Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Tuesday 22 November 2016
On November 22, 2016, the House heard Opposition questions on alleged partisan appointments in the civil service, including the clerk of Executive Council and a consumer advocate post, and on school board election voting hours. Government members answered that the appointments followed proper process and that the Independent Appointments Commission had been created. The House also gave first reading to Bills 47, 48 and 49 and a notice for Bill 50, passed Bill 44 through Committee of the Whole and third reading, and began second reading debate on the procurement bill, Bill 46, which was adjourned.
Members' Statements
Fishery markets and off-season fishing
Mr. K. Parsons
Mr. K. Parsons reported unusually good mid-November cod catches off Flatrock and said fishers need markets, asking government to develop them before the next season's larger catch.
Routine Proceedings
Bill 47, An Act Respecting the Relocation of Certain Communities
Mr. A. Parsons
The Government House Leader moved for leave to introduce the bill and for first reading, which carried.
Bill 48, An Act to Amend The Hydro Corporation Act, 2007
Mr. A. Parsons
Leave was sought and first reading moved for the bill, which was carried. It was set for second reading tomorrow.
Bill 49, An Act to Amend The Income Tax Act, 2000 No. 6
Mr. A. Parsons
Leave was sought and first reading moved for the bill, which was carried. It was set for second reading tomorrow.
Bill 50, An Act to Amend The Vital Statistics Act
Mr. Joyce
Mr. Joyce gave notice that he would ask leave to introduce the bill.
Petition to keep libraries open
Ms. Rogers
Ms. Rogers presented a petition asking government to reverse library budget cuts that threaten 54 libraries and to develop a long-term plan, and spoke about the library in Cape St. George.
Petition on education cuts
Mr. Brazil
Mr. Brazil presented a petition asking government to reverse its cuts to teachers and the education system, and commented on candidates in the school board election.
Question Period
Patronage and appointments in the public service
Mr. P. Davis, Mr. Kirby, Premier Ball, Mr. A. Parsons, Mr. Kent
The Opposition asked how many Liberal supporters, failed candidates and former staffers had been hired since the government took office, and what process selected a former Liberal leadership candidate as clerk of the Executive Council. Government members said the appointments followed the usual process, that the Independent Appointments Commission was new, and pointed to appointments made by the previous administration.
Consumer Advocate appointment and senior civil service changes
Mr. Brazil, Premier Ball, Mr. A. Parsons
Mr. Brazil asked the process and number of candidates interviewed for the Consumer Advocate post, and whether there were changes to ADMs and other senior staff beyond those publicly released. The Premier defended reductions in deputy minister and ADM positions as a fiscal measure.
Assistant deputy minister of Royalties and Benefits
Asked by Mr. Kent · Answered by Mr. A. Parsons
Mr. Kent asked the Minister of Natural Resources whether a newly appointed ADM had been a Liberal candidate in the last general election. The Government House Leader responded by pointing to appointments the previous government had made.
School board election voting hours
Asked by Mr. Kirby · Answered by Mr. P. Davis
Mr. P. Davis asked why employees on long shifts were not given time off to vote in the school board elections. Mr. Kirby said the rules matched those of the 2009 school board election, that no changes had been proposed, and encouraged employers to give staff time to vote.
Muskrat Falls Project
Ms. Coady
Asked about Muskrat Falls, the minister said the government was working to keep the project on track, with Nalcor engaged on cost and schedule, and acknowledged the concerns that had been raised.
Housing rent supplements and boarding house conditions
Asked by Ms. Gambin-Walsh · Answered by Ms. Rogers
The Minister responsible for Housing said a review of rent supplements was well under way and would extend to all Newfoundland and Labrador Housing programs. Ms. Rogers described substandard boarding-house conditions in her district and asked why public rent money was not ensuring proper services.
Orders of the Day
Bill 42, An Act to Amend The Highway Traffic Act No. 3
Mr. A. Parsons
The Government House Leader called third reading of the bill, and the Speaker put the question on its adoption.
Bill 44, An Act to Amend The Municipalities Act, 1999
Mr. Joyce, Ms. Michael, Mr. K. Parsons
In Committee of the Whole, members asked about conflict-of-interest exemptions for councillors and about local service district civic addressing, including fees, administration and the Next Generation 911 service. Mr. Joyce answered and the bill passed without amendment. It then went through third reading, and the Minister thanked members for their input.
Bill 46, An Act Respecting Procurement by Public Bodies
Mr. Joyce, Mr. K. Parsons, Mr. Letto, Mr. Brazil, Ms. Haley, Ms. Michael, Ms. Parsley, Mr. Hutchings
The minister introduced the bill to replace the Public Tender Act and related legislation, citing best value, transparency and modernization. Opposition members raised concerns about regulations left to Cabinet, monetary thresholds, the exemption of Nalcor, supplier accountability and the appointment of a chief procurement officer by Cabinet. Government speakers supported the bill, and debate was adjourned by Mr. Petten.
Other business
Minimum wage increase
Ms. Michael
Ms. Michael cited a Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives study on minimum wage increases and urged the minister to act, saying the government had so far done nothing.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.