Hansard·Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly·Session 1, GA 44·

Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Friday 14 May 1999

The House sat on May 14, 1999, with Question Period dominated by the Health Minister's demand that the Member for Ferryland apologize over remarks about Hoyles Escasoni, and by opposition criticism of the Education Minister over teacher cuts, special needs services and school trustee vacancies. Ministers also made statements on school construction and offshore oil drilling, and the Marystown Shipyard contract was questioned. In Committee of the Whole on Supply, the Placentia & St. Mary's member pressed Executive Council and Government House budget questions and raised out-migration figures, and the House adjourned until Monday at 2:00 p.m.

Read the official Hansard ↗

Question Period

Demand that the Member for Ferryland apologize over Hoyles Escasoni remarks

Ms J.M. Aylward

The Health Minister called on the Member for Ferryland to apologize publicly and retract criticism of care at Hoyles Escasoni, citing the board CEO's view that the draft report was unfinished and had been taken out of context. The member was not present in the House.

Teacher allocation cuts and impact on schools

Ms Foote, Mr. Hedderson, Mr. H. Hodder, Premier Tobin

The Education Minister said the reduction of 182 teachers was under review and that legitimate concerns from boards, principals and parents would be addressed. Opposition members cited specific school losses at Grand Falls Academy and Lewisporte Primary, and asked whether the minister would apologize for remarks about teachers and principals. The Premier accused the opposition of playing politics on the issue.

Special needs education and proposed round table

Asked by Mr. H. Hodder · Answered by Ms Foote

The opposition asked when the promised round table on special needs children would be held and whether access to services would be based on need. The Education Minister said more special education teachers had been added and that a round table was being considered.

School trustee vacancies

Asked by Mr. H. Hodder · Answered by Ms Foote

The opposition asked how the government would fill school trustee vacancies. The minister said by-elections would be called where seats had been filled and then vacated, and that seats left unfilled after elections would be filled by appointment under the act.

Ministerial statement on school construction and renovations

Ms Foote, Mr. Hedderson, Mr. Harris

The Education Minister reported on progress with school construction and renovations funded by commitments of $50 million and $75 million, including new schools in Hopedale and Rigolet. Opposition members questioned whether the new schools would be adequately staffed and raised needs at St. Augustine's in St. John's.

Ministerial statement on offshore drilling activity

Mr. Grimes, Mr. Ottenheimer, Mr. Harris

The Mines and Energy Minister outlined offshore exploration commitments of about $500 million since 1995, active rigs, Hibernia production and expected output by 2004. The opposition asked for more detail on benefits to the Province and raised concerns about any shared environmental review jurisdiction.

Quebec power contract and Twin Falls arrangement

Asked by Mr. Harris · Answered by Mr. Ottenheimer

The Premier had announced the final contract for winter availability and a Twin Falls power component. The opposition welcomed the upfront benefits but asked for full details and a review of what the Province gave in return.

Public access to waterways and river-specific licences

Mr. Collins

The Bonavista South member thanked the minister for an advance copy of the statement and said public concern about privatization of waterways, particularly over river-specific licences, must be addressed.

Refusal to table Marystown Shipyard contract with Friede Goldman

Asked by Mr. French · Answered by Ms Kelly

The Conception Bay South member asked why the contract for the sale of the Marystown Shipyard for $1 could not be tabled. The Industry Minister said legal advice treated it as a commercial agreement with a confidentiality clause, and that questions were being answered with the company's permission. A point of order over a remark by the member was ruled out of order.

Other business

Pay equity anomalies in the classification system

Mr. Harris

The Signal Hill-Quidi Vidi member argued that pay anomalies, such as Cook I being paid more than Cook II, resulted from a classification review that left male-dominated positions unexamined. He urged the government to act quickly.

Road repair petition for Newmans Cove area

Mr. Fitzgerald

The Bonavista South member presented a petition on a deteriorated road in the Newmans Cove area, saying it lacked proper base and rock and needed urgent repair. He said teachers, principals and bus operators had made the case to officials.

Executive Council and Government House estimates

Mr. Manning, Ms Thistle, Mr. Tulk, Mr. Barrett, Mr. Efford

In Committee of the Whole on Supply, the Placentia & St. Mary's member questioned line-item changes in the Premier's Office, Social Policy Analysis and Offshore Fund budgets, and asked whether Government House could be afforded given its salary costs. The Minister of Industry, Trade and Technology answered questions on Opening Doors and French language programs and on professional services savings. Exchanges grew heated over the Member for Lewisporte's stance on fisheries licence buy-backs and early retirement.

Out-migration figures and the record of the government

Mr. Manning, Mr. Tulk, Mr. Efford

Mr. Manning read net out-migration figures from 1990-1991 to 1997-1998, totalling 44,388 people during the government's time in power, and argued the trend was a major concern. Mr. Tulk and Mr. Efford rejected the criticism, citing Liberal fisheries policy and the record of the previous federal and provincial administrations.

Adjournment of the House

Mr. Tulk

The Government House Leader noted that three heads of estimates remained with time limits and moved that the House adjourn until Monday at 2:00 p.m. The motion was carried.

This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.