Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Monday 14 May 2007
The House, sitting on May 14, 2007, heard members' statements on the opening of the Aur Resources Duck Pond mine, ministerial statements on forestry and Peace Officer Memorial Day, and a question period focused on a proposed $15 million provincial investment in Persona linked to a fibre optic cable deal. Routine business included committee reports, a Public Tender Act report and a notice of motion on resource revenues and equalization. The afternoon was mainly spent in the concurrence debate on Resource Committee estimates and in budget debate, where members including Ms Jones, Mr. Hutchings, Mr. Joyce, Ms Michael, Mr. O'Brien and Mr. Reid raised forestry, environmental, economic and patronage concerns. The House adjourned until the next day at 1:30 p.m.
Members' Statements
Congratulations on Aur Resources' Duck Pond mine opening
Ms Thistle
Ms Thistle congratulated Aur Resources on the official opening of its Duck Pond mine near Millertown, noting an investment of over $100 million, about 200 permanent jobs and that 95 per cent of employees are Newfoundlanders and Labradorians. She noted concentrate shipments had begun in April and were set to increase.
Labrador wood and forestry concept for Happy Valley-Goose Bay
Ms Jones
Ms Jones objected to a government plan to truck wood from the South Coast of Labrador to Happy Valley-Goose Bay for processing, arguing it would deny local communities economic opportunity. She said the consultation on the issue had been limited and had excluded the Labrador Metis Nation.
Routine Proceedings
Notice of private member's motion on non-renewable resource revenues and equalization
Mr. French
Mr. French gave notice of a private member's motion calling on all members to support the Premier in urging the Government of Canada to honour its commitment to remove non-renewable resource revenues from the equalization formula.
Social Services Committee report on estimates
Mr. Ridgley
Mr. Ridgley reported that the Social Services Committee had passed, without amendment, the estimates for six departments and agencies, including Education, Health and Community Services, Justice, Municipal Affairs, Human Resources, Labour and Employment, and the Newfoundland and Labrador Housing Corporation.
Tabling of Public Tender Act exceptions report
Mr. Speaker
The Speaker tabled the Report of Public Tender Act Exceptions covering November and December 2006 and January and February 2007.
Question Period
Question on Persona and Bragg negotiations and a $15 million provincial investment
Mr. Parsons, Mr. O'Brien, Mr. Rideout
Mr. Parsons asked the government to confirm whether negotiations between Bragg and Persona were ongoing while a deal was being negotiated for a $15 million provincial injection of taxpayers' money. Mr. O'Brien said he had no knowledge of the item referenced and would look into it and report back.
Orders of the Day
Concurrence debate on Resource Committee estimates
Mr. Harding, Mr. Hutchings, Mr. Joyce, Mr. Rideout
Mr. Harding opened the concurrence debate on estimates for six departments and the Rural Secretariat considered by the Resource Committee, noting a $145 million increase, and highlighted spending on business, exports, the Strategic Enterprise Development Fund and related programs. Mr. Rideout moved the concurrence and later moved to adjourn, with the debate set to conclude the next day.
Economic indicators and rural investment in Ferryland district
Mr. Hutchings
Mr. Hutchings cited 2006 economic indicators, including GDP growth of 1.9 per cent, retail sales of $6.1 billion, tourism and exploration gains, and listed funding for roads, infrastructure, tourism marketing and skills development in his district and rural Newfoundland and Labrador.
Sustainability of budget increases and Business Department job creation
Mr. Joyce
Mr. Joyce questioned how the government would sustain its budget increases, attributing oil revenues partly to accelerated production, and said road maintenance had declined despite higher spending. He also criticized the Business Department's record on job creation and grants, and raised allegations about nomination calls involving the Minister of Natural Resources.
Concurrence debate on general government sector and Rural Secretariat
Ms Michael, Mr. Rideout
Ms Michael, speaking to the concurrence on the general government sector, focused on the Rural Secretariat and argued that rural development needs funding for local, trained staff rather than more bureaucracy in St. John's. Mr. Rideout raised a procedural point about a voice vote held when a member was not in his seat.
Environmental concerns over Duck Pond tailings and oil and gas research
Ms Michael
Ms Michael criticized federal approval for mine tailings to be placed in Trout Pond, which feeds the Exploits River, and questioned the government's use of the precautionary principle in its sustainable development discussion paper. She also called for more research on the environmental effects of oil and gas exploration and for environmental concerns to be integrated into resource development.
Budget debate: Business Department and Business Attraction Fund
Mr. O'Brien
Mr. O'Brien reviewed the government's fiscal record since 2003 and described budget investments in health care, education and the removal of textbook costs. He outlined a $25 million strategic investment fund for loans and equity and a $7 million non-repayable grant fund to attract businesses.
Budget debate: tax reductions, surtax, and staff salaries
Mr. Reid, Mr. Oram
Mr. Reid criticized the budget's elimination of a surtax on incomes over $60,000, arguing it benefited MHAs and the Premier's staff more than low-income earners, and questioned raises in the Premier's office and the $25,000 parliamentary secretary stipends. Mr. Oram disputed the claims, saying the reduction applied to all income groups, including the Leader of the Opposition, and that he received no income from his businesses.
Other business
Ministerial statement on secondary processing report
Ms Michael
Ms Michael welcomed the minister's advance statement on secondary processing but said the report's appendices did not list those consulted, though it mentioned about eighty people or groups.
Peace Officer Memorial Day and police investment
Mr. Parsons
The Minister of Justice's statement noted continued investment in police forces to keep them up to date and marked Peace Officer Memorial Day on May 14 in remembrance of fallen officers.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.