Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Monday 1 December 2014
The House sat on December 1, 2014, with question period focused on Nalcor's Muskrat Falls and Hebron spending, the government's hiring freeze, the Marble Mountain chairlift insurance shortfall, the cost of new ferry vessels, and deaths of children receiving provincial services. Members also made statements and presented petitions on a Corner Brook hospital, literacy, the Family Violence Intervention Court, broadband in Labrador, autism services and herbicide use. The Address in Reply debate continued, including maiden speeches by the new members for St. George's - Stephenville East and Conception Bay South, and its adjournment was moved. Bills 32 and 33 were introduced, Bill 30 on child care services was passed, and the House then moved to adjourn.
Members' Statements
Mount Pearl soccer volunteers
Mr. Lane
Mr. Lane recognized John Nolan and Brian O'Keefe for their decades of volunteer service to the Mount Pearl Soccer Association, noting their induction into the Mount Pearl Soccer Hall of Fame.
Routine Proceedings
Nunatsiavut Day
Mr. Russell
Mr. Russell marked Nunatsiavut Day, the anniversary of the Labrador Inuit Land Claims Agreement taking effect in 2005, and described the government's continuing work with the Nunatsiavut Government.
Petition on new Corner Brook hospital
Mr. Joyce
Mr. Joyce presented a petition asking the House to commit to planning and building a new Corner Brook hospital on schedule. He questioned why the project had to go through budgetary review again, given earlier announced start dates.
Petition on literacy strategy
Ms C. Bennett
Ms C. Bennett presented a petition calling for a provincial literacy strategy and more funding for literacy programs. She asked about accountability for funding linked to the Newfoundland and Labrador literacy foundation.
Petition to reinstate Family Violence Intervention Court
Ms Rogers
Ms Rogers presented a petition asking government to reinstate the Family Violence Intervention Court, citing lower recidivism and its low share of the Justice budget. She contrasted the spending on the Marble Mountain chairlift with the court's funding.
Petition on broadband for Labrador Coast communities
Ms Dempster
Ms Dempster presented a petition asking government to provide adequate broadband to communities along the Labrador Coast, noting that some communities lack adequate service and that a plan was not expected until 2016.
Petition on Applied Behaviour Analysis program
Mr. A. Parsons
Mr. A. Parsons presented a petition asking for a review of the Applied Behaviour Analysis program for children with autism and for autism programming to extend beyond Grade 3.
Petition on EION Inc. rural broadband delays
Mr. J. Bennett
Mr. J. Bennett presented a petition on Phase 2 of the Rural Broadband Initiative, asking government to resolve delays by EION Inc. in providing contracted Internet service to several communities on the Bay d'Espoir and Bay of Islands area.
Petition on Tordon 101 herbicide use
Mr. Murphy
Mr. Murphy presented a petition asking government to stop using Tordon 101 for brush clearing, citing picloram and the province's cosmetic pesticide ban, and to use manual or mechanical methods instead.
Question Period
Muskrat Falls and Hebron funding for next year
Asked by Mr. Ball · Answered by Mr. Wiseman
Mr. Ball asked how much money Muskrat Falls and Hebron would require from Nalcor next year. Finance Minister Wiseman estimated about $500 million for Muskrat Falls equity in the coming year and described it as a strategic investment with a future return.
Hiring freeze and discretionary spending savings
Asked by Mr. Ball · Answered by Premier Davis
Mr. Ball asked how much the hiring freeze and cuts to discretionary spending would save and who decides what counts as a critical hire. Premier Davis said no firm figure was available, that decisions are made case by case by departments, and that Treasury Board would review requests.
Marble Mountain chairlift insurance and funding
Asked by Mr. Ball · Answered by Mr. Wiseman
Mr. Ball raised the $5.2 million replacement cost of the lightning-struck Marble Mountain chairlift, of which only $1.2 million came from insurance, and asked where the remainder would come from. Mr. Wiseman said the asset was strategic and responded on the funding.
Cost of new ferry vessels
Asked by Mr. Osborne · Answered by Mr. Brazil
Mr. Osborne compared the price of the Newfoundland and Labrador ferries with larger vessels being built in British Columbia and asked whether lower-cost proposals had been received. Transportation and Works Minister Brazil said the government was in a contract with a quality shipyard and that value rather than price was the priority. Mr. Osborne was pressing a follow-up question when the exchange ended.
Child deaths under provincial care
Mr. J. Bennett, Mr. S. Collins, Premier Davis
Mr. J. Bennett asked whether more children had died under provincial care since September and whether these deaths had been reported to the Child and Youth Advocate. Minister S. Collins said all deaths had been reported and that the three children in care died in hospital from medical conditions. Mr. Bennett cited at least thirty-five deaths since 2009 and asked the Premier for a report; Premier Davis said many of the children were receiving services rather than in care.
Orders of the Day
Address in Reply debate, maiden speeches and adjournment
Mr. King, Mr. Reid, Mr. Hillier, Mr. Forsey, Mr. F. Collins, Mr. Slade, Mr. Peach, Mr. Mitchelmore
The Government House Leader called Address in Reply. Mr. Reid and Mr. Hillier gave maiden speeches on their districts, Mr. Reid also on committee structures. Members from both sides spoke on district funding, roads, forestry, fracking and oil revenues, and Mr. Murphy argued against government's Nalcor rate and oil-price assumptions. Mr. King then moved to adjourn the debate, which was carried.
Bill 32, An Act To Amend The Registered Nurses Act, 2008
Mr. Speaker
The Minister of Health and Community Services was given leave to introduce Bill 32, which was read a first time and ordered read a second time the next day.
Bill 33, An Act Respecting The Atlantic Provinces Harness Racing Commission
Mr. Speaker
The Minister of Finance was given leave to introduce Bill 33, which was read a first time and ordered read a second time the next day.
Bill 30, An Act To Regulate Child Care Services
Clerk
Bill 30 was read a third time and ordered passed, with its title as on the Order Paper.
Private Members' Business
Notice of private member's motion to be debated
Mr. A. Parsons
Mr. A. Parsons noted under Standing Order 63(3) that the private member's resolution entered by the Member for St. John's South would be debated the following Wednesday.
Other business
Adjournment of the House
Mr. Speaker
The Speaker put the motion that the House do now adjourn, and members voted on it.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.