Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Monday 7 June 2004
The House sat on June 7, 2004, with question period dominated by the Premier's announced deal to receive 100 per cent of offshore oil and gas revenues under the Atlantic Accord, which the Opposition questioned. The government also pushed through several bills in Committee of the Whole: Bill 26 on shrimp sales and collective bargaining, Bill 32 on fuel price regulation, and Bill 30 on automobile insurance reform. Opposition members, including Mr. Grimes, Ms Thistle, Mr. Reid and Ms Jones, criticized all three, and the government used closure on Bill 26. Members also gave notice of private members' motions on public automobile insurance and on federal commitments.
Members' Statements
Member's statement congratulating Principal of the Year
Mr. Fitzgerald
Mr. Fitzgerald congratulated Maurice Lewis, principal of St. Mark's All Grade School in King's Cove, on being named the provincial Principal of the Year, citing his school and community work.
Speaker's notice of member's statements
Mr. Speaker
The Speaker announced two member's statements, from the Member for Port de Grave and the Member for Bonavista South, before question period began.
Routine Proceedings
Petition on closure of the Port aux Basques weigh scales
Mr. Parsons
Mr. Parsons presented a petition from residents of Southwestern Newfoundland opposing the closure of the weigh scales at Port aux Basques. He said the closure would cost jobs and allow commercial vehicles onto a highway in poor condition.
Question Period
Offshore oil and gas revenues under the Atlantic Accord
Premier Williams, Mr. Grimes, Mr. Harris, Mr. Speaker
The Premier said the Prime Minister had accepted the Province's proposal for 100 per cent of offshore revenues. The Opposition asked for the proposal to be tabled. The Premier said the NDP leader had committed to the 8.5 per cent Hibernia transfer, but the other federal leaders had not, and that the matter remained under negotiation.
Question on the appointment of new school board directors
Mr. Ottenheimer
Mr. Ottenheimer described the selection process for the transitional committee chairs and the directors designate, who were drawn from existing school boards. The Deputy Minister of Education and the Dean of Education at Memorial University took part in the interviews.
Rural Development Council and regional economic development boards
Ms Foote
Ms Foote said the Regional Economic Development Boards would not be reduced but questioned why the Minister had limited time to meet the Rural Development Council. She also asked why neither the Minister nor the Premier had attended its annual general meeting.
Question on public automobile insurance contingency planning
Asked by Mr. Harris · Answered by Mr. Speaker
Mr. Harris asked the Premier what form of public automobile insurance was being considered, whether implementation dates had been planned, and whether the Province was ready if three insurers left by year's end.
Orders of the Day
Bill 26, amendment to the Fishing Industry Collective Bargaining Act (shrimp auction)
Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Reid, Ms Jones, Mr. Parsons, Mr. Harris, Mr. Grimes, Mr. Taylor
The bill would enable the Minister of Fisheries to introduce an auction system for shrimp. Opposition members argued it could replace negotiated collective pricing and that the minister had not been clear whether the auction would be optional or mandatory. Mr. Harris's amendment adding a sunset clause was accepted, and the bill was reported with amendments and passed third reading.
Bill 32, amendment to the Petroleum Products Act (fuel price regulation)
Ms Whalen, Ms Thistle, Mr. Joyce, Mr. Collins, Mr. Grimes
The bill would move fuel price regulation from the Petroleum Products Pricing Commissioner to the Public Utilities Board. Ms Whalen said the Grand Falls-Windsor office and staff would be retained. The Opposition questioned the proclamation date, the removal of the commissioner, the handling of legal costs, and whether the PUB could absorb the work. The bill was reported without amendment.
Bill 30, automobile insurance reform
Ms Thistle, Mr. Butler, Mr. Joyce, Ms Jones, Mr. Wiseman, Mr. Collins, Mr. J. Byrne
The bill would reform automobile insurance, including a deductible approach and no cap on soft-tissue injuries, which Opposition members said broke an election commitment. Government members said it was a step toward public hearings. Opposition members also warned that insurers might leave the Province, and the bill was passed without amendment.
Closure motion on the sitting hours and the Standing Order 11 motion
Mr. Speaker, Ms Whalen, Mr. Reid
The Acting Government House Leader moved under Standing Order 11 that the House not adjourn at 10:00 p.m. that day. Mr. Reid said closure on Bill 26 limited the Opposition to one speech each, and that the government's numerical majority would pass the bill.
Private Members' Business
Private member's motion on a Select Committee on public automobile insurance
Mr. Harris
Mr. Harris gave notice that he would ask leave the next day to introduce a motion for a Select Committee to examine the most suitable form of public automobile insurance for the Province, citing insurers' announced departures and the need for a ready plan.
Private member's motion on federal commitments from party leaders
Mr. Grimes
Mr. Grimes gave notice of a private member's motion listing fourteen issues on which the Premier had sought commitments from federal party leaders. These included 100 per cent offshore revenues, transfer of the Hibernia share, equalization on a ten-province standard, health and social transfers, and fisheries management.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.