tabled.
Hansard·Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly·Session 2, GA 47·

Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Monday 4 November 2013

The House opened with members' statements congratulating and thanking volunteers and award recipients, then moved to Question Period, where the Official Opposition pressed the Premier and ministers on the Muskrat Falls power contract with Emera, the project's cost to date, and delays in workers' compensation reviews. Government ministers made statements on a moratorium on hydraulic fracturing applications and a memorial to the victims of the helicopter crashes. Routine business included notices of several bills, a special warrant, and petitions on home care, rural roads, broadband, autism services, fracking and the Bunker C vessel off the coast. The Address in Reply debate, where government and opposition members spoke on rural development, health, housing and education, closed with the Opposition's criticism of the hospital plan for Corner Brook.

Read the official Hansard ↗

Routine Proceedings

Bill notices and special warrant

Mr. Marshall, Mr. King, Mr. A. Parsons

The Government House Leader tabled a special warrant for the 2013-2014 fiscal year relating to the L'Anse au Clair by-election and gave notice of several bills and supplementary supply resolutions, including Bills 8, 9 and 12. The Minister of Municipal and Intergovernmental Affairs gave notice of further bills, including Bills 11, 14, 15, 16, 17 and 19 on court, statute, labour standards and related matters. Bills 5 and 6 were introduced by leave and motions carried.

Petitions on home care, roads, broadband, autism, fracking and the Bunker C vessel

Mr. Bennett, Mr. A. Parsons, Mr. Mitchelmore, Mr. Kirby, Mr. Murphy

Members presented petitions on several matters. Mr. Bennett criticized the government for not using money allocated for home care for families who had requested it. Mr. A. Parsons raised a road needing repairs and a washed-out road to Burgeo. Mr. Mitchelmore urged a broadband strategy for about 200 communities. Mr. Kirby asked that autism services be considered in pre-Budget planning. Mr. Murphy presented a petition on fracking. Mr. Bennett also raised concerns about the sunken vessel's Bunker C oil and asked what the Province was doing about it.

Question Period

Muskrat Falls power sale to Emera

Mr. Joyce, Premier Dunderdale, Ms Michael

The Opposition questioned why the Province was offering Emera of Nova Scotia a long-term power purchase agreement, which the Premier had earlier said she would not do. The Premier replied that 20 per cent of Muskrat Falls power was pledged to Emera and that the remainder would serve Island ratepayers and industrial and residential demand. The Opposition argued that Nova Scotia would get discounted power while Newfoundland and Labrador ratepayers would pay higher rates.

Cost of Muskrat Falls to date

Mr. Ball, Mr. Dalley, Mr. McGrath

The Opposition asked how much taxpayer money was committed to Muskrat Falls and what had been tendered. The Minister of Finance said he did not have the exact figure but estimated about $235 million to date and noted more than 3,300 expected jobs. The Minister of Transportation and Works said the Labrador ferry schedule and an RFP would be managed to avoid a debacle.

Workers' compensation review delays

Asked by Mr. Joyce · Answered by Mr. Crummell

The Opposition said injured workers were waiting months for reviews at the Workers' Compensation Review Division, with 309 cases stranded, and that deadlines were being missed with ministerial approval. The Minister said wait times had been cut from six months to four and called the system efficient. The Opposition said the minister should review his position.

Minimum housing standards for tenants

Asked by Mr. Osborne · Answered by Mr. Crummell

The Opposition asked when tenants would be protected by minimum housing standards like those in other provinces. The Minister Responsible for Service Newfoundland and Labrador said a comprehensive residential tenancies review was underway, public consultations had just concluded, and legislation would come to the House when appropriate.

Orders of the Day

Address in Reply: economic and municipal priorities

Mr. Kent, Mr. Little, Mr. O'Brien

The Minister of Municipal and Intergovernmental Affairs highlighted the federal loan guarantee, White Rose Extension, more than 500 municipal infrastructure projects, solid waste investments, and a smoke alarm campaign and basic province-wide 911 system. Government members cited CETA fisheries benefits, tourism growth, infrastructure investment since 2008, and the residential energy efficiency program. Opposition-side speakers were asked to offer alternatives.

General state of affairs and health care spending

Mr. Bennett

The Leader of the Opposition argued that public confidence in government was low and that government appeared secretive. He said health care takes about 40 per cent of the budget, called for an independent audit of health spending, and criticized the consolidation of health authorities and the limited investment in prevention. He also criticized the appointed school board's election of its chair.

Labrador district and rural services

Ms Dempster

In her first speech in the House, the Member for Cartwright – L'Anse au Clair paid tribute to her district, describing community successes and needs. She raised high commercial power rates, the loss of zone boards and EAS offices, medical transportation reimbursement delays, home care, and a need for a tourism development officer.

Education and skilled trades

Mr. Jackman

The Minister of Education defended the government's record on the pupil-teacher ratio, free textbooks, the removal of school fees, and promotion of skilled trades and non-traditional careers for young women. He said he would make a ministerial statement the next day.

Seniors' housing and home care

Ms Rogers

The Member for St. John's Centre argued that seniors and people with disabilities faced precarious housing, a lack of accessible and affordable units, and inadequate home care. She cited British Columbia's seniors' housing programs and said the government had lost touch with people's needs despite the Province's prosperity.

Corner Brook hospital services

Mr. Joyce, Ms Sullivan

The Opposition member raised the lack of a PET scanner and radiation unit in the planned Corner Brook hospital and cited ministers' statements on construction timing, including a 2015 start that another minister could not confirm. The Minister of Health and Community Services rose on a point of order before debate was adjourned.

Other business

Hydraulic fracturing moratorium

Mr. Dalley, Mr. Ball

The Minister of Natural Resources announced that the government would not accept applications for onshore and onshore-to-offshore petroleum exploration using hydraulic fracturing, pending a review of regulations elsewhere, technical work on geology in Western Newfoundland, and public engagement. The Opposition welcomed the public engagement approach but noted it had earlier voted down a private member's resolution on fracking and urged a firm timeline.

Memorial to helicopter crash victims

Mr. French, Mr. Ball

The Minister of Tourism, Culture and Recreation announced a memorial site for victims of the helicopter tragedies, featuring permanently illuminated lights along a path to circular contemplation spaces. The Opposition welcomed the site and said questions remained about the 1985 Cougar 491 crash and how to prevent such accidents.

This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.