Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Wednesday 18 March 2015
The House heard members' statements on a Harbour Breton volunteer and a late Bay of Islands community figure, then question period, where the Opposition pressed the government on Muskrat Falls cost and schedule overruns, Statoil negotiations and the unreleased royalty regime, the Labrador ferry tender, Long Harbour and land claims, seafood marketing, and women's centre funding. The day's main debate was a private member's motion from Baie Verte - Springdale urging Ottawa to end the Last In, First Out (LIFO) policy for Northern shrimp, which drew speakers from all parties and was followed by a call for a vote. The Speaker also tabled Management Commission minutes, and a Bay of Islands member presented a petition about busing Holy Family School students in Paradise.
Members' Statements
Members' statement on Harbour Breton Citizen of the Year
Ms Perry
Ms Perry congratulated Sandra Dominie, named Harbour Breton's 2014 Citizen of the Year, for her volunteer work with schools, committees and community projects.
Members' statement honouring Wayne Rodgers
Mr. Kirby
Mr. Kirby paid tribute to Wayne Rodgers, a realtor and volunteer who ran a breakfast program and maintained grounds at Leary's Brook Junior High. The school will name the breakfast space after him and plant a memorial garden.
Routine Proceedings
Holy Family School busing petition
Mr. Kirby
Mr. Kirby presented a petition from Paradise residents opposing a proposal to bus Holy Family School students to the former School for the Deaf, asking government to direct the school district to find a better alternative. He noted the school board had since proposed two options, busing or more portables.
Question Period
Muskrat Falls project oversight, costs and schedule
Mr. Dalley, Mr. Ball, Premier Davis
Mr. Ball said the project's generating facility is falling behind schedule and asked who will pay for extra costs, Newfoundlanders and Labradorians or the contractor Astaldi. Minister Dalley said the project remains on schedule with first power expected in late 2017 and cited oversight through Nalcor, the Oversight Committee and an independent engineer.
Statoil negotiations, Bay du Nord and the generic royalty regime
Mr. Ball, Mr. Dalley, Premier Davis
Mr. Ball questioned the mandate to finalize a deal with Statoil this year when the company says it will not know about Bay du Nord development until 2016, and asked why the new generic royalty regime is not public. Mr. Dalley said negotiations are ongoing with no deal yet and that the government would not negotiate in public. The Premier defended the Muskrat Falls-linked electricity export opportunity and the Budget consultations.
PDAC convention attendance and mining investment
Asked by Mr. Dalley · Answered by Mr. J. Bennett
Minister Dalley highlighted the government's presence at the Prospectors and Developers Association of Canada convention and the Province's ranking in an international mining survey. Mr. Bennett did not object to attendance but criticized the shared Atlantic pavilion, the number of people the Premier reached, and the missed chance to attract venture capital.
Labrador ferry service request for proposals
Mr. Brazil
Transportation and Works Minister Brazil answered repeated questions on the Labrador ferry service procurement. He said a fairness monitor was used, a short list was made, one proponent was dropped, and a contract will be awarded to one of the two remaining companies within weeks, stressing ice conditions and vessel capacity.
Long Harbour amendment and Labrador Inuit land claims consultation
Mr. Russell
Labrador and Aboriginal Affairs Minister Russell defended the government's consultation duties under the Labrador Inuit Land Claims Agreement and said an amendment for the Long Harbour project keeps jobs and benefits flowing. He said a remark he made to the Nunatsiavut Government was taken from a wider conversation and was not a legal opinion.
Role of private business in delivering public services
Asked by Premier Davis · Answered by Mr. Dalley
The Premier argued that private businesses already deliver many government-funded services, such as family doctors, pharmacists, dentists and road construction, and said the government should keep discussing the role of business. The debate followed earlier comments he had made during Budget consultations.
Funding for women's centres
Asked by Ms Sullivan · Answered by Mr. King
Status of Women Minister Sullivan said the government admires and supports the province's women's centres and that funding requests will go through the Budget process. She rejected a suggestion that the government planned cuts. Justice Minister King said requests would receive consideration in the Budget process.
Seafood expo and seafood marketing strategy
Asked by Mr. Granter · Answered by Ms Michael
Mr. Granter reported on the seafood trade expo, citing more interest from Asian buyers in Newfoundland and Labrador fresh, live and shellfish products. Ms Michael called for a Province-wide seafood marketing strategy and a seafood marketing council and asked whether the government would act.
Labrador West iron ore downturn
Ms Michael
Ms Michael asked what the government is doing for Labrador West workers and families, citing low iron ore prices, the Wabush shutdown, the stalled Kami project and IOCC concessions. The minister's response is not recorded in this excerpt.
Nutrition, dietitians and diabetes
Asked by Mr. Jackman · Answered by Ms Rogers
Health Minister Jackman asked members to thank dietitians and recognized local nutrition organizations. Ms Rogers urged that dietitians be part of primary health care teams, citing diabetes rates and food insecurity among seniors.
Private Members' Business
Northern shrimp allocation and LIFO policy (private member's motion)
Mr. Pollard, Mr. Slade, Mr. Hutchings, Mr. Mitchelmore, Mr. Little, Ms Michael, Mr. Granter
Mr. Pollard moved a resolution urging the federal government to end the LIFO policy and adopt a fairer sharing arrangement between inshore and offshore fleets. Speakers from all sides cited job and community impacts, adjacency, the All-Party Committee's Ottawa presentation, and the case for a rollover of the Area 6 quota. Mr. Pollard closed the debate, and the House moved to a vote.
Other business
Tabling of House of Assembly Management Commission minutes
Mr. Speaker
The Speaker tabled the minutes of the House of Assembly Management Commission meeting held on October 22, 2014, under the Accountability, Integrity and Administration Act.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.