Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Monday 2 November 2026
Question Period was dominated by the opposition's sustained attack on the Churchill Falls deal, with the Leader of the Official Opposition arguing that the 17 definitive agreements are not yet negotiated and should be voted on by the House before signing, while the Premier and Energy Minister insisted the material terms are settled and will return to the House. Secondary exchanges covered the Deer Lake health centre dispute, electoral boundary redistribution timelines, downtown St. John's public safety, and housing targets and whether housing should be enshrined as a human right. The sitting opened with members' and ministerial statements on municipal infrastructure funding and wildfire preparedness, followed by routine business including tabled documents, notices of motion (among them a private member's resolution on red tape reduction), and petitions on a Cartwright school, public safety, and the Churchill Falls agreements. The main Orders of the Day debate centred on Bill 22, which temporarily removes provincial tax on certain gasoline grades until March 31, 2027, alongside an electricity rebate, with opposition members raising concerns about the Churchill Falls definitive agreements, a House vote before signing, and broader affordability issues such as rent, food security, and minimum wage. The debate was adjourned by the Government House Leader, after which Bill 29 (An Act Respecting Certain Cities in the Province) was introduced and read a first time, and Bill 30 (An Act Respecting Registered Professional Planners in the Province) was introduced with first reading only. The House then adjourned until Tuesday, November 3, at 1:30 p.m., with no substantive debate in the final segment.
Members' Statements
Smash Up for MS Derby fundraiser
E. Joyce
Recognized Gavin Butt and volunteers behind the 11-year Smash Up for MS demolition derby, which has raised over $60,000 for MS research and patients.
Passing of James Aylward
J. Power
Paid tribute to Jim Aylward, a Labrador West bush pilot and water bomber pilot for 30 years, who died September 6, 2026.
Educators and school staff in Lake Melville
K. Russell
Recognized educators, support staff, bus drivers and retired teachers in Lake Melville who continue to serve despite staffing shortages, calling for real action and resources.
Ernie Watkins and Twillingate Christmas hamper project
M. Butt
Recognized Ernie Watkins, a Twillingate entrepreneur and philanthropist, on the 10th anniversary of the community Christmas hamper project he helped grow.
Town of St. Mary's 60th anniversary
S. Gambin-Walsh
Congratulated the Town of St. Mary's on 60 years since incorporation and thanked past and present council and volunteers.
Routine Proceedings
Ministerial statement on municipal infrastructure funding
B. Petten
Stated approximately $73 million has been invested in municipal water and wastewater projects over the past year, with $123 million allocated over 10 years through the Canada Housing Infrastructure Fund.
Opposition response on municipal infrastructure
J. Parsons
Argued that the government has not delivered on its campaign promise of a multi-year municipal funding approach, noting fewer communities qualify for Multi-Year Capital Works and seven remaining get less money.
Water backlog and LSD of Queen's Cove
S. O'Leary
Cited a CBC report on Queen's Cove's drinking water difficulties and called for a long-term plan to address a $400-million backlog in water system maintenance and replacement.
Ministerial statement on 2026 wildfire season
P. Forsey
Thanked those who responded to the Labrador wildfires, cited over $7 million for firefighting resources and return of a fifth waterbomber, and announced the Community Wildfire Prevention and Mitigation Program deadline extended to November 30.
Opposition responses on wildfire preparedness
P. Parsons; J. Dinn
P. Parsons said gratitude is not a strategy and called for certainty of funding and staffing for rural communities. J. Dinn suggested hiring permanent wildfire prevention staff given longer, more intense fire seasons.
Tabling of documents
B. Petten; M. King
B. Petten tabled a letter to the Town of Deer Lake explaining the past 12-13 months of discussions. M. King tabled a document listing Route 480 projects from 2000 to 2026 with comparative spending figures, and Petten also tabled a response letter to M. King's questions.
Private member's resolution on red tape reduction (notice)
R. Balsom
Gave notice of a private member's resolution, 'Cutting Red Tape for Newfoundland and Labrador Businesses', seconded by the Minister of Red Tape Reduction, supporting the government's red tape efforts and aiming for an A grade on the CFIB report card.
Procedural notices of motion and bills
L. Parrott
Gave notice of the PMR for Wednesday, November 4; motions on sitting hours for November 3, 4 and 5; committee membership for Public Accounts and Privileges and Elections; and introduction of Bills 31, 32, 33 and 34 (Evidence Act, Workplace Health Safety and Compensation Act amendments, Cannabis Control Act).
Petition on new school in Cartwright
L. Dempster; B. Petten
Dempster petitioned for construction of a new Henry Gordon Academy in Cartwright, citing the cancelled project and a reported $65 million contractor lawsuit. Petten responded that the project was far over budget (about $60 million for 55 children) and would be rescoped.
Petition on public safety and bail enforcement
P. Parsons; H. Conway Ottenheimer
Parsons petitioned for stronger legislation, policing and sentencing against repeat offenders and criticized lack of progress on 'catch and release'. Minister Conway Ottenheimer cited policing, courts and sheriff's officer investments.
Petition on Churchill Falls agreements
F. Hutton; L. Parrott
Hutton petitioned for final Churchill River agreements to be returned to the House for a vote before signing, citing a broken referendum promise. Parrott responded defending the deal and urging members to listen to the Minister of Finance.
Point of order on unparliamentary remarks during petition responses
F. Hutton; L. Parrott; L. Dempster; The Speaker
Hutton raised a point of order over being accused of misleading people. Exchanges followed over the phrasing and a remark about manhood; the Speaker reserved ruling on the matter, then found no point of order or privilege in the disagreement.
Question Period
Churchill Falls: bringing the 17 definitive agreements back to the House for a vote before signing
Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by The Premier
The Premier said the material terms in Section 2.2 are negotiated and protected, that definitive agreements will be brought back to the House for a technical briefing and debate, and that an Oversight Committee will ensure they follow the agreed terms, without committing to a vote before signing.
Deputy Premier's remark that voting in the House is irrelevant
Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by The Premier
The Premier did not directly disavow the Deputy Premier's characterization, instead attacking the Opposition's prior MOU and stating the government brought an Independent Review Committee and a better deal.
Premier's disdain for the House and fear of bringing the final deal before MHAs
Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by The Premier
The Premier said the Opposition voted for the less favourable MOU and voted no to the better deal, and cited federal support for the agreement, without addressing whether the final deal would be brought to the House before signing.
Whether PC caucus knew the lead negotiator and legal advisor had left before the debate
Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by The Premier
The Premier redirected to benefits for the people of the province, arguing the Opposition's MOU would have meant less power, transmission, money and jobs, and did not address the negotiator departures.
Whether the Premier is afraid to bring the final agreements to the House; public support and caucus departures
Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by The Premier
The Premier said the public did not support the previous MOU and that an independent Review Committee's recommendations were followed, citing avoidance of $30 billion owing on Gull Island.
Minister's claim the Opposition misrepresented facts; whether Premier Furey was negotiating the deal
Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by Minister of Energy and Mines (L. Parrott)
The Minister said the former government never negotiated the definitive agreements and accused the Opposition of misrepresenting facts, without directly confirming that everything has been negotiated.
Section 4 Hydro-Québec sales: capacity factor not yet agreed in the agreement
Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by Minister of Energy and Mines (L. Parrott)
The Minister said the deal has better transmission, more power and jobs, and that the Opposition voted against it, without addressing the capacity factor being left to the definitive agreements.
Annex L hiring protocol not yet established
Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by Minister of Energy and Mines (L. Parrott)
The Minister said the benefits agreement is in place, committed to hiring at least 85 per cent Newfoundlanders and Labradorians, and that Newfoundlanders and Labradorians will be the primary beneficiaries.
Annex K dividend policies and remaining negotiations; whether everything has been negotiated
Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by Minister of Energy and Mines (L. Parrott)
The Minister said the DCIA represents the framework in its totality, that the material terms are locked in, and that the 17 agreements will be brought forward as they are negotiated, without addressing the specific annex references.
Gull Island executive construction committee and timelines for definitive agreements
Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by Minister of Energy and Mines (L. Parrott)
The Minister said when the government took over there were no talks with Quebec, criticized the former premier's 173 days in office, and stated the former government would not have met its timeline either.
Deer Lake health centre held up in a dispute with the town and the Mayor
Asked by J. Korab · Answered by Minister of Transportation and Infrastructure (B. Petten)
The Minister said the health centre will open and will not be used as a bargaining chip, that a highway access arrangement has been changed to a turn-in, and that other issues remain open for negotiation.
Minister of TCAR's role as former Deer Lake mayor in approving a town plan and public criticism of Mayor Ball
Asked by J. Korab · Answered by Minister of Tourism, Culture and Arts; Sport, Recreation and Parks (M. Goosney)
The Minister said the former administration allowed the highway access issue to happen, that the mayor contacted the Opposition Leader, and that the truth would come out, without directly answering whether he should have addressed the issue differently.
Electoral boundary redistribution: timeline and chairperson appointment
Asked by P. Parsons · Answered by Minister of Justice and Public Safety (H. Conway Ottenheimer)
The Minister said the government is committed to the independent process and respecting the roles of the Chief Justice and Speaker, and will provide a further update when able, without confirming the year-end deadline or a chair appointment.
Public safety and used needles in downtown St. John's
Asked by P. Parsons · Answered by Minister of Justice and Public Safety (H. Conway Ottenheimer)
The Minister said she toured downtown with the St. John's mayor and that a productive meeting with the mayor and the Downtown Safety Coalition was held that morning, with work underway toward positive results.
Accuracy of the government's housing construction numbers (874 new homes)
Asked by J. Dinn · Answered by Minister of Social Supports and Well-Being, and Housing (C. Tibbs)
The Minister cited January to September figures of 1,341 new builds and 857 completions, a 22 per cent increase over last year, and reaffirmed the 10,000-home goal, without clearly breaking down locations or non-profit versus private builds.
Enshrining housing as a human right in provincial legislation
Asked by J. Dinn · Answered by Minister of Social Supports and Well-Being, and Housing (C. Tibbs)
The Minister did not commit to enshrining housing as a human right, instead pointing to the 10,000-home goal, regular meetings with home builders, and expected economic growth requiring more housing.
Premier's credibility and trust in promises versus the previous government
Asked by J. Dinn · Answered by Minister of Social Supports and Well-Being, and Housing (C. Tibbs)
The Minister said the government is moving ahead with record investments and will work with the people of the province, without directly answering the question about trust.
Orders of the Day
Second reading of Bill 22, An Act to Amend the Revenue Administration Act No. 3 (gas tax)
S. Stoodley
Stoodley said the Opposition supports removing the gas tax but criticized the proposed price-threshold formula (around $89 US per barrel, set in regulations, assessed quarterly) as needlessly complex and noted CFIB opposition to Alberta's similar model. She urged an earlier effective date than December 1, 2026.
Churchill Falls agreements and Schedule F for fairness
S. Stoodley
Stoodley argued the government dropped the Schedule F fairness mechanism recommended by Power Advisory from the current agreements and said she would vote against a 50-year deal lacking protections against future material changes.
Churchill Falls negotiations and Muskrat Falls lessons
S. O'Leary
O'Leary expressed concern that Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro staff were largely not involved in drafting the current DCIA and were only briefed afterward, and urged government to apply Muskrat Falls inquiry lessons on relying on negotiator reputation and rigorous challenge of assumptions.
Churchill Falls definitive agreements: oversight, Government of Canada involvement, and House vote before signing
S. O’Leary
O'Leary urged that lessons from the Muskrat Falls inquiry be applied, including fully heeding Public Utilities Board advice if it is involved. He argued that the Premier's claim that everything is negotiated is untrue, citing new government references to agreements with the Government of Canada that briefings had said did not exist, and called for the definitive agreements to be brought back to the House for a vote before signing.
Churchill Falls: outstanding items to be negotiated (hiring protocols, dividend and financing policies, executive construction committee)
S. Stoodley
Stoodley said several elements remain undefined in the DCIA, including hiring protocols, dividend policies, the Executive Construction Committee's consultation scope and post-PPA financing policies. She argued the House should vote on the agreements before signing and that claims everything has been agreed are not accurate. She also praised the gas tax removal but said it should be removed fully in legislation rather than through the current complicated mechanism.
Revenue Administration Act: gas tax removal and the 15 per cent electricity rebate
B. Davis
Davis welcomed the gas tax removal but argued it starts too late (December 1 to March 31), estimating savings of about $3.45 per fill-up for a 40-litre vehicle and under $180 annually. He said the windfall revenue, estimated at $500 to $600 million and possibly $800 to $900 million, should fund more relief and that the tax break should be permanent with a sliding rather than all-or-nothing trigger tied to Brent crude below $89 a barrel. He also said the 15 per cent electricity rebate's 2,000 kilowatt cap was not clearly stated at the announcement and would leave many households, particularly those heating with electricity, under-protected.
Churchill Falls oversight, referendum promise, and the Premier's credibility
B. Davis
Davis questioned the independence of the three-member oversight committee, which he said was hand-picked by the Premier's office, and noted the Premier's campaign promise of a referendum before any Churchill Falls deal. He said the government should bring the agreement back to the House and that the 11 members who did not speak at the information session should now contribute.
Affordability, Churchill Falls conditions, and the Revenue Administration Act
J. Dinn
Dinn restated the NDP's three conditions on Churchill Falls: truly independent oversight, a House vote before signing, and Innu support. He said the gas tax cut is too narrow for affordability and that a broader plan is needed, citing transit, electrification, home heating HST removal and seniors' needs. He noted that people are increasingly frustrated with the Churchill Falls deal.
Rent increases, food insecurity, homelessness and housing policy
J. Dinn
Dinn cited community breakfast testimony that rent increases of $50 to $150 a month push families toward food banks, noted that many food bank users are employed, and cited the Dunn House model and public housing evidence. He called for rent and vacancy controls, a livable minimum wage, a guaranteed basic income committee, a publicly owned grocery store study, recognition of housing as a human right, and a 24/7 shelter model. He also said he would be attending the Canadian Alliance to End Homelessness conference and that the NDP will support tenant organizing.
Churchill Falls process: referendum promise, petition, and changes to the negotiating team
F. Hutton
Hutton said the Premier repeatedly promised a referendum before signing and broke that promise, leaving the public feeling deceived. He presented a petition and described constituent feedback opposing a 50-year deal without a vote. He questioned the departures of the chief negotiator and legal counsel, the claim that the deal is done, and the government's advertising, and asked that Members at least be given a final vote on the agreements if the public is not.
Speaker recognizes next speaker
The Speaker
The Speaker recognized the Member for St. John's East - Quidi Vidi to speak next.
Bill 22 – Affordability, rent control, basic living income, food security and mental health
S. O’Leary
The NDP critic welcomed the temporary gas tax relief in Bill 22 but urged broader affordability measures, including rent control, a public release of the basic living income report, and action on food bank demand. She read a constituent letter describing financial strain from rising rents and argued housing and mental health are linked to the economy.
Speaker’s reminder on forms of address
Speaker
The Speaker reminded the Member not to use names in debate and to use positions, titles and districts instead.
Bill 22 – Gas tax mechanism and Churchill Falls deal
J. Parsons
The Corner Brook MHA supported the gas tax reduction but criticized the fuel tax trigger tied to oil prices set by Cabinet regulation (initially $89), contrasting it with the predictability of the federal approach. He then raised detailed concerns about the Churchill Falls DCIA, including pricing under the cost-of-service model for Gull Island, equity and transmission costs, and the premium tranche, and called for the 17 definitive agreements to be debated in the House.
Bill 22 – Temporary gas tax relief and Churchill Falls deal
P. Pike
The Burin - Grand Bank MHA welcomed the removal of provincial gasoline tax but said it is temporary and should be tied to retail prices rather than Brent crude, and that relief should be applied more quickly and fully. He criticized the government’s handling of the Churchill Falls deal, its rushed timelines, the lack of an independent review, and unfulfilled commitments, and referenced past electricity rate mitigation.
Bill 22 – Gas tax timing, electricity rate mitigation and Churchill Falls deal
P. Parsons
The Harbour Grace - Port de Grave MHA noted Bill 22 as a money bill allowing broader debate, criticized the Muskrat Falls debt and the rate mitigation funding, and called for gas tax relief to start immediately. He read public feedback from NL HAVE YOUR SAY opposing the Churchill Falls deal and urged renegotiation. The Speaker and Government House Leader raised points of order on naming Members and quoting remarks, and the Speaker asked the Member to address the Chair.
Adjournment of debate on Bill 22
L. Parrott
The Government House Leader moved, seconded by the Member for Ferryland, that debate be adjourned; the motion was carried on a voice vote.
Introduction and first reading of Bill 29, An Act Respecting Certain Cities in the Province
L. Parrott
The Government House Leader moved, seconded by the Minister of Municipal and Community Affairs, for leave to introduce the bill and for first reading; the motion carried. The bill was read a first time, and second reading was set for tomorrow.
Bill 29 first reading
The Speaker
Bill 29 was read a first time and ordered read a second time on the following day.
Bill 30, An Act Respecting Registered Professional Planners in the Province – leave to introduce and first reading
L. Parrott
The Government House Leader, seconded by the Minister of Health and Community Services, moved for leave to introduce Bill 30; the House agreed, and the bill was read a first time with second reading set for the following day.
Motion to adjourn
L. Parrott
The Government House Leader moved, seconded by the Minister of Finance and President of Treasury Board, that the House adjourn; the motion carried and the House stood adjourned until Tuesday, November 3, at 1:30 p.m.
Other business
Visitor recognition in public gallery
The Speaker
Welcomed Mayor Rudy Norman of Burlington to the public gallery.
Point of order on unparliamentary language during Question Period
L. Parrott
Raised a point of order regarding the word 'lie' used by a member during QP; the Leader of the Official Opposition withdrew the language.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.