Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Wednesday 27 November 2013
On 27 November 2013 the House of Assembly heard members' statements on Pastors Benjamin and Rita Elliott, Come Home Year in Centreville-Wareham-Trinity, and a Nain climate-change advocate, followed by ministerial statements on the northern air food subsidy, red-tape reduction and historic commemorations. Question Period covered the ferry strategy, the St. Lawrence fluorspar mine loan, emergency room wait times, bicycle helmet legislation, poverty reduction and Income Support, and the OCI yellowtail plant in Fortune, with Minister O'Brien, Minister Sullivan, Minister Crummell, Minister Hutchings and Premier Dunderdale answering for government. The afternoon's Private Members' motion, brought by Mr. Forsey, supported the Newfoundland and Labrador Seniors' Benefit; the vote was contested, with the Speaker's declared result disputed and a division recorded as 39 ayes and two nays.
Members' Statements
Members' statement: Pastors Benjamin and Rita Elliott
Mr. S. Collins
Mr. S. Collins paid tribute to the Elliotts for founding Pentecostal churches in Glovertown and Bonavista and for their work on the coastal mission boat. He asked members to thank Pastor Rita Elliott, now ninety-five.
Members' statement: Centreville-Wareham-Trinity Come Home Year
Mr. Cross
Mr. Cross recognized the August 2013 Come Home Year in Centreville-Wareham-Trinity and its volunteers and leaders, including Mayor Rogers. He asked for unanimous recognition of the community's efforts.
Members' statement: Caitlyn Baikie of Nain
Mr. Edmunds
Mr. Edmunds recognized Caitlyn Baikie for her climate-change research and advocacy in Nunatsiavut and the Torngat Mountains, and noted her upcoming Antarctic expedition.
Ministerial statement: air food subsidy for Northern Labrador
Mr. Edmunds
Responding to a ministerial statement on the air freight food subsidy, Mr. Edmunds said retailers are not passing the subsidy on to consumers, and called for better program monitoring.
Ministerial statement: red tape reduction and Accountability Framework
Mr. Crummell, Mr. Edmunds, Mr. Kirby
Mr. Crummell described red-tape reduction as a permanent function supported by the Accountability Framework. Mr. Edmunds said the statement repeated an earlier announcement, and Mr. Kirby suggested electronic paystubs for public servants as a further measure.
Ministerial statement: Provincial Historic Commemorations Program
Mr. French, Ms Rogers
Mr. French encouraged nominations to the Provincial Historic Commemorations Program. Ms Rogers welcomed the program but criticized cuts to community museum grants and archivist and conservator positions at The Rooms.
Routine Proceedings
Tabling of documents: Citizens' Representative annual digest and CETA correspondence
Mr. Speaker, Mr. Hutchings
The Speaker tabled the Citizens' Representative Annual Digest for April 2012 to March 2013. Mr. Hutchings moved to table a January 2013 letter concerning fisheries industry input to the CETA negotiations, responding to a point raised in Question Period.
Notice of motion: Bill 27, An Act Respecting Adoptions
Mr. Davis
Mr. Davis gave notice that he will seek leave to introduce Bill 27, An Act Respecting Adoptions.
Petition for full-day kindergarten
Mr. Kirby
Mr. Kirby presented a petition urging government to introduce full-day kindergarten. He argued it could be phased in over three or four years starting the next September.
Question Period
Question Period: ferry replacement strategy
Mr. Ball
Mr. Ball asked whether government has a strategy to replace all or some ferries, noting that the minister had described it as both in place and still being developed. He challenged the government's consistency on written strategies.
Question Period: St. Lawrence fluorspar mine loan
Mr. Ball
Mr. Ball asked how much of the $17 million repayable loan for the St. Lawrence fluorspar mine has been spent and when construction and jobs will begin, noting re-scoping after cost overruns. He also sought clarity on conflicting ministerial answers about whether $300,000 had been advanced.
Question Period: emergency room wait times
Asked by Mr. A. Parsons · Answered by Ms Sullivan
Mr. A. Parsons said Eastern Health misses national ER wait-time targets at the Health Sciences and St. Clare's most of the time. Ms Sullivan replied with figures showing rising visits but shorter assessment times, shorter stays and fewer patients leaving unseen.
Question Period: bicycle helmet legislation
Asked by Mr. A. Parsons · Answered by Mr. Crummell
Mr. A. Parsons asked whether government will introduce bicycle helmet legislation, citing child hospitalizations and ER visit studies. Mr. Crummell said there is no plan at present, that municipalities lead on such bylaws, and that government may look at it in future.
Question Period: poverty reduction, Income Support and housing
Mr. Osborne, Mr. O'Brien, Ms Dempster, Ms Michael, Premier Dunderdale, Ms Rogers
Opposition members questioned the Poverty Reduction Strategy, Income Support rent rates against the Seniors' Benefit indexing, the case management recommendations of John Noseworthy, the dropped literacy goal, and the portability of the rent supplement. Mr. O'Brien and the Premier cited reduced Income Support caseloads, a doubled rental supplement and falling poverty rates.
Question Period: OCI yellowtail processing and Fortune plant
Asked by Mr. Bennett · Answered by Mr. Hutchings
Mr. Bennett asked when the minister will make OCI honour its commitment to hire 110 people at the Fortune plant, which remains closed under a December 2012 quota deal. Mr. Hutchings said most crew on the vessel are Newfoundlanders and Labradorians and that the government expects the plant to reopen.
Private Members' Business
Private Member's Motion on the Newfoundland and Labrador Seniors' Benefit
Mr. Forsey, Mr. Joyce, Ms Sullivan, Ms Rogers, K. Parsons, Mr. Osborne, Mr. Crummell
Mr. Forsey moved a motion supporting the Seniors' Benefit, which he said reached about 42,000 seniors at up to $971 this year. Opposition members argued that the benefit does not lift many seniors out of poverty and raised housing, rent and drug coverage concerns, while government speakers defended the program's growth and wider seniors' supports.
Division and disputed vote on the Seniors' Benefit motion
Mr. Speaker, Ms Michael, Clerk
The Speaker first declared the motion defeated and the House adjourned at 5:00, but a division was then called. Ms Michael asked for clarification on the sequence of the ruling and the call for division, and the clerk recorded 39 ayes and two nays.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.