Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Tuesday 14 May 1996
The House returned from its break and was dominated by the government's post-secondary cuts, which closed several college campuses and first-year university programs in rural areas, and by the Opposition's attacks on the decision and on the Premier's handling of consultation. Members also presented petitions on the Carbonear campus, a proposed Newfoundland Power rate increase and the closure of St. Joseph's School in Harbour Main. The afternoon ended with the Address in Reply debate, in which several members spoke for their districts before Mr. Shelley adjourned debate.
Routine Proceedings
Petition on first-year university at Carbonear
Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Harris, Mr. Grimes
Mr. Sullivan presented a petition of about 10,000 signatures asking the government to withdraw the Carbonear campus cuts and support the Baccalieu Trail Chamber of Commerce. Mr. Harris supported it, and Mr. Grimes said the cuts were part of a wider budget and that the college boards were working on alternate delivery options.
Petition opposing Newfoundland Power rate increase
Mr. E. Byrne, Mr. Fitzgerald
Mr. E. Byrne presented a petition asking the government to prevent a Newfoundland Power rate increase, citing the company's profit and the impact of PST-GST harmonization. Mr. Fitzgerald presented a similar petition from Bonavista South, arguing that low-income residents would be hurt and that the utility's profit was excessive.
Closure of St. Joseph's School, Harbour Main
Mr. Whelan, Mr. French, Mr. Grimes
Mr. Whelan asked the Minister of Education to reverse the school board's decision to close St. Joseph's School in Harbour Main. Mr. French raised concerns about funding and repairs at Holy Cross School in Holyrood. Mr. Grimes said the government had not asked any board to close a school, that the board had made the decision, and that the department's only option had been to allow borrowing.
Question Period
College campus closures and the government's post-secondary education decision
Mr. Sullivan, Premier Tobin, Mr. Grimes, Mr. Ottenheimer
Mr. Sullivan asked whether the Premier agreed that there was no particular crisis in post-secondary education, and questioned the consultation and planning behind the closure of five campuses and first-year university courses. The Premier defended the cuts as a response to a deficit, and Mr. Grimes said a new single college board would review course offerings and report quickly.
Framework agreement on education reform
Asked by Mr. Ottenheimer · Answered by Premier Tobin
Mr. Ottenheimer asked whether a framework agreement on education reform existed, citing conflicting statements. The Premier said a framework agreement sets parameters for discussion with the DECs, that implementation was still under negotiation, and asked whether the Opposition would join a delegation to Ottawa to pass the constitutional amendment.
Hiring of a former MHA as a consultant
Asked by Mr. E. Byrne · Answered by Premier Tobin
Mr. E. Byrne alleged that a contract given to a former Conception Bay South MHA was political patronage intended to bridge her to a pension. The Premier replied that he had hired former Premier Tom Rideout during the turbot war, and accused the Opposition of partisanship.
Orders of the Day
Address in Reply to the Throne Speech
Mr. Tulk, Mr. J. Byrne, Mr. Wiseman, Mr. Sparrow, Ms Thistle
The Government House Leader moved to proceed to the Address in Reply. Mr. J. Byrne criticized the Throne Speech on education, health care, the public service, the mineral tax and Hibernia benefits. Government members spoke about their districts, including Mr. Wiseman on Topsail and water and sewer funding, Mr. Sparrow on Placentia-St. Mary's and road and port development, and Ms Thistle on debt, Buchans aquaculture and Grand Falls-Windsor as a college headquarters site.
Experimental shrimp and crab fisheries
Mr. Shelley, Mr. Efford, Ms Thistle
Ms Thistle praised the Minister of Fisheries and Aquaculture's announcement of experimental shrimp and king crab fisheries. Mr. Shelley asked how many direct jobs would result, and Mr. Efford said six experimental licences in shrimp and five commercial crab licences would create roughly twenty-plus jobs on the boats, plus processing work.
Grand Falls-Windsor college proposal and first-year university access
Ms Thistle, Mr. Shelley
Ms Thistle urged the minister to restore first-year university in Grand Falls-Windsor and to designate the town as the site of the provincial college headquarters at no cost to government. Mr. Shelley supported that and argued that removing first-year courses would discourage rural young people from pursuing post-secondary education.
Consultation on the Budget and the hiring of a consultant
Mr. Shelley
Mr. Shelley criticized the government's consultation process, the hiring of a consultant at a daily rate, and the lack of caucus consultation on the college closures. He then adjourned debate on the Address in Reply.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.