Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Thursday 3 June 2004
The House sat late into the night on June 3, 2004, and the government used the day to push three bills through the Committee of the Whole stage: Bill 26 on an auction system for fish, Bill 31 on consolidating school boards from eleven to five, and Bill 30 on auto insurance reform. Opposition members, led by Grimes, Parsons, Harris and Reid, criticized the shrimp auction bill as too broad and the insurance changes as unclear, while government members including E. Byrne, Taylor, Whalen and Hedderson defended the legislation. Bill 31 passed without amendment and was read a third time, and the House adjourned until Monday, June 7.
Members' Statements
60th anniversary of D-Day
Mr. T. Marshall
Mr. Marshall marked the 60th anniversary of D-Day, noted the role of Newfoundland and Labrador soldiers in the Battle of Normandy, and encouraged residents to attend the commemorations.
Routine Proceedings
Tabling of departmental and agency reports
Mr. E. Byrne
Mr. E. Byrne tabled annual reports for the Department of Forest Resources and Agrifoods, the Livestock Owners Compensation Board, the Crop Insurance Agency, the former Department of Mines and Energy, and a report on mining, mineral and surface leases for 2003-2004.
Petition on behalf of Public Service Pensioners
Ms Foote
Ms Foote presented a petition from public service pensioners, who complained of long gaps without pension increases and of being used as pawns in the last strike.
Consolidation of school boards and the Grand Falls-Buchans bid
Ms Thistle
Ms Thistle criticized the government for not setting out criteria for choosing the school board headquarters, arguing that the Grand Falls-Buchans area was passed over in favour of Gander.
Question Period
Shrimp auction legislation and the Government's authority over fish species
Asked by Mr. Reid · Answered by Mr. Taylor
Mr. Reid asked the Minister of Fisheries to confirm that the bill would allow a mandatory auction for all fish species, not a voluntary shrimp pilot as described. Mr. Taylor defended the initiative as a way to change a shrimp fishery plagued by tie-ups and shutdowns.
Auto insurance reform and treatment of seniors
Asked by Mr. Parsons · Answered by Ms Whalen
Mr. Parsons asked why the age discrimination piece had been dropped from Bill 30 and why Newfoundland and Labrador alone rejected claim caps. Ms Whalen said the reforms would save drivers an average of 15 per cent and defended the deductible recommended by the 1998 select committee.
Public Utilities Board role in auto insurance policy
Asked by Mr. Parsons · Answered by Mr. Harris
Mr. Parsons asked the Minister of Justice why the government was asking the Public Utilities Board to make policy on auto insurance instead of doing so itself. Mr. Harris asked whether the government would follow the New Brunswick all-party committee model, which studied start-up costs, operating costs and coverage options for a public system.
Atlantic Accord commitment from Ottawa
Asked by Mr. Grimes · Answered by Mr. E. Byrne
Mr. Grimes asked what the government planned to do to secure a federal commitment on the Atlantic Accord in the coming weeks. Mr. E. Byrne responded that the Premier was preparing the federal ministers' position and criticized the Opposition Leader's approach.
Arnold's Cove fish plant and fish quota
Mr. Harris
Mr. Harris urged the government to ensure that fish quota would not be moved away from the Arnold's Cove plant and to find a use that would keep the workers employed.
Orders of the Day
Bill 31, An Act To Amend The Schools Act, 1997 (school board consolidation)
Mr. Hedderson, Ms Thistle, Mr. Grimes, Mr. Parsons, Mr. Barrett, Mr. Jackman, Mr. Wiseman, Mr. Harris
The government argued the bill is a housekeeping measure to make new school boards successors in law as eleven boards become five, citing savings and a smooth transition. Opposition members questioned the lack of clear answers on dissolved boards, board headquarters, leases, and rural representation, and the bill was voted through in Committee without amendment, read a third time, and passed.
Bill 30, An Act To Amend The Automobile Insurance Act (auto insurance reform)
Mr. Parsons, Ms Whalen, Mr. Harris, Mr. Langdon, Mr. Grimes
Opposition members criticized the removal of the age discrimination provision, the choice of a deductible rather than caps or a public or no-fault system, and the use of the Public Utilities Board for policy decisions. Minister Whalen said the reforms would save drivers an average of 15 per cent, and Mr. Harris reported that insurers were threatening to leave the Province.
Bill 26, An Act To Amend The Fishing Industry Collective Bargaining Act (shrimp auction)
Mr. E. Byrne, Ms Jones, Mr. Taylor, Mr. Reid, Mr. Harris, Mr. Langdon, Mr. Grimes
The bill would allow an auction system for fish that the minister could apply to any species at his discretion. Opposition members said it should be optional and limited to a shrimp pilot project, with Mr. Reid arguing it would not suit small harvesters, while Mr. Taylor said it was needed to break stalemates and proposed a sunset clause ending December 31, 2005. Committee rose and reported progress, and the debate resumed after the supper recess.
Other business
Adjournment of the House
Mr. Speaker
The House adjourned until Monday, June 7, 2004, at 1:30 p.m.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.