Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Tuesday 4 May 1999
The House heard question period on the Strategic Social Plan, teacher allocations and their effect on programs, child protection staffing, and school busing in St. John's, along with a petition on a Bonavista road. The Finance Minister described how a fund for hospital construction would be used through private-sector tenders, and debate on the 1999 Budget continued with members raising shipbuilding, Churchill Falls, health care, education, and rural roads. Mr. Mercer adjourned debate for the day, and the Government House Leader then took the floor.
Question Period
Strategic Social Plan demonstration project funding
Asked by Ms Bettney · Answered by Mr. Harris
The Minister of Human Resources and Employment announced that a $1.2 million fund for demonstration projects under the Strategic Social Plan was open for proposals, with grants normally capped at $25,000 and funding running to March 31, 2000, and also described a research data system for 400 communities. Mr. Harris criticized the plan as jargon-heavy and said the government should address poverty and family hardship directly instead of commissioning more reports.
Teacher allocations and impact on programming
Asked by Mr. E. Byrne · Answered by Ms Foote
Mr. Byrne pressed the Minister of Education on whether she knew, before teacher allocations were made, that losing about thirty teaching units in District 5 would affect programs, and cited board-level losses and course cuts such as a computer technology moratorium and alternating chemistry and physics. The minister said she would look at any impact on programming if one was found.
Child protection staffing and a child's safety
Asked by Ms S. Osborne · Answered by Ms J.M. Aylward
Ms Osborne asked why child protection lacked personnel to monitor a case involving a two-year-old child and an alleged offender, and why the government had investigators for welfare checks but not child protection. The Minister of Health and Community Services said she was shocked not to have been informed, asked for the details so she could act, and expressed full confidence in the social workers and the system.
School busing in St. John's
Asked by Mr. Harris · Answered by Ms Foote
Mr. Harris asked whether students affected by school reorganization in St. John's would keep busing and whether the government would end what he called discrimination against St. John's families in busing eligibility. The Minister of Education said public transit is the main consideration in urban areas, that Corner Brook has a similar policy, and that she would meet the Avalon East School Board chair about safety concerns.
Protecting drinking water and Gisborne Lake
Asked by Mr. T. Osborne · Answered by Mr. Harris
Mr. T. Osborne argued that the government had not given away water from Gisborne Lake only because a federal ban was in place, and called for protecting water and natural resources for future generations. Mr. Harris, responding to the minister's statement, said it did not address conservation or protection of water sources.
Orders of the Day
Marystown Shipyard and national shipbuilding policy
Mr. H. Hodder
Mr. Hodder, in the Budget debate, raised concerns about the Marystown Shipyard's reduced workforce and planned relocation of some operations, and urged the provincial government to press Ottawa for a national shipbuilding policy and the summit promised in 1993. He also noted the Terra Nova project's limited benefit to Marystown.
Churchill Falls and Lower Churchill negotiations
Mr. H. Hodder
Mr. Hodder said Lower Churchill proposals should be analyzed by experts, that the process should be more open and transparent, and that full disclosure of the final contract is important. He also referred to a reported disagreement between federal and provincial representatives.
Budget debate on education cuts and teacher morale
Mr. Shelley
Mr. Shelley, in the Budget debate, called the budget unfair and argued that teacher cuts, closures and low morale would harm students, particularly through reductions in music, art and physical education. He also accused the government of a policy reversal after a federal meeting, referring to a 'woodshed' session with the Prime Minister.
Rural health care, doctors and hospital governance
Mr. Fitzgerald
In the Budget debate, Mr. Fitzgerald cited Bonavista hospital doctors leaving, pay differences between class A and class B hospitals, and called for elected hospital boards. He also raised the impact of out-migration, EI surplus concerns, and the need for rural road paving.
Health care spending and nursing working conditions
Mr. Mercer
Mr. Mercer, in the Budget debate, argued that health care is the government's number one priority, citing spending of about one-third of the budget, and defended the regional health boards. He also described nursing working conditions at Western Memorial Hospital raised by constituents, including staffing and casualization concerns, before adjourning debate for the day.
Other business
Hospital construction funding from the capital fund
Mr. Dicks, Ms Kelly
The Minister of Finance explained that the Harbour Breton Hospital would be paid for through the regular capital works program, while the remaining fund money would go to hospitals at Fogo, Bonne Bay and Grand Bank through private-sector tenders with set repurchase terms and a bid based on monthly lease payments. Ms Kelly tabled information requested the previous day.
Petition on Route 235 road conditions near Bonavista
Mr. Fitzgerald
Mr. Fitzgerald presented a petition from students and staff of Matthew Elementary School, and residents of Bonavista South, asking the government to upgrade and pave Route 235 between Birchy Cove and Bonavista because of hazards to school buses and damage to vehicles. He asked the minister to take the petition seriously.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.