premier had made tough decisions.

Other business

Petition on home care for dementia patients and family caregivers

Mr. Bennett

Mr. Bennett presented petitions on home care, describing a case where a family member could not provide paid care despite a promised policy. He described a dementia patient in Port Saunders who panics when strangers replace her regular care providers, and he said the promised change was in the Budget but had not been acted on.

Petition on fracking and environmental protection

Mr. Murphy

Mr. Murphy presented a petition calling for caution on fracking, citing Quebec's halt after well leakage, risks to drinking water, endangered plants on the Port au Port Peninsula, and tourism in the Western area and Gros Morne National Park. He urged the Natural Resources Minister to develop careful regulations.

Petition on privatization and College of the North Atlantic funding

Mr. Edmunds

Mr. Edmunds presented a petition questioning privatization and asked who would cover the 40 per cent of programming costs the college funds for Nunatsiavut beneficiaries. He raised the same concerns in later remarks about ABE, including rural access and Labrador workers for Muskrat Falls.

Whistle-blower protection legislation

Ms Rogers

Ms Rogers called for whistle-blower protection legislation, saying Justice officials could draft it in the public interest. She cited spending scandals in the House and the Cameron Inquiry, and argued the measure would not cost the Province much.

Petition on ABE cuts

Mr. Mitchelmore

Mr. Mitchelmore presented a petition opposing the cut to ABE funding at the College of the North Atlantic. He said students needing a few courses before moving into college would lose a suitable route to further education.

This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.