Hansard·Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly·Session 4, GA 47·

Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Monday 4 May 2015

On May 4, 2015, the House opened with members' statements marking Mental Health Week and several local achievements, followed by question period dominated by the Budget 2015 tax increases (HST and tax on heat and light) and the cancelled Labrador ferry RFP. Ministers also announced health back-office consolidation and a Transportation and Works training program. The House then heard petitions on rural doctor shortages, pesticide use and policing in Conception Bay South, and began debate on the Budget Speech motion, with Ms C. Bennett opening for the Liberals before the House adjourned.

Read the official Hansard ↗

Members' Statements

Mental Health Week and community recognition

Ms Rogers, Mr. Kent

Ms Rogers commended the Community Coalition 4 Mental Health and a benefit concert for Waterford Hospital patients during Mental Health Week. Mr. Kent announced a $50,000 research grant to fund the BreathingRoom program for young people.

Tributes: minor hockey and Gros Morne tourism awards

Mr. Ball, Mr. J. Bennett

Mr. Ball congratulated Deer Lake Minor Hockey Association teams on provincial medals. Mr. J. Bennett congratulated the Gros Morne Magic and Gros Morne Online Campaign on winning gold at the 2014 Adrian Awards.

Routine Proceedings

Health back-office consolidation and staffing cuts

Mr. Kent, Mr. Speaker

The Health Minister announced consolidation of back-office functions across the four regional health authorities and the Centre for Health Information, with estimated savings of $18 to $26 million over five years. He said 180 to 230 full-time equivalent positions would be eliminated mainly through attrition.

Public service supervisor training and road standards

Mr. Brazil, Mr. Osborne

The Transportation and Works Minister announced a four-day training program for department supervisors on safety and consistency. Mr. Osborne welcomed it but said road standards, given highway ruts and hydroplaning, also needed review.

Petition on doctor shortage in Heatherton to Highlands

Mr. Reid

Mr. Reid presented a petition from residents of the Heatherton to Highlands area asking government to restore a permanent doctor or other health care arrangements at the Jeffrey's clinic. He said the area has been without a permanent doctor for nearly a year and a half.

Petition on Tordon 101 herbicide use

Mr. Murphy

Mr. Murphy presented a petition asking government to stop using Tordon 101, which he said contains Picloram and 2,4-D, for brush clearing and to adopt safer methods. He noted signatories from St. John's, Paradise, and other areas.

Petition on policing levels in Conception Bay South

Mr. Hillier

Mr. Hillier presented a second petition asking government to review and increase police services in Conception Bay South, citing traffic speeds, pedestrian safety and visibility of police. He said the concern was not with the work of RNC officers.

Question Period

Budget 2015: HST increase and fairness of tax regime

Ms Michael

Ms Michael asked the Premier why the regressive HST was being raised now, when lowering it was not accepted in good times. She also questioned the rationale for a tax system she said burdened lower and middle-income earners while easing taxes for high earners.

Budget 2015: first-time homebuyers and the HST

Asked by Mr. Ball · Answered by Mr. Wiseman

Mr. Ball asked whether the government agreed that the HST increase makes it harder for first-time homebuyers. The Minister of Finance responded that a balanced approach was needed and that unbalanced borrowing or cuts would be worse.

Muskrat Falls investment and return

Mr. Wiseman

The Finance Minister argued that the Muskrat Falls investment, about $3 billion over ten years, would be recovered within eight years and would yield substantial returns afterward. He was responding to opposition criticism of borrowing.

Cancelled Labrador ferry RFP

Mr. Ball, Mr. Brazil, Mr. Hutchings

Mr. Ball asked when the decision to cancel the Labrador marine service RFP was made, given the minister's April 22 statements. The Transportation and Works Minister said costs exceeded the budget, so the government would work with Labrador residents and return to market later. He also described the new vessels contracted with Damen Shipyards and a federal tariff dispute.

Tax on heat and light reinstated

Mr. Murphy

Mr. Murphy asked why the government reinstated the tax on heat and light, which he said was promised to be dropped in the 2012 Budget. He also raised concerns about rising gas and diesel prices and their effect on consumers.

Corner Brook hospital funding

Mr. Joyce

Mr. Joyce asked the Health Minister what the $9.6 million budgeted for the Corner Brook hospital would be used for this year. The minister's answer is not recorded in the transcript.

Orders of the Day

Budget Speech debate (Motion 1)

Mr. King, Ms C. Bennett

The Government House Leader called Motion 1 to approve in general the government's budgetary policy. Ms C. Bennett opened the Liberal response, criticizing deficits, debt, ministerial turnover, consultant spending, the Corner Brook hospital, and education and full-day Kindergarten, and calling for better economic management.

Other business

Adjournment and Social Services Committee notice

Mr. King

The Government House Leader noted that the Social Services Committee would meet that afternoon at 6:00 p.m. to review the Estimates of the Department of Seniors, Wellness and Social Development. He then moved that the House adjourn, and the motion carried.

This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.