Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Monday 31 March 2014
The House of Assembly sat on March 31, 2014, with Question Period covering the Budget's borrowing plans, pension reform, Muskrat Falls, justice services in Labrador, and children's services in Natuashish. Members also presented petitions on Pynn's Brook highway speed limits, the Corner Brook hospital, reinstating the Family Violence Intervention Court, and cellphone coverage in coastal Labrador. Bills 7, 9 and 10 received first reading, and Ball opened debate on Motion 1, the Budget Speech, before the House adjourned until the next day.
Members' Statements
Labrador flag 40th anniversary
Mr. Russell
Russell marked the fortieth anniversary of the Labrador flag's raising in 1974 and explained the meaning of its colours and design. He asked members to join in recognising the anniversary.
Tricentia Timberwolves volleyball silver medal
Mr. Peach
Peach congratulated the Arnold's Cove volleyball team on its silver medal at the 2014 Winter Games and the four Eastern Region bronze medallists. He asked members to recognise all athletes.
Routine Proceedings
Petition on Pynn's Brook highway speed limit
Mr. Murphy
Murphy presented a petition asking government to reduce the Trans-Canada Highway speed limit through Pynn's Brook from 100 to 60 kilometres an hour, citing turning dangers and fatal accidents. He said the government has lowered speeds in other communities.
Petition on new Corner Brook hospital
Mr. A. Parsons
Parsons presented a petition asking government to commit to a timely planning and construction schedule for the new Corner Brook hospital. He criticised the delay, the radiation study and the minister's handling of a request to meet Eastern Health.
Petition to reinstate Family Violence Intervention Court
Ms Rogers
Rogers presented a petition asking government to reinstate the Family Violence Intervention Court. She cited its reported recidivism results and broad support from the justice system and questioned why it was cancelled.
Petition on cellphone coverage in coastal Labrador
Ms Dempster
Dempster presented a petition asking government to provide cellphone coverage along the Trans-Labrador Highway and in coastal communities. She described safety risks, including a driver stranded in freezing conditions.
Opposition to proposed facility at Peak Pond
Mr. Lane
Lane said residents oppose a proposed facility at the Peak Pond area and urged government to relocate it to former industrial or dump sites. He said he would keep presenting the concern until government listens, though an environmental assessment is under way.
Question Period
Budget 2014 borrowing and debt
Asked by Mr. Ball · Answered by Premier Marshall
Ball asked why the Budget mail-out omitted the $1 billion in borrowing. The Premier replied that the government has borrowed nothing for operations since 2004, that the borrowing is to refinance maturing bonds at lower rates, and that the money will fund water bombers and Nalcor investments.
Public sector pension plans
Asked by Premier Marshall · Answered by Ms Michael
The Premier said the government supports defined benefit pensions, will not remove accrued benefits, and will work with unions on a sustainable plan for the future. Ms Michael suggested the pension concern was a ploy to divert attention from Muskrat Falls debt.
Muskrat Falls project returns
Asked by Ms Michael · Answered by Premier Marshall
Ms Michael argued Muskrat Falls creates real debt. The Premier called the spending an investment and projected dividends of about half a billion dollars a year from 2019.
Justice system crisis in Labrador
Asked by Mr. Edmunds · Answered by Mr. F. Collins
Edmunds asked the Attorney General to accept that Labrador's justice system is in crisis. Collins acknowledged delivery challenges, which he attributed to geography and culture rather than funding, and said the government is working with stakeholders on innovative service delivery.
Kindergarten class size cap
Asked by Mr. Kirby · Answered by Minister of Education
Kirby asked whether the election promise includes keeping the class size cap for kindergarten. The Minister of Education responded, though the answer is not clearly recorded in the excerpt.
Community of Natuashish fly-in service model (CONSEP)
Mr. Davis
Davis reported on the four-month-old fly-in, fly-out child, youth and family service model in Natuashish, which uses two rotating teams. He described positive early feedback from his February visit. Davis later said children in staffed residential placements will largely remain in their current communities with existing providers, and withdrew a comment made in that exchange.
Early release of road and bridge tenders
Asked by Mr. Osborne · Answered by Mr. Murphy
Murphy responded to a Transportation and Works statement on early tender release, noting his party had proposed the idea in a private member's motion that the government defeated. He called for long-term roads and bridges planning and cited an $800 million shortfall identified by the Auditor General.
Withdrawal of remarks about Nalcor and the Leader of the Opposition
Mr. Dalley
The Minister of Natural Resources apologised for and withdrew a comment from an earlier speech that suggested the Leader of the Opposition had found Nalcor negligent.
Orders of the Day
Bill 7, An Act To Amend The Health Professions Act
Mr. Speaker
Leave was granted for the Minister of Health and Community Services to introduce Bill 7, which was read a first time and set down for second reading the next day.
Bill 9, An Act To Amend The Revenue Administration Act
Mr. Speaker, Mr. King
Leave was granted for the Minister of Finance to introduce Bill 9, which received
Other business
Tabling of activity plans and administrative reports
Mr. Hutchings, Mr. Speaker
Hutchings tabled 2014-2016 activity plans for the Professional Fish Harvesters Certification Board, its Appeal Board and the Fish Processing Licensing Board. The Speaker tabled amendments to the Members' Resources and Allowances Rules and Public Tender Act exception reports for November 2013 to January 2014.
Heated exchange over Western Newfoundland meeting
Mr. Joyce, Mr. S. Collins
Joyce challenged Collins, the member for Bay of Islands, to attend a public meeting on April 24 about a Western Newfoundland issue and to say publicly what he had posted on Twitter. Collins's interjection is not recorded.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.