Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Tuesday 19 April 2016
The House, on April 19, 2016, was dominated by debate on the new government's 2016 budget, including the Opposition's amendment moved by Leader of the Opposition P. Davis and the Deficit Reduction Levy. Question Period covered the closure of long-term care beds at Masonic Park, the cancellation of the Coley's Point school, and blind trust rules, with Premier Ball, Health Minister Haggie and Education Minister Kirby answering. Members' statements honoured a Ladle Cove family's war sacrifices, local festivals and volunteers, and petitions were presented on the levy, food security and Marine Atlantic ferry rates. The transcript is a partial, OCR-digitised extract, so some speakers and exchanges are incomplete.
Members' Statements
Ministerial statement on the Beaumont-Hamel First World War commemoration
Ms. Michael
Ms. Michael responded to the minister's statement on the Commemoration of the First World War and the Battle of Beaumont-Hamel, thanking him for the advance copy and reflecting on the price of past conflicts and Canada's commitment to peace.
Members' statement on the Goodyear family's war service
Mr. Trimper
Trimper recognized the Goodyear family of Ladle Cove, whose seven children served or were affected in the First World War, with two sons killed and another memorialized, and asked Members to recognize their sacrifice.
Members' statement on Frosty Festival 2016
Mr. Lane
Lane congratulated the City of Mount Pearl, the festival board, sponsors and volunteers on the 34th annual Frosty Festival, listing its activities.
Members' statement on the Shane Mercer Memorial Fishing Derby
Mr. Letto
Letto recognized Mark and Joanne Lush for organizing the fifth annual derby in Wabush, which raised $3,200 for the local chapter of Mothers Against Drunk Driving.
Members' statement on the Manning Awards
Ms. Michael
Ms. Michael congratulated Paul Rowe and the Basilica Heritage Foundation
Routine Proceedings
Petition on the Deficit Reduction Levy
Ms. Michael
Ms. Michael presented a petition calling for the Deficit Reduction Levy to be eliminated, with any replacement based on progressive taxation, and for an independent review of the provincial income tax system.
Petition on food security
Mr. Kent
Kent presented a petition asking the government to set targets for improving food security by growing more of the food consumed in the province. He linked the matter to fuel tax increases and the removal of the Air Foodlift Subsidy.
Petition on Marine Atlantic ferry rates
Mr. Petten
Petten presented a petition urging the province's federal Members of Parliament and the federal government to reduce Marine Atlantic ferry rates, arguing the increases would hurt tourism and grocery prices, alongside the new gasoline tax.
Question Period
Masonic Park long-term care facility and bed closures
Mr. Kent, Mr. Haggie, Premier Ball
Kent asked the Health Minister for data showing Masonic Park was in disrepair and how moving residents would save $1.5 million, and asked the Premier to justify closing 50 long-term care beds. Haggie said residents would move to new beds at the Veterans Pavilion, that alternatives would be considered with families, and that the vacant beds would be used. Premier Ball said no provincial funding was going to the Sundara site and that the facility was not connected to Eastern Health's decisions.
Coley's Point school replacement cancelled
Asked by Mr. Brazil · Answered by Mr. Kirby
Brazil asked why the Coley's Point school was cut, noting the former minister had argued for a new school. Kirby said the deficit had grown from $1.1 billion to $2.7 billion, so funds were not available this year, and that officials were looking for an interim solution with the English school district.
Premier's business interests and blind trust rules
Asked by Ms. Michael · Answered by Premier Ball
Ms. Michael asked whether the Premier believed current conflict of interest rules were tough enough, given he did not yet have a blind trust. Premier Ball said that declaring business and personal interests and setting up blind trusts is the responsibility of each Member under the conflict of interest rules.
Budget's effect on hope and rural communities
Asked by P. Davis · Answered by Premier Ball
Davis asked how the budget, including the gas tax and higher food costs, provides a stronger tomorrow and what the plan is for rural Newfoundland and Labrador. Premier Ball responded by citing the previous administration's record on economic diversification and said the government was starting work to get the province back on track.
Orders of the Day
Opposition amendment to the 2016 budget debate
P. Davis, Madam Speaker, Hawkins, Holloway
Mr. P. Davis moved an amendment that would replace the motion's wording with a statement deploring the government's failure to deal with the province's real problems and to provide competent management. The Speaker ruled the amendment in order. Davis argued the budget cuts spending on business, raises taxes on lower and middle incomes, and risks driving people out of the province, while the Government House Leader and Mr. Holloway defended the budget as consultative and necessary to address the deficit.
Deficit Reduction Levy and tax burden
P. Davis, Hawkins
Davis said the levy falls hardest on lower- and middle-income families, that it will bring little revenue this year because it is collected later, and that it adds to the HST increase. Hawkins said the budget was not a popularity contest and that the government was correcting problems and charting a course for the future.
Bill 24 first reading and second reading timing
Mr. Speaker, Hawkins
Bill 24 was read a first time, and the Speaker asked when it would be read a second time. The Government House Leader responded in the course of the budget-related debate.
Budget highlights: debt service, highways, ferries and vessel refits
Hawkins
Hawkins said debt servicing at $988 million exceeds education spending and that the budget contains positives. He cited about $23 million for the Team Gushue Highway, $63.7 million to leverage federal funding for Trans-Labrador Highway Phases 2 and 3, and $13 million for vessel refits, and said he would press Damen on ferry service to Fogo Island and Change Islands.
Historical comparison of past budgets and deferred capital projects
P. Davis
Davis compared the current budget with 1990s budget experience and the oil price collapse, and criticized the deferral of projects including the Springdale-Green Bay health centre, Gander Academy, Grand Falls-Windsor, Coley's Point and Riverside Elementary.
Cuts to student and apprenticeship programs and fee increases
P. Davis
Davis criticized savings measures including eliminating apprenticeship scholarships, changes to post-secondary disability training, and new fees for apprenticeship exams and applications, calling them small cuts that hit families.
Government's budget defence and consultation process
Holloway
Holloway said the government had engaged the public through 26 sessions, over 1,000 participants, and hundreds of submissions, and that the advice received led to action on efficiencies and revenue. He also criticized the previous administration's spending on a Terra Nova bridge deck and a fire truck without a fire hall.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.