Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Monday 10 June 1996
The House spent the day on the Trans City contract controversy, with the Opposition pressing the Premier for a judicial inquiry after a Newfoundland appeal ruling on the award, which the Premier refused. Members also debated a petition on the Newfoundland Power rate increase, a proposed $61 monthly cut to social assistance, and the food fishery, and the House concluded the Resource Estimates and Social Services Estimates concurrence debates, with both reports carried. Members speaking included Mr. Sullivan, Premier Tobin, Mr. Ottenheimer, Mr. Fitzgerald, Mr. H. Hodder, Mr. Shelley, Mr. E. Byrne, Mr. Efford, Mr. Osborne, Mr. Harris and Mr. Ramsay.
Routine Proceedings
Newfoundland Power rate increase petition
Mr. Fitzgerald, Mr. H. Hodder
Members presented and spoke to petitions opposing a proposed 4.9 per cent rate increase by Newfoundland Power, arguing the utility's profits were excessive and that low-income and unemployed households in older, poorly insulated homes would be hardest hit.
Food fishery petition and the fishery's treatment across the Atlantic Provinces
Mr. Shelley, Mr. E. Byrne, Mr. Efford
Mr. Shelley presented petitions calling for a food fishery for Newfoundlanders and argued that residents of other Atlantic Provinces and foreign vessels were allowed to fish. Mr. E. Byrne said the federal government should apply equal rules across the region, and Minister Efford said a food fishery needed to be weighed against conservation and the rebuilding of the groundfish stock.
Question Period
Trans City contract and call for a judicial inquiry
Mr. Sullivan, Premier Tobin, Mr. Ottenheimer
The Opposition Leader asked the Premier to order a judicial inquiry after a Newfoundland Court of Appeal decision on a multi-million-dollar contract awarded to Trans City in breach of the Public Tender Act. The Premier refused, arguing the courts had already dealt with the matter and that any allegations should be made publicly or referred to the RCMP. Mr. Ottenheimer asked whether the Attorney General and Minister of Justice should be removed from the affair, and the questions drew repeated heated exchanges.
Orders of the Day
Social assistance $61 monthly reduction
Mr. Fitzgerald, Mr. H. Hodder, Mr. Harris, Mr. Ramsay
Opposition members condemned the Budget's withdrawal of a $61 monthly supplement under the Social Services regulations, saying it fell on the poorest residents and that the clawbacks and overpayment practices were unfair. Mr. Ramsay defended the Budget as necessary to protect the basic social assistance program, and Mr. H. Hodder cited the Auditor General's criticisms of the department's computer system spending.
Resource Estimates concurrence debate
Mr. Efford, Mr. Shelley, Mr. Osborne, Mr. Fitzgerald, Mr. E. Byrne
Members debated the Resource Committee report, covering crab processing licences and quotas, shrimp processing, forestry job losses in Baie Verte, seal predation, the Argentia cleanup, the trans-shipment site, aquaculture funding and the Marystown natural gas conversion promise. The debate ended when the time limit expired, and the motion on the report of the Resource Estimates Committee was carried.
Social Services Estimates concurrence debate
Mr. Tulk, Mr. Harris, Mr. H. Hodder, Mr. Ramsay, Mr. Mercer
The House moved to the Social Services concurrence debate. Members discussed the Budget's effect on social assistance recipients, overpayment and clawback problems, rent top-ups, and information technology spending, while government members defended the Budget's priorities. The motion on the report of the Social Services Estimates Committee was carried.
Western Community Health Care Corporation budget pressures
Mr. Mercer
Mr. Mercer reported on a weekend meeting of the Western Community Health Care Corporation board, which had been guaranteed flat funding for two years and planned public consultation and invited MHAs to take part in making difficult spending decisions.
Medical school tuition increase at Memorial University
Mr. E. Byrne, Mr. Matthews
Mr. E. Byrne argued that the proposed rise in Faculty of Medicine tuition, from about $2,500 to $8,000 a year, was neither gradual nor comparable with other Canadian medical schools, and he set out estimated student expenses against available aid. He said the change would deter students without family wealth. Mr. Matthews and others challenged the comparison, which Mr. Byrne rejected.
Government's Budget defence and priorities
Mr. Ramsay, Mr. Harris, Mr. Fitzgerald
Mr. Ramsay said the government had made difficult but necessary choices after public consultation and pointed to vocational and education programs. Mr. Harris criticized the government for presiding over cuts to health, education and social services, and said the Opposition's own platform had lacked a budget plan.
Opposition criticism of the Budget and the Liberal platform
Mr. Harris, Mr. Osborne
Mr. Harris criticized the Liberal campaign platform for failing to disclose planned cuts, and the Budget's tax and spending choices more generally. Mr. Osborne raised economic concerns about interprovincial trade and tax harmonization, the loss of skilled young people, and industries that might relocate.
Auditor General's findings on Social Services computer systems
Mr. H. Hodder, Mr. Harris
Mr. H. Hodder and Mr. Harris cited the Auditor General's report on the Integrated Delivery System and information technology spending in the Department of Social Services, arguing that large sums had been wasted and that the savings should have come from there rather than from social assistance recipients.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.