Hansard·Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly·Session 4, GA 45·

Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Wednesday 9 May 2007

The House sat on a Wednesday in May 2007 and heard members' statements honouring a Conception Bay South boy and two community groups, a ministerial statement on a skilled trades pilot, and a tribute to RNC Chief Joe Browne. Question Period was dominated by Opposition questions on the fibre optic deal, including the Premier's blind trust and a 2005 letter from Dean MacDonald, along with EI extensions and waste management. The main business was a private member's motion, moved by the Leader of the Opposition and seconded by Mr. Parsons, to establish an all-party committee to explore buying Fishery Products International; it was defeated on a recorded vote. The House then adjourned until Thursday.

Read the official Hansard ↗

Members' Statements

Members' statement honouring the St. Mary's All-Grade Wolves boys' basketball team

Ms Jones

Ms Jones congratulated the St. Mary's team on winning the inaugural Boys' Small School provincial championship, noting four girls on the roster and naming the players and coach. She also recognized a player named most sportsmanlike.

Members' statement on six-year-old Christan Critch's cancer fundraising

Ms E. Marshall

Ms E. Marshall recognized a six-year-old from Conception Bay South who asked to shave his head to support the Shave for the Brave campaign after hearing a cancer survivor speak at a hockey game.

Members' statement on the Glovertown Salvation Army's ninety-eighth anniversary

Mr. Oram

Mr. Oram congratulated the Glovertown Salvation Army Corps on its ninety-eighth anniversary and its community work, including support for the local food bank.

Ministerial statement on occupational health and safety training for skilled trades pilot teachers

Ms Burke, Mr. Butler

The Minister of Education reported that fifty pilot teachers received occupational health and safety training, funded at $30,000, and that the skilled trades pilot will expand to thirty-seven schools in September. Mr. Butler welcomed the statement and urged the government to create jobs so that graduates would not leave the province.

Ministerial statement on Chief Joe Browne receiving the Order of Merit of Police Forces

Mr. T. Osborne, Mr. Parsons

The Minister of Justice congratulated Royal Newfoundland Constabulary Chief Joe Browne on receiving the Order of Merit of Police Forces and outlined his career. Mr. Parsons, a former Justice Minister, praised Browne's professionalism and recalled promoting him in 2001.

Routine Proceedings

Resource Committee report on departmental Estimates

Mr. Harding

Mr. Harding reported that the Resource Committee had passed, without amendment, the Estimates for several departments, including Innovation, Trade and Rural Development and Natural Resources.

Question Period

Questions on the fibre optic deal: Premier's blind trust, the Persona letter and related e-mails

Mr. Reid, Mr. Rideout, Mr. Parsons, Mr. Taylor, Mr. Speaker

Mr. Reid asked whether the Premier's blind trustee was connected to the fibre optic deal, and Mr. Parsons pressed for a copy of a May 17, 2005 letter from Dean MacDonald to the Premier and for details of meetings with Allstream and others. The Minister of Innovation, Trade and Rural Development said the e-mail exists, that officials were seeking clarification of a Cabinet directive on consultation, and that the Premier had not interfered. The Speaker later ruled an expression used against the Opposition House Leader unparliamentary and asked the minister to withdraw it.

Questions on the communications concerns and mixed messaging about the fibre optic deal

Asked by Mr. Parsons · Answered by Mr. Taylor

Mr. Parsons quoted e-mails from the Premier's communications office and officials expressing concern about the justification for the project and the messaging used. The minister replied that senior communications staff routinely check facts with departments and pointed to outside groups that had called the infrastructure essential.

EI extension for residents affected by severe ice conditions

Asked by Mr. Reid · Answered by Mr. Rideout

Mr. Reid asked whether the government had forwarded information on affected workers to the federal minister to speed an EI extension. The Government House Leader said the matter had been raised with federal ministers and that he had not personally raised it at a recent meeting.

Waste management strategy and recycling funding

Ms Michael

Ms Michael asked the Minister of Municipal Affairs when the details of the waste management strategy would be known, what the other funding sources were, and why more money was not committed upfront so the plan would be in place before 2020. She also asked why recycling and composting were not funded provincially on a mandatory basis.

Private Members' Business

Private member's motion for an all-party committee to explore purchasing FPI

Mr. Reid, Ms Michael, Mr. Rideout, Ms Foote, Mr. Jackman, Ms Jones, Mr. Fitzgerald, Mr. Parsons

Opposition members argued that the province should explore buying Fishery Products International, citing its history, jobs and the government's record of equity investments, with the Crown corporation model raised as an option. Government members, including the Minister of Fisheries, opposed the motion, arguing that the FPI Act was designed for privatization and that an inquiry would delay a federal-led deal. The motion was put to a vote and lost.

This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.