Hansard·Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly·

Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Monday 16 November 2026

Question Period was dominated by the Opposition's attacks on the government's handling of the media, with the Leader of the Opposition repeatedly pressing the Premier to disavow blanket statements that the media twist the narrative. The majority of the session focused on the Churchill Falls deal, where questions on Quebec's willingness to renegotiate, federal funding disparities, the lack of a referendum, and Hydro-Québec's pricing role went largely answered with political rebuttals. Other questions touched on safer communities in St. John's, minimum wage and food bank reliance, and a constituent health care issue. The sitting opened with Members' statements, ministerial statements honouring former MHA Lloyd Matthews and marking World Day of Remembrance for Road Traffic Victims, and a ministerial recognition of an educator's dyslexia award, alongside tabled notices of a Private Member's Motion on grocery costs, several petitions, and first reading of Bills 35 through 39. The main business was second reading of Bill 29, the Cities Act, which would replace the City of Corner Brook and City of Mount Pearl Acts with a more flexible framework; speakers from both sides broadly supported it while raising concerns about mandatory services, law enforcement titles, and amalgamation. The bill then proceeded to Committee of the Whole, where the Minister answered detailed Opposition questions on bylaw powers, council voting, budgets and audits, fire protection, tourism accommodation tax, and ministerial restructuring powers, with Committee reporting back several times and leave to sit again granted.

Read the official Hansard ↗

Members' Statements

Gingerbread House Christmas charity in Corner Brook

J. Parsons

Recognized the 45-year-old Gingerbread House charity at Valley Mall, sponsored by the Salvation Army, BayFM and Sterling Group, which collects gifts and donations for local children.

Fogo Island Academy soccer championships

J. McKenna

Congratulated Fogo Island Academy's girls' team on winning the provincial A-division soccer gold and the boys' team on earning a sportsmanship award.

Outport Woman book by Hayward and Raymond Blake

E. Loveless

Acknowledged the Blake brothers and their book Outport Woman, a tribute to the generations of women whose lives built the province's outports.

Eithne Daly and Gander Junior Firefighter Program

B. Ford

Recognized Eithne Daly for creating a junior firefighter program that has involved about 175 youth over 12 years, with 25 former participants later serving as firefighters.

Ally Cleary's Special Olympics coaching award

P. Parsons

Recognized Harbour Grace volunteer Ally Cleary, named Rising Star Coach of the Year at the Special Olympics Canada National Awards.

Tribute to Lloyd Matthews

Premier Wakeham; J. Hogan; J. Dinn

The Premier, Leader of the Official Opposition and Leader of the Third Party each paid tribute to Lloyd Matthews' public service, Cabinet roles, and community work, including co-founding the Children's Wish Foundation.

World Day of Remembrance for Road Traffic Victims

L. Parrott; K. White; J. Dinn

The Minister of Government Services marked the day and called for safer driving, with a moment of silence observed; the Official Opposition called for more police recruitment, stronger penalties and vehicle safety, and the Third Party shared a personal loss and urged government action.

Anne Beaumaster's Dyslexia Canada award

P. Dinn; P. Pike; J. Dinn

The Minister of Education recognized reading specialist Anne Beaumaster's 2026 Educational Excellence Award; the Official Opposition noted its prior introduction of the reading specialist role, and the Third Party called for more specialists to be hired.

Routine Proceedings

Notice of Private Member's Motion on grocery costs

J. Dinn; S. O'Leary

The Third Party gave notice of a motion calling for an all-party committee to study grocery prices and food affordability, to be tabled as a final report; the NDP confirmed it as their resolution for debate on November 18.

Petition on policing resources in Placentia region

S. Gambin-Walsh; H. Conway Ottenheimer

The Member for Placentia - St. Mary's presented a petition seeking a review of policing resources and enforcement in the Placentia area; the Minister of Justice responded by citing increased RCMP and RNC funding and an auxiliary police initiative.

Petition on personal care standards and in-room appliances

L. Stoyles; C. Pardy

The Member for Mount Pearl North presented a petition asking that residents be allowed small electrical appliances in their rooms under updated personal care standards; the Minister of Finance and Seniors said the standard was driven by fire and life safety concerns regarding wiring and that government is looking at mitigation.

Petition for a publicly owned non-profit grocery network

J. Dinn

The Third Party presented a petition asking government to study the viability of a publicly owned, non-profit grocery network to lower food prices and support local supply chains.

Petition on municipal operating grant

P. Pike

The Member for Burin - Grand Bank presented a petition asking government to adjust the Municipal Operating Grant to reflect rising costs for municipalities facing fuel, infrastructure, fire services and water costs.

Question Period

Premier's view on media 'twisting the narrative' and anti-media statements

Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by The Premier

The Premier did not directly address whether the media twists the narrative, instead pointing to government work, a $500-per-child affordability measure, and planning efforts. He did not commit to disavowing anti-media statements and turned to criticism of the Opposition's priorities.

Media commentary on podcasts and the government's accessibility to the press

Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by L. Parrott (Minister of Energy and Mines); The Premier

The Minister of Energy and Mines said the government has been accessible to the media and criticized the Leader of the Opposition's own past media conduct, while the Premier said the government focuses on plans rather than announcements and listed priorities before his time expired. No commitment was made to change how ministers engage with the press.

Minister's response to MHA for Mount Pearl North's health care constituent issue

Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by J. Wall (Minister of Health and Community Services)

The Minister said he answered the email on behalf of the Premier and the department, that officials have contacted the patient directly, and that the matter is being handled step by step.

Churchill Falls deal: Quebec renegotiation and lack of accountability or referendum

Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by The Premier; L. Parrott (Minister of Energy and Mines)

The Premier said he spoke with the Quebec premier, the material terms of the DCIA are done, and the deal will not be renegotiated; definitive agreements will reflect those terms. The Minister of Energy and Mines rebutted the Opposition on past Muskrat Falls and LeBlanc inquiry positions and said the government listened and brought back a better deal, with no commitment to an independent review or referendum.

Premier's exclusion from Quebec-federal Churchill Falls discussions and referendum promise

Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by The Premier; L. Parrott (Minister of Energy and Mines)

The Premier said he had no concerns because the federal Prime Minister has delivered, and cited $3.5 billion in federal support and a 2,000 MW wind commitment, criticizing the Opposition's prior MOU. The Minister of Energy and Mines quoted the Opposition Leader's past support for the 2024 deal and said the Opposition voted against it; no referendum commitment was made.

Federal investment disparity between Quebec and Newfoundland and Labrador

Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by C. Pardy (Minister of Finance and President of Treasury Board)

The Minister of Finance said Quebec receives more federal money because it spends more, including on Gull Island, while Newfoundland and Labrador receives $3.5 billion in equity and an 8.5 per cent return, and Annex D shows rising annual payments reaching $1 billion by 2033. He did not provide a dollar valuation of the Churchill Falls resource.

Value of Churchill Falls resource and whether the government sold it short

Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by L. Parrott (Minister of Energy and Mines)

The Minister of Energy and Mines listed benefits including Gull Island, Kami, the Labrador Trough, an $8.5 billion Goose Bay investment and attracting people, and rejected the claim as imaginary narratives. He did not directly answer whether the resource was undervalued.

Quebec electricity shortage and leverage over the Churchill Falls deal

Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by L. Parrott (Minister of Energy and Mines)

The Minister acknowledged hydroelectric fluctuations and cited a 150 per cent premium trough allowing higher prices in tight periods, but did not commit to renegotiating for market-based pricing.

Contingency if NECEC and CHPE contracts lapse and Quebec stops exporting to US

Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by L. Parrott (Minister of Energy and Mines)

The Minister said the province would use the power for industrial purposes at home if it is not sold to Quebec or exported, and pointed to attracting mines and offshore oil and gas. He did not address the contract expiry question directly.

Section 4(f) pricing role of Hydro-Québec for 521 MW and deal fairness

Asked by J. Hogan · Answered by The Premier

The Premier said the deal lets the province retain power and choose whether to sell to Quebec, and that the province will no longer subsidize Quebec's cheaper sales, adding the province will get the same price. He did not address the Section 4(f) pricing mechanism specifically.

Crime and the RNC buddy-system warning in downtown St. John's

Asked by P. Parsons · Answered by H. Conway Ottenheimer (Minister of Justice and Public Safety)

The Minister said the government is committed to safer communities, that he toured downtown St. John's with the mayor, and cited record investments in the criminal justice system. He did not address the buddy-system warning directly.

Minimum wage increase and food bank reliance

Asked by J. Dinn · Answered by C. Pardy (Minister of Finance and President of Treasury Board)

The Minister of Finance said every affordability measure is on the table before the next budget and the government wants to do more, but is constrained by its finances. He made no commitment to raise the minimum wage.

Requirement that individuals use food banks before receiving food vouchers

Asked by J. Dinn · Answered by C. Tibbs (Minister of Social Supports and Well-Being)

The Minister said using community food outlets is recommended but not required, that the government will be there for people, and that legislation can be reviewed. No commitment was made to change the policy.

Public confidence in the Churchill Falls deal amid Quebec renegotiation reports

Asked by S. O’Leary · Answered by The Premier

The Premier defended the deal as new and better, credited the federal government, and cited $273 billion in value over time. He did not address the Quebec renegotiation reports directly or the public trust concerns.

Orders of the Day

First reading of Bills 35, 36, 37, 38 and 39

L. Parrott; The Speaker

The Government House Leader moved first reading of Bill 35 (Tobacco and Vapour Products Control Act amendments), Bill 36 (Pension Benefits Act amendments), Bill 37 (Highway Traffic Act amendments), Bill 38 (Hague Convention on child support recovery) and Bill 39 (Safer Communities and Neighbourhoods Act amendments); all were carried and ordered read a second time on the following day.

Motion that the House not adjourn at 5:30 p.m.

L. Parrott

The Government House Leader moved, under Standing Order 11(1), that the House not adjourn at 5:30 p.m. on Monday, November 16, 2026, and the motion was carried.

Second reading of Bill 29, the Cities Act

L. Parrott; B. Petten; J. Parsons

The Government House Leader moved second reading of Bill 29; the Minister of Municipal and Community Affairs explained it would repeal and replace the Corner Brook and Mount Pearl acts, create a modern framework for future cities, and expand municipal flexibility, transparency and revenue tools. The Member for Corner Brook welcomed the bill, noting its basis in the Towns and Local Service Districts Act and its flexibility on bylaws and ministerial approvals, and debate was ongoing at the end of this part.

Second reading debate on Bill 29, the Cities Act: opening remarks

J. Parsons

Parsons supported the bill's move toward municipal autonomy and subsidiarity, while flagging concerns about mandatory services, the change from peace officer to bylaw enforcement officer titles, and lessons from the Towns and Local Service Districts Act, and suggested the minister consult staff before Committee.

Second reading debate on Bill 29: support for the bill

J. Power

Power supported the bill as a modern, flexible framework for cities including Corner Brook, Mount Pearl and future cities, emphasizing accessibility, transparency, regional co-operation and economic benefits.

Second reading debate on Bill 29: concerns about amalgamation and land transfers

L. Stoyles

Stoyles raised concerns that the act could enable amalgamation of Mount Pearl and transfers of municipal land without public hearings or consultation, and criticized past treatment of Mount Pearl in capital works funding.

Second reading debate on Bill 29: support for modernization and consultation

M. Butt

Butt supported the bill as the result of consultation with both cities, providing plain-language, online-accessible bylaws, clearly defined mandatory services, fee-for-service regional options, and new financial tools, while keeping provincial oversight.

Second reading debate on Bill 29: relief from ministerial handcuffs and housing

S. O'Leary

O'Leary supported the bill as giving municipalities more authority on routine decisions, citing expropriation without ministerial approval and water conservation powers, and referenced a discussion with the mayor of St. Thomas about housing and homelessness.

Second reading closing remarks and vote

The Minister of Municipal and Community Affairs (B. Petten)

Petten thanked speakers and staff, said there is no desire for amalgamation, and stated Mount Pearl's mayor was pleased with the bill; the motion for second reading was carried and the bill was referred to Committee of the Whole.

Motion to resolve into Committee of the Whole on Bill 29

L. Parrott

The Government House Leader moved that the House resolve into Committee of the Whole to consider Bill 29; the motion was carried.

Committee of the Whole: bylaw powers and mandatory services

J. Parsons and B. Petten

Parsons asked how bylaw powers under sections 7 and 8 differ from the Towns and Local Service Districts Act and whether mandatory services such as snow clearing could be limited by bylaw; Petten said bylaw authority is enabling, mandatory services are expected, and service levels are ultimately judged by residents.

Committee of the Whole: definition of local roadways and liability for mandatory services

J. Parsons and B. Petten

Parsons asked whether the local roadways definition is physical jurisdiction or ownership and raised liability concerns about undefined service standards for mandatory services; Petten said the definition reflects existing responsibilities and that the act is intended to be enabling rather than prescriptive.

Committee of the Whole: fire protection reference to City of St. John's Act

J. Parsons and B. Petten

Parsons asked why section 161 references the City of St. John's Act; Petten explained the reference applies only to Mount Pearl, which receives fire services from St. John's under a fee arrangement that the city is content with, and does not affect Corner Brook.

Committee of the Whole: private meetings under section 41

J. Parsons and B. Petten

Parsons questioned why section 41 limits private meeting protection to personal information when other protected information exists; Petten said the provision was reviewed under ATIPPA and is intended to provide clarity and curb overuse of private meetings.

Committee of the Whole: funding for cities under the act

S. O'Leary and B. Petten

O'Leary asked whether new funding or grants accompany the expanded powers; Petten said no specified funding is attached and existing grant arrangements continue.

Committee of the Whole: affordable housing provisions

S. O'Leary and B. Petten

O'Leary asked whether the bill helps deliver affordable housing; Petten said nothing in the bill directly addresses housing, pointing instead to federal and provincial housing programs and noting the city is the legal person rather than the council.

Committee of the Whole: definition of remuneration

S. O'Leary and B. Petten

O'Leary asked what remuneration beyond pension contributions the definition in section 2(ee) covers; Petten said the provision is enabling and details would be decided by each city.

Committee of the Whole: feasibility reports under section 15

S. O'Leary

O'Leary asked which situations would require feasibility reports under section 15 now that the minister has discretion over them and whether any requirement would be waived; the minister had not yet responded when this part of the transcript ends.

Committee of the Whole: Bill 29, An Act Respecting Certain Cities in the Province, clause-by-clause questions

Multiple

Members questioned the Minister of Municipal and Community Affairs on provisions including ministerial discretion over municipal studies, at-large councillors, abstentions and tie votes, conflict-of-interest appeals, financial signing authorities, budget revisions, audit deadlines, tax sale conveyances, minimum service standards, bylaw enforcement officers' peace officer status, tourism accommodation tax use, fire services, and civic address numbering. The Minister responded that many provisions are enabling or carried over from existing legislation and undertook to follow up on certain points.

Committee of the Whole: interim report and recess

Government House Leader (L. Parrott)

The Government House Leader moved that Committee rise and report progress and ask leave to sit again, which carried, and the Chair of Committee reported progress. The House then recessed and resumed to call Bill 29 to Committee of the Whole.

Committee of the Whole: Bill 29 clause 1 and new cities provisions (second sitting)

Multiple

Committee resumed on clause 1, where the Member for Corner Brook sought confirmation that bylaw enforcement officers retain peace officer status under the Highway Traffic Act and Off-Road Vehicles Act; the Minister said those acts are unaffected. The Member for Virginia Waters - Pleasantville then asked about the new section enabling city creation, annexation, boundary alteration and disincorporation; the Minister said the provision is enabling, driven by municipal requests, and intended as a protective backstop. Committee then rose, reported progress and asked leave to sit again, and the House recessed until 6:30 p.m.

Other business

Passing of former MHA Lloyd Matthews

The Speaker

The Speaker acknowledged the passing of Lloyd Matthews, former MHA for St. John's North and Cabinet Minister, and offered condolences.

This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.