Newfoundland and Labrador House of Assembly, Thursday 21 April 2016
The House sat on April 21, 2016, in the first days after Budget 2016. Members made statements on local achievements, a Queen's 90th birthday tribute, and a reading of First World War war dead. Question Period focused on closing long-term care beds at Masonic Park Nursing Home, the closure of Whitbourne Elementary, and Nalcor's leadership change after the Finance Minister's remarks, with the Premier defending the new CEO appointment. Several members presented petitions against the Deficit Reduction Levy, and government and opposition MHAs debated the budget's taxes, fees, cuts and municipal and education measures.
Members' Statements
Queen Elizabeth II's 90th birthday
Premier Ball, Mr. P. Davis
Premier Ball marked the Queen's 90th birthday, citing her visits to the province and royal designations for the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary and the Royal St. John's Regatta. Mr. P. Davis, on behalf of the Opposition, joined in the birthday wishes.
Recognition of Goward Heath's service and 100th birthday
Mr. D. Bennett
Mr. D. Bennett honoured Goward Heath of Fogo Island, a Second World War veteran and longtime Royal Canadian Legion executive, who turned 100 in October 2015.
Youth Ventures Award recipients
Ms. Perry
Ms. Perry congratulated Nicole Whittle and Eemaan Thind of Harbour Breton on receiving Youth Ventures Awards at the 2015 provincial awards.
Winterfest in Conception Bay South
Mr. Petten
Mr. Petten congratulated the organizers, sponsors and volunteers of Winterfest 2016 in Conception Bay South, which he said drew record turnout at events such as the pancake breakfast.
Viking site discovery at Point Rosie
Mr. Reid
Mr. Reid recognized archaeologist Sarah Pareak's work on a possible second Viking site at Point Rosie in the Codroy Valley, supported by radiocarbon dating, and wished the investigators well.
Amelia Curran's ECMA awards and mental health initiative
Ms. Rogers
Ms. Rogers announced that singer-songwriter Amelia Curran won two ECMAs and praised her mental health initiative, It's Mental, and her documentary project.
Dorset Collegiate Table Tennis Club achievements
Mr. Warr
Mr. Warr congratulated the Dorset Collegiate Table Tennis Club on its provincial, regional and national successes since its founding in 1992.
Reading of First World War casualty names
Mr. Crocker
Mr. Crocker read into the record 40 names of Newfoundlanders who died in the First World War, followed by a moment of silence.
Routine Proceedings
Deficit Reduction Levy petitions
Ms. Rogers, Mr. K. Parsons, Ms. Michael, Ms. Perry
Members presented petitions calling for the Deficit Reduction Levy to be eliminated or stopped, arguing it is regressive and unfair to middle- and low-income earners, and asking for an independent review of the provincial income tax system. Ms. Perry separately urged the health minister to reverse budget measures, including one affecting breast cancer screening for women under 50.
Question Period
Masonic Park Nursing Home closure and long-term care beds
Asked by Mr. Kent · Answered by Mr. Haggie
Mr. Kent questioned the closure of Masonic Park Nursing Home and the number of long-term care beds available at Veterans Pavilion, and asked for the cost-savings information to be tabled. Health Minister Haggie disputed the figures, said the transition plan would provide 35 beds at Veterans Pavilion, and offered to discuss the finances with Mr. Kent privately rather than table them.
Nalcor leadership change and Muskrat Falls EY review
Asked by Ms. Michael · Answered by Premier Ball
Ms. Michael asked why government did not manage an orderly transition at Nalcor and why the EY review did not analyse continuing with Muskrat Falls. Premier Ball said the Nalcor CEO had decided to step down after meetings with him, and that government had quickly appointed a new CEO with experience to stabilize the corporation.
Closure of Whitbourne Elementary school
Asked by Mr. Brazil · Answered by Mr. Kirby
Mr. Brazil asked the Education Minister why he now supported closing the Whitbourne school after earlier petitioning to keep it open. Mr. Kirby said the school board trustees made the decision to use public funds efficiently, that appeal processes exist, and that the decision would not be revisited in the House.
Orders of the Day
Budget 2016 debate: taxes, levy and fiscal record
Mr. Kent, Ms. C. Bennett, Ms. Rogers, Mr. Letto, Mr. K. Parsons, Mr. Petten
Opposition members criticized the budget's levy, fee increases and cuts, including dental and health measures, and argued for alternatives. Government members defended the budget as necessary to address a $2.7 billion deficit, pointed to past tax reductions and the Newfoundland Income Supplement, and listed government spending and municipal supports. Ms. C. Bennett and Ms. Rogers exchanged accusations about the previous and current administrations' tax records.
Budget 2016 debate: education and full-day kindergarten
Mr. Kirby, Mr. Kent, Mr. Petten
The Education Minister described declining enrolment, the redeployment of 27 positions to inclusive education, and the continuation of building a St. Peter's Primary extension in Mount Pearl. He defended the full-day kindergarten program against calls to postpone it. Mr. Petten also spoke on the budget's effects on families and listed government spending.
Municipal funding and Labrador budget measures
Mr. Letto, Mr. K. Parsons
Mr. Letto outlined the Community Sustainability Partnership, a $22 million fund and a 10 cent fuel rebate for border communities, saying over $38 million would go to municipalities this year. He also addressed the planned Wabush court changes, the L'Anse au Clair town hall loss, and iron ore prices. Mr. K. Parsons welcomed municipal supports while arguing the levy hurts families and small businesses.
This is Tabled's summary of the sitting, written from the official record; Hansard is only ever quoted at the link above. Read this sitting in the archive for the words themselves.