Hansard·Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly·Session 4, GA 47·

Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Tuesday 28 April 2015

The House spent the day on question period, a series of statements and petitions, and two long sittings on Bill 1, the Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act, which would repeal the 2012 Bill 29. Opposition members pressed the Premier on privatizing long-term care in Corner Brook and other facilities, and on workers' compensation and firefighter cancer coverage. Bill 1 passed second reading and clause-by-clause review in Committee of the Whole, which carried all clauses and moved to report. Many members, including Ball, Premier Davis, Kent, Joyce, Rogers and Dempster, were named in the debate.

Read the official Hansard ↗

Question Period

Privatization of long-term care facilities

Mr. Ball, Premier Davis, Mr. Kent, Ms Michael, Ms C. Bennett

Mr. Ball asked why private operators would set long-term care costs for seniors and whether the contract with a British Columbia Crown corporation was awarded through an open process. The Premier and Mr. Kent said partnerships would build and operate 120 beds, including a facility in Corner Brook that would open a year earlier, and defended private partners; Ms Michael argued that quality of care declines when profit is involved.

Workers' compensation statutory review and workplace safety

Mr. Joyce, Mr. S. Collins, Premier Davis

Mr. Joyce raised the status of the workers' compensation statutory review. Minister Collins said the review has been largely completed, is now with government, and that a response is being prepared. The Premier marked National Day of Mourning and cited 2014 workplace death and disease figures.

Occupational cancers among firefighters

Mr. Murphy

Mr. Murphy began a question noting that occupational cancers among firefighters are covered by workers' compensation in other provinces but not in this one. The Speaker then called on the Minister of Child, Youth and Family Services, and no answer is recorded.

National Day of Mourning and workplace safety statistics

Premier Davis

The Premier noted April 28 as the National Day of Mourning, a wreath-laying he attended, and that lost-time injury claims are at their lowest recorded level for a third year. He said eleven workers died from accidents and eighteen from occupational disease in 2014, and described WHSCC and Service NL inspection and directive work.

Lions Club Speak Out winners recognized

Ms Perry

Ms Perry recognized the first-, second- and third-place winners of the 2015 Coast of Bays regional Lions Club Speak Out and thanked the Lions Club, teachers, parents and volunteers.

Measles, mumps and rubella vaccine and autism study

Mr. Kent

Mr. Kent said a study linking the MMR vaccine to autism had been discredited by a large US study, and he encouraged parents to consult the departmental website on vaccinations.

Land lease and electrical hookup problems on Coppermine Brook

Mr. Joyce

Mr. Joyce said residents on government-leased land cannot be connected to electricity and that letters from Service NL have been put on hold, citing a sewer problem. He pressed the Minister of Service NL to respond, and noted a land use advisory report commissioned five years earlier was still outstanding.

Orders of the Day

Motions on extending the sitting hours

Mr. Speaker

The Speaker put motions that the House not adjourn at 5:30 p.m. and then at 10:00 p.m. on the day, and the House agreed to sit into the evening. Mr. King later sought leave for a supper break and resumption at 7:00 p.m.

Bill 1 second reading: critique of Bill 29 and the 2012 process

Mr. Slade, Ms Rogers, Mr. Reid, Ms Dempster, Mr. Joyce, Mr. Cross

Opposition members argued that Bill 29 was secretive and undemocratic, cited Democracy Watch, Newspapers Canada and the Centre for Law and Democracy, and said public outcry and the filibuster forced the repeal. They also criticized the cost of the review and the government's handling of earlier reports; Mr. Cross described the Commission's expanded review of the whole Act.

Bill 1 second reading: government defence of the new legislation

Mr. Brazil, Mr. Russell, Mr. Crummell, Mr. Crocker, Mr. Lane, Mr. Hedderson

Government speakers said Bill 1 implements the Wells committee's recommendations, making the Province a leader in access and privacy law, with changes including reduced fees, protection of applicant identity and breach reporting. Mr. Lane said he had voted for Bill 29, and Mr. Hedderson urged an open debate and said implementation would show whether the bill was right.

Second reading of Bill 1 closed and passed

Mr. King, Mr. Speaker

The Government House Leader closed second reading on behalf of the responsible minister, and the Speaker put the question that Bill 1 be read a second time. It was carried by voice vote.

Bill 1 in Committee of the Whole: general debate and Wells committee report

Chair, Mr. Kirby, Mr. Kent, Mr. Mitchelmore, Mr. Reid

In Committee, Mr. Kirby questioned the government's reasons for the 2012 changes and the review cost, and called for documents on the advice received. Mr. Kent defended the review, the reduced fee schedule, and the reasons for the six-year Commissioner term and the changes to the public body definition, which Mr. Wells had clarified in a letter.

Bill 1 clause-by-clause: definitions, dataset and purpose clauses

Mr. Mitchelmore, Mr. Kent, Mr. Reid, Mr. Joyce

Mr. Mitchelm

Other business

Tabling of Orders-in-Council on funding pre-commitments

Mr. Wiseman

Mr. Wiseman tabled two Orders-in-Council under the Financial Administration Act relating to funding pre-commitments for 2015-2016 and 2017-2018.

Petition on Main Street East, Salmon Cove

Mr. Crocker

Mr. Crocker presented a petition asking government to make necessary repairs to Main Street East in Salmon Cove, and thanked the department for recent temporary work while calling for a permanent fix.

Petition on broadband service on the Labrador Coast

Ms Dempster

Ms Dempster presented a petition asking government to work with federal and provincial agencies to provide adequate broadband to communities in the Cartwright to L'Anse au Clair district and along the Labrador Coast.

Petition on two-worker minimum for late-night shifts

Ms Michael

Ms Michael presented a petition asking that legislation require either two workers on site or a secure barrier between worker and customer in hazardous workplaces such as late-night convenience and gas station shifts, between 10:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m.

Petition on rural snow clearing policy

Mr. Reid

Mr. Reid presented a petition asking government to review its rural snow clearing policy, which it had changed without consultation, and to set procedures for adding new roads. He said the petition began with a St. David's resident who had to clear a public road to reach his home.

This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.