Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Wednesday 16 March 2016
The House opened on March 16, 2016 with Members' statements and Question Period, where the Opposition pressed the government on the Central Health management review, school board elections, the handling of budget savings, a fishing processing licence transfer, and adult literacy. The main business of the day was a private Member's resolution from Mr. Reid (St. George's-Humber) calling for a legacy fund from non-renewable resource revenues. An amendment moved by Mr. Hutchings was ruled out of order, and the resolution was passed on a recorded vote of 29 ayes to 7 nays, though Opposition speakers said they would not support it. Ministers Kirby, Byrne, Haggie and Premier Ball answered most of the questions.
Members' Statements
Ministerial statement on Check Registration Day and fraud prevention
Mr. Joyce, Ms. Michael
Mr. Joyce marked Check Registration Day, urging consumers to check the registration of businesses and individuals before dealing with them, and pointed to Service NL resources. Ms. Michael welcomed the initiative but called for an office of the seniors advocate to address fraud against seniors, a promise she urged the government to keep.
Statement on National Nutrition Month and Dietitians Day
Ms. Perry
Ms. Perry marked National Nutrition Month and Dietitians Day, citing the cost and availability of healthy food, and listed government-supported programs such as Eat Great and Participate, Rec NL initiatives, the School Milk Foundation and Kids Eat Smart. She thanked registered dietitians.
Canadian Agricultural Safety Week statement
Mr. Mitchelmore, Ms. Michael
Mr. Mitchelmore marked Canadian Agricultural Safety Week (March 13 to 19) and the Be an AgSafe Family campaign, which received Growing Forward 2 funding. Ms. Michael noted the deaths of farm children and asked how the provincial farm federation would take part.
Members' statement on the Morgan family Gutsy Walk
Ms. P. Parsons
Ms. Parsons recognized the Morgan family of Port de Grave for organizing the Gutsy Walk for Crohn's and Colitis Canada in memory of their son Lloyd, and said the family had raised more than $65,000.
Members' statement on Lions Club public speaking competition
Mr. Reid
Mr. Reid congratulated the students who took part in the Lions Club Speak-off in Pasadena, named the winners, and thanked the Lions Club and its volunteers.
Question Period
Budget savings and disclosure of details on ministerial office spending
Asked by Ms. C. Bennett · Answered by Mr. P. Davis
Mr. Davis asked why the Finance Minister had reversed her earlier commitment to provide details of about $100 million in budget savings, including which ministerial offices had extra political staff. Ms. Bennett said the details would be disclosed through the year-end and Estimates process and the budget, and listed the sources of savings such as discontinued reallocations, unpaid parliamentary secretaries, eliminated political staff, and hiring and travel freezes.
Central Health management and the Bhatia diagnostic imaging review
Mr. Haggie, Mr. Kent, Mr. Joyce
Mr. Kent called for a full review of management at Central Health and asked why the 18 recommendations of the Bhatia report on diagnostic imaging had not all been implemented. Mr. Haggie said the chair of the board was holding confidential meetings with physicians and management, and said the recommendations he cited had been completed. Mr. Kent also asked whether the four regional health authorities were to be amalgamated, and Mr. Haggie disputed any patient safety problem.
School board elections timing and legislation
Mr. Brazil, Mr. Kirby, Mr. Speaker
Mr. Brazil said the Education Minister had moved school board elections back to at least a year away, and asked about a contradiction with his earlier stance on governance. Mr. Kirby said the government had committed to an election within 12 months, that consultations were under way, and that legislation would be needed to change how francophone and anglophone board elections are run. He also said the trustees, not the minister, hold legal responsibility for running the school system.
Royal Greenland and the transfer of a processing licence from Quin-Sea
Asked by Mr. K. Parsons · Answered by Premier Ball
Mr. Parsons asked whether subsidies to state-owned European fishing companies such as Royal Greenland gave it an advantage, and whether local companies would be disadvantaged. Premier Ball said the processing licence transfer from Quin-Sea had involved due diligence, that Royal Greenland planned to invest in the province, and that the harvesting sector would not be affected. He challenged Opposition Members to produce any evidence of controlling agreements.
Privatization of adult literacy (ABE) and its contract review
Asked by Ms. Michael · Answered by Mr. Byrne
Ms. Michael asked whether the government would review the impact of privatizing Adult Basic Education before the first contract expires. Minister Byrne said the contract expires in 2016, that a full review is under way alongside an adult literacy strategy, and that the process used by the previous administration in implementing privatization had been questioned.
Holy Cross school concerns raised by parents
Asked by Ms. Rogers · Answered by Mr. Kirby
Ms. Rogers said dozens of Holy Cross parents had written to the Education Minister and asked what he was telling them. Mr. Kirby said he was not closing any schools, that trustees hold legal responsibility for school decisions, and that concerns about trustees should be directed to them.
Enhanced home care pilot project
Mr. Haggie
Mr. Haggie said the enhanced home care project had reduced demand in pilot sites in Gander, St. John's and Corner Brook, and that the government aimed to seek funding in the coming budget to continue it.
Private Members' Business
Private Member's resolution on a legacy fund for non-renewable resource revenues
Mr. Reid, Mr. Hutchings, Madam Speaker, Ms. C. Bennett, Mr. Brazil, Ms. Coady, Ms. Michael
Mr. Reid moved a resolution supporting a legacy fund modelled partly on Norway's sovereign wealth fund, citing the Auditor General's 2012 warnings about oil dependence. Mr. Hutchings moved amendments to remove criticism of the previous government and to tie the fund to a return to surplus; the Chair ruled them out of order because they imposed a condition. Finance Minister Bennett said the government would enshrine a legacy fund in legislation, Mr. Brazil said his party could not support it now, Ms. Coady discussed models from Norway and Alberta, and Ms. Michael said she would vote for it while doubting it could happen soon. The resolution passed on a recorded vote, reported as 29 ayes and 7 nays.
Other business
Visitors recognized in the galleries
Mr. Speaker
The Speaker welcomed Sean Lyall, Minister of Culture, Recreation and Tourism with the Nunatsiavut Government; Mayor Juanita Stone and councillor Bob Stone of Red Bay; representatives of the Dietitians of Newfoundland and Labrador; and others in the galleries.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.