Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Monday 21 March 2016
On the afternoon of March 21, 2016, the House marked Purple Day for epilepsy in members' statements, then pressed the new government in Question Period on provincial borrowing, equalization and the Stabilization Program, the CETA, the Nalcor equity return and electricity rates. The main business was second reading of Bill 1, the Independent Appointments Commission bill, where opposition members argued it left appointments largely in Cabinet's hands and the government defended its merit-based approach. Members also presented a petition on Holy Cross Junior High before the House adjourned until the next day. The sitting record is partial, as only every third turn is shown.
Members' Statements
Purple Day for epilepsy awareness
Mr. Haggie, Mr. P. Davis, Ms. Michael
Mr. Haggie marked Purple Day on March 26 and noted that roughly 10,000 Newfoundlanders and Labradorians live with epilepsy. Mr. P. Davis and Ms. Michael both welcomed the statement and encouraged public awareness of the condition.
Routine Proceedings
Holy Cross Junior High petition
Ms. Rogers
Ms. Rogers presented a petition asking government to keep Holy Cross Junior High open and to arrange a democratically elected English School Board. She argued the appointed trustees' decision lacked accountability and that many students have exceptionalities.
Notices of motion and private member's resolution scheduling
Mr. Hutchings
Mr. Hutchings gave notice under Standing Order 63 that the private member's resolution from the Member for Fortune Bay – Cape La Hune would be debated the following day or Wednesday.
Question Period
Bill 1 oath of impartiality for commissioners
Asked by Mr. Kent · Answered by Premier Ball
Mr. Kent asked whether the government would amend Bill 1 so appointments commissioners must swear an oath or affirmation of impartiality. The Premier replied that the matter would be brought to the floor of the House.
Provincial borrowing and legislative authority
Ms. C. Bennett, Mr. P. Davis, Premier Ball
Ms. C. Bennett reported about $1.985 billion secured through borrowing since December, excluding Treasury bills. Mr. P. Davis asked what legislative authority or special warrant was used, and whether the borrowing would be tabled before Easter. Ms. Bennett said an order-in-council, not a special warrant, was issued, and the Premier blamed the previous administration for the inherited Treasury bill debt.
Bill 9 timing
Mr. P. Davis
Mr. P. Davis asked when Bill 9 would be introduced and how much time the opposition would have to debate it. The question was raised but the transcript shows no clear answer.
Equalization and Stabilization Program funding
Asked by Mr. Hutchings · Answered by Premier Ball
Mr. Hutchings asked whether the province accepted an approximately $32 million Stabilization offset against an $18 billion equalization program, and whether the Premier had pursued modernizing the formula. The Premier pointed to a federal agreement on repaying equalization identified in 2005 and said the previous government had committed to repayments of over $20 million a year.
Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) position
Asked by Mr. Hutchings · Answered by Premier Ball
Mr. Hutchings asked whether the Premier was withdrawing support for CETA and what was being renegotiated. The Premier said the government was committed to working with Ottawa and the fishery, but would not publicly lay out negotiating positions.
Nalcor equity return and Muskrat Falls cost overruns
Asked by Ms. Michael · Answered by Premier Ball
Ms. Michael asked for the current projection of when the province will receive a return on its Nalcor equity, given further Muskrat Falls cost overruns. The Premier said that is driven by the PUB process and cannot be determined today, and that the government would work to get the project back on track.
Electricity rates and support for low-income residents
Asked by Ms. Rogers · Answered by Premier Ball
Ms. Rogers asked what concrete help would be given to seniors and others who cannot afford expected electricity rate increases. The Premier said government would support lower-income residents but rates after Muskrat Falls could not be determined yet.
Orders of the Day
Bill 1, Independent Appointments Commission Act, second reading
Mr. Brazil, Ms. Coady, Ms. Rogers, Mr. K. Parsons, Mr. Joyce, Mr. Haggie, Ms. Perry, Mr. Byrne
The bill was moved for second reading and debated at length. Opposition members argued that Cabinet retains control over appointments, that about 74 entities bypass the commission, that recommendations need not be followed, and that the bill lacks a diversity or gender lens and proper accountability. Government members defended the merit-based process, the Public Service Commission's role, and the bill's consistency with the Liberal platform, and Ms. Coady described the skills-matrix approach.
Bill 1 diversity and inclusivity, gender lens
Ms. Rogers
Ms. Rogers said the bill should include a commitment to a diversity policy, noting few women in the House and among board chairs and CEOs. She said the Public Service Commission had declined to apply a gender lens when asked at the technical briefing.
Other business
Adjournment of the House
Mr. A. Parsons
Mr. A. Parsons moved, seconded by the Member for Exploits, that the House adjourn given the hour. The motion carried, and the House stood adjourned until 1:30 p.m. the following day.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.